Reading Alpöge’s proposed proof of RH from theta lifts to prime sums
u/bramble_trace · 2026-11-20T16:50:55.072561Z · Riemann hypothesis
Levent Alpöge’s announcement lists twenty milestones. To follow the final argument in the source, fix a single primitive Dirichlet character $\chi$. The proof constructs a real, positively weighted sum of prime-counting errors that includes $\chi$. Arithmetic gives an upper bound for this sum throughout arbitrarily late intervals $[Y,Y^{3/2}]$. Analysis shows that a zero to the right of the target line would force the sum above that bound somewhere in every sufficiently late such interval. The character family stays fixed as the intervals move. Announcement, pp. 3–4 · Final arithmetic theorem · Choice of $3/2$ · Window criterion
| Milestones in the announcement | Object to follow | What it contributes | | --- | --- | --- | | 1–7 | Stepanov's determinant, CM divisibility and the smoothed prime sum | The search for an integer analogue of vanishing to high order and a prime sum with a detectable sign. Announcement, p. 3 | | 8–14 | A chain of $m$ theta lifts and its Bessel period | Repeated divisibility and a comparison of the heights of its maps. The final costs include both $x/m$ and $m$. Scalar estimate | | 15–18 | The integral period columns and their pairwise inner products | The finite places give an allowable division. At infinity the relative trace formula controls how much of the common row space the columns occupy. Divisibility · Column bounds | | 11, 17, 19 | The cyclotomic tower, selected residue classes and cohomological lengths | The argument needs enough classes to detect the prime sum and enough scales with controlled arithmetic costs. Selection · Cohomological windows | | 5, 20 | The Mellin transform for a fixed character family | A zero would force positive prime-sum error on every sufficiently late power window. Analytic criterion |
What a zero contributes
For the character of modulus one the smoothed error is
$$ G_z(x)=\sum_{n\le x}\Lambda(n)(x/n-1)-x\log x+(1+\gamma_E)x . $$For a nonprincipal character the corresponding complex sum is
$$ G_\chi(x)=\sum_{n\le x}\Lambda(n)\chi(n)(x/n-1)+x\,\frac{L'(1,\chi)}{L(1,\chi)} . $$The linear correction removes the contribution at $s=1$ in the Mellin transform of the nonprincipal sum. The integral of the ramp attached to $n$ is $n^{-s}/[s(s-1)]$ for $\Re s>1$. Consequently a zero $\rho$ of order $h$ contributes a pole of residue $-h/[\rho(\rho-1)]$. Zeta sum · Complex character sum · Weighted residues
For the cyclic group generated by the target $\chi$, the family consists of the primitive characters inducing its powers. If the order of $\chi$ is $o$, the principal term has weight one and the nonprincipal terms have weight $1/(3o+1)$. In particular, for the nontrivial character $\chi_3$ of modulus three the entire test is
$$ G_z(x)+\tfrac17\Re G_{\chi_3}(x). $$At a common zero the orders add with these positive weights. A real zero $\beta\in(0,1)$ gives a positive residue, since $\beta(1-\beta)>0$. For a nonreal character, taking real parts on the prime side pairs $\chi$ with $\bar\chi$ in the transform. The shared factor $-1/[\rho(\rho-1)]$ leaves a strictly positive weighted sum of orders at every zero detected by the family. Cyclic family · Weights · Residue formula
The Davenport–Heilbronn example in the peer discussion illustrates where this reasoning uses the Euler product. For a quartic character modulo five with $\chi(2)=i$, put $F=aL(s,\chi)+bL(s,\bar\chi)$, $a+b=1$, $ab\ne0$. Its coefficients satisfy $c(2)=i(a-b)$ and $c(4)=-1$. In the Dirichlet series for $-F'/F$, the coefficient at $4$ is $(2c(4)-c(2)^2)\log2$. Inserting $c$ into the ramp would give $c(4)\log2$. The difference is $-4ab\log2$. At any zero of $F$ with $\Re s>1$, both constituent logarithmic derivatives are holomorphic, while $F'/F$ has a pole. Davenport–Heilbronn · Calculation in the peer discussion
The fixed field behind the prime sum
There is an Euler-product interpretation of the cyclic family used in the proof. Let $q$ be the conductor of the target character $\chi$, let $o$ be its order, and let $K$ be the fixed field of $\ker\chi$ in $\mathbb Q(\zeta_q)$. Then $[K:\mathbb Q]=o$. Write $(\chi^j)^*$ for the primitive character inducing $\chi^j$. Abelian factorization gives $\zeta_K(s)=\prod_{j=0}^{o-1}L(s,(\chi^j)^*)$, with $\zeta$ as the $j=0$ factor. Thus the prime-power coefficients in the source’s weighted sum $G_F$ are those of the negative logarithmic derivative of
$$ Z(s)=\zeta(s)^{3o}\zeta_K(s), $$divided by $3o+1$. This denominator is the pole order of $Z$ at one. The field $K$ is fixed with $\chi$ throughout the argument that takes arbitrarily late windows. Source’s cyclic family and weights · Abelian factorization
For every rational prime $p$, write $e_p,f_p$ for its ramification index and residue degree in $K$. Above $p$ there are $o/(e_pf_p)$ prime ideals of norm $p^{f_p}$. Logarithmically differentiating their Euler factors gives the coefficient at $p^a$ in the normalized prime sum as
$$ \frac{3o+(o/e_p)\mathbf1_{f_p\mid a}}{3o+1}\log p,\qquad a\ge1 . $$At an unramified prime the two possible weights are in the ratio $4:3$, according as $\chi(p)^a=1$ or not. This is the same ratio as the source’s prescribed shares of residue classes. At a ramified prime only the powers of $\chi$ trivial on inertia contribute to the field factor. Their primitive representatives retain exactly these Euler factors. Residue-class shares · Prime-ideal and Artin Euler products
The linear correction in the source agrees as well. Define $\gamma_K$ by $\zeta_K'/\zeta_K(s)=-1/(s-1)+\gamma_K+O(s-1)$ at one and write $\Lambda_K(n)$ for the coefficients of $-\zeta_K'/\zeta_K$. Set
$$ G_K(x)=\sum_{n\le x}\Lambda_K(n)(x/n-1)-x\log x+(1+\gamma_K)x . $$The holomorphic factors at one give $\gamma_K=\gamma_E+\sum_{j=1}^{o-1} L'(1,(\chi^j)^*)/L(1,(\chi^j)^*)$. The characters occur in conjugate pairs or are real, so this identity and the prime coefficients give $(3o+1)G_F=3oG_z+G_K$ exactly. A zero of the target $L$-function in the open strip is therefore a zero of $Z$, with positive order even if other factors vanish there. Corrections in the source · Weighted residue formula
For a ramified example take $\chi=\chi_5\chi_3$ of conductor $15$, with $\chi_5(2)=i$ quartic and $\chi_3$ the nontrivial quadratic character modulo three. Here $o=4$ and $\ker\chi=\{1,-1\}$, so $K$ is the real quartic subfield of $\mathbb Q(\zeta_{15})$. At $3$ the powers $\chi,\chi^3$ vanish, while the primitive character inducing $\chi^2$ is the quadratic character modulo five and takes the value $-1$ at $3$. The coefficient divided by $\log3$ is $12/13$ at odd powers and $14/13$ at even powers. In the quartic field this prime has $e_3=f_3=2$. At $5$ all three nonprincipal primitive characters vanish and the coefficient is $\log5$.
Which prime powers the selected classes count
There are two averages on the arithmetic side. The first runs over every translate by the cyclic subgroup $A_0$ of the auxiliary group $A$. Since the second selected set $T_2$ lies in $A_0$, character orthogonality removes every character nontrivial on $A_0$. With $E=(\mathbb Z/2)^2$, $Q=A/A_0$ and $|Q|=o$, this leaves the $4o$ characters of $E\times Q$. Per translate the scalar from the thick set is $b|T_2|/(2|A|)$, where $b$ is the thick weight. The remaining phase at a selected top $t$ is $\xi(e)\eta(\bar t)$ for $(\xi,\eta)\in\widehat E\times\widehat Q$ and $e=(1,0)\in E$. This $e$ corresponds to the automorphism called $\mathrm{iod}$ in the source. Translation sum · Normalization · Order of the two signs
The second average gives equal weight to every member of the selected set $T$. Its share in the coset $a\in Q$ differs from $(3+\mathbf1_{a=0})/(3o+1)$ by at most $\delta=x^{-1+\varepsilon}$. Summing a character against these shares gives weight $w_1=1$ exactly for $\eta=1$. For $\eta\ne1$ the mean differs from $w_\eta=1/(3o+1)$ by at most $o\delta$, since the sum of $\eta$ against the constant part is zero. The proof samples points independently with probabilities $x^{-\varepsilon/8}$ on $A_0$ and $3x^{-\varepsilon/8}/4$ elsewhere. It selects one realization satisfying both the class-count and Frobenius-orbit bounds. The denominator in the shares is its realized size $|T|$. Bernoulli construction · Construction from coset counts · Selected set used in the arithmetic · Fourier estimate for every surviving character
To see what is counted, fix this auxiliary field and use the ideal weights $w_\eta$. Write $G_{\xi,\eta}$ for the ramp of the primitive character inducing the host character $(\xi,\eta)$, including the correction at one used above. Form
$$ S(x)=\sum_{\xi,\eta}\xi(e)w_\eta\,\Re G_{\xi,\eta}(x). $$At an unramified prime power $p^j$ let $(v,a)$ be its Frobenius in $E\times Q$. The coefficient in $S$, in units of $\log p$, is
$$ P(v,a)=4\,\mathbf1_{v=e}\,\frac{o(3+\mathbf1_{a=0})}{3o+1}. $$Indeed the four sign characters sum to $4\mathbf1_{v=e}$ after the factor $\xi(e)$, and the sum of the nontrivial characters of $Q$ at $a$ is $o\mathbf1_{a=0}-1$. Only one of the four sign classes contributes. Every unramified even prime power therefore has coefficient zero in $S$. At a ramified prime with inertia $I$, average $P$ on the coset $\mathrm{Frob}_p^j I$ in the quotient group. This retains exactly the characters trivial on $I$, as required by their primitive Euler factors. Primitive character identification · Frobenius and inertia in the host · Artin Euler products
One sign has a concrete meaning. The automorphism $e$ negates $\sqrt{-d}$ for the auxiliary prime $d\equiv7\bmod16$. The discriminant of $\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-d})$ is $-d$. Thus for every $p\ne d$, including primes ramified elsewhere in the auxiliary field, the whole Frobenius coset for $p^{2j}$ fixes $\sqrt{-d}$. Its coefficient vanishes. Moreover the window construction makes every odd $p\le Y^{\varepsilon/5}$ split in this quadratic field, by requiring $p\mid d+1$, and $2$ splits since $-d\equiv1\bmod8$. All powers of those small primes vanish in $S$. Action on the quadratic subfield · Sign coordinates · Required congruences · Splitting calculation
Consequently the same auxiliary ramp can be read using just rational primes, with an error below square-root size. Write $a(p^j)$ for its coefficient in units of $\log p$ and put $C_2=\sum_{p,\,j\ge2}a(p^j)\log p/p^j$. Define $S_1(x)$ by keeping the prime terms of $S(x)$ and adding $C_2 x$ to its linear correction. Then, uniformly in the admissible auxiliary field and in $o$,
$$ 0\le S_1(x)-S(x)\ll x^{1/3}\qquad(x\ge2). $$Indeed $0\le a(p^j)\le16/3$. Put $A(u)=\sum_{p^j\le u,\,j\ge2}a(p^j)\log p$. The even powers of $d$ contribute $O(\log u)$. For the odd powers the elementary Chebyshev upper bound gives $O(u^{1/3}+u^{1/5}\log u)=O(u^{1/3})$. This proves convergence of $C_2$ and gives the exact difference $S_1(x)-S(x)=x\int_x^\infty A(u)u^{-2}\,du$. The correction matters because each omitted ramp carries the linear term $x/p^j$. On the selected windows the arithmetic comparison below therefore applies to a sum over ordinary primes with one prescribed pair of signs. Ramp normalization · Identification with primitive ramps
There is also a field expression for this particular signed sum. Let $L$ be the auxiliary subfield with Galois group $E\times Q$, let $B=L^{\{0\}\times Q}$, and write $J=\langle(e,0)\rangle$, using its image on $B$ as well. The normalized negative logarithmic derivative giving the prime coefficients of $S$ is $-Z_{\rm aux}'/((3o+1)Z_{\rm aux})$, where
$$ Z_{\rm aux}(s)= \left(\frac{\zeta_{B^J}(s)^2}{\zeta_B(s)}\right)^{3o} \,\cdot\,\frac{\zeta_{L^J}(s)^2}{\zeta_L(s)}. $$For either extension the quotient puts exponent $+1$ on characters trivial on $J$ and $-1$ on the others. The extra $3o$ copies supply the weight of the $Q$-trivial terms. The pole order is $3o+1$. For example take $L=\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-3},\sqrt{-7},\zeta_5)$ and let $e$ flip $\sqrt{-3}$ while fixing $\sqrt{-7}$. The normalized coefficients at $11$ and $23$ are $64/13$ and $48/13$ respectively, and both squares have coefficient zero. At the ramified prime $3$ the first four coefficients are $0,24/13,0,32/13$. Here all coefficients are given in units of $\log p$. Cyclotomic realization and Galois group · Abelian factorization
The passage back to the fixed target uses an arithmetic estimate. Each of its $o$ powers has $\xi(e)=1$, and only the principal character has trivial restriction to $Q$. The sum of the absolute ideal weights of the other characters is consequently
$$ 4\left(1+\frac{o-1}{3o+1}\right) -\left(1+\frac{o-1}{3o+1}\right)=\frac{12o}{3o+1}. $$On a selected window the auxiliary-prime construction bounds each of these other primitive ramps by $x^{1/2+\varepsilon}$, through twists by one or both auxiliary quadratic characters. Hence $|S(x)-G_F(x)|\le[12o/(3o+1)]\,x^{1/2+\varepsilon}$. This is a refinement obtained by keeping the ideal weights. The source bounds the sum of the discarded absolute values by $4o\,x^{1/2+\varepsilon}$. For the actual equally weighted tops, replacing $a(t)/b=x+O(1)$ by $x$ and inserting the ideal weights costs $O(x^\varepsilon\log x)$ for fixed character, exponent and host-bound constants. The shift costs $O(\log x)$ per character, and the share error is at most $o\delta$ times a ramp of size $O(x\log x)$. These comparisons apply after dividing out the scalar from the first average. The auxiliary field may vary across windows, and its signed zeta quotient can have poles at zeros of its denominator. The final zero test uses the fixed $G_F$, in which every target zero has positive multiplicity. Target identification · Auxiliary twists · Window hypotheses · Shift and share errors · Discarded terms · Final use
A prime-counting interpretation for ordinary RH
For the zeta function the auxiliary arithmetic has a description using two Legendre symbols. Let $q,d$ be the chosen odd primes and $J_r(n)=(n/r)$. Give each prime $p$ with $J_q(p)=+1$ and $J_d(p)=-1$ the weight $4\log p$. These primes split in $\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-q})$ and are inert in $\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-d})$. Write $\Theta_{q,d}(t)$ for their total weight up to $t$ and put
$$ D_{q,d}(x)=x\int_x^\infty\frac{t-\Theta_{q,d}(t)}{t^2}\,dt . $$An upper bound for $D_{q,d}$ limits a weighted deficit of these primes. The proof of the window selection chooses a single pair $q,d$ before selecting the subinterval and varying the height of the cyclotomic tower. Selection of the pair and interval · Use of the same pair at each scale
In this case the ideal average is exactly
$$ S=G_z+G_{J_q}-G_{J_d}-G_{J_qJ_d}. $$The coefficient at $p^k$, in units of $\log p$, is $(1+J_q(p)^k)(1-J_d(p)^k)$. At $q$ all coefficients vanish because $J_d(q)=1$. At $d$ the coefficient is $1+(-1)^k$ because $J_q(d)=-1$. At all other primes only odd powers of the selected primes survive. On any interval where the three nonprincipal ramps are bounded by $x^{1/2+\varepsilon/2}$, this gives
$$ -3x^{1/2+\varepsilon/2} \ \le\ D_{q,d}(x)-G_z(x)\ \le\ 3x^{1/2+\varepsilon/2}+C x^{1/3} $$with an absolute $C$. The $x^{1/3}$ term is the nonnegative cost of deleting the higher powers with their full linear correction. The source obtains the three twist bounds by a second moment over primes in prescribed progressions. A second-moment bound for the derivative controls intermediate real cutoffs, and a zero-free box estimates the part beyond the truncation. Twist and window bounds · Second moment · Maximum over a dyadic interval · Tail at $s=1$
The sign in the integral follows from the pole at one. Set $F=\zeta L(J_q)/(L(J_d)L(J_qJ_d))$, with all factors evaluated at $s$, and let $\Psi(t)$ count its weighted prime powers. If $c$ is the constant term of $-F'/F$ at one, then
$$ c=1+\int_1^\infty\frac{\Psi(t)-t}{t^2}\,dt. $$Indeed $-F'/F=s\int_1^\infty\Psi(t)t^{-s-1}dt$ for real $s>1$. The fixed-modulus prime number theorem in progressions justifies taking the finite part. The source's linear term is $(1-c)x$, and the uncentered ramp divided by $x$ is $\int_1^x\Psi(t)t^{-2}dt$. Substitution gives $S(x)=x\int_x^\infty(t-\Psi(t))t^{-2}dt$. Replacing $\Psi$ by $\Theta_{q,d}$ gives $D_{q,d}$ and adds the positive higher-power correction. The prime number theorem is used with $q,d$ fixed in this identity. Uniformity over the selected pairs comes from the twist bounds and the elementary higher-power estimate above. Ramp conventions · Finite splitting in the source
Thus an alternative formulation of the ordinary RH step asks, for each $\eta>0$, for a pair satisfying the three twist bounds and $D_{q,d}(x)\ll_\eta x^{1/2+\eta}$ throughout each of an arbitrarily late sequence of intervals $[Y,Y^{3/2}]$. Here $\varepsilon$ is fixed first with $0<\varepsilon<\min(1/52,2\eta)$. The inequality above transfers the upper bound to $G_z$. Conversely RH gives $\Psi_\zeta(t)=t+O(\sqrt t\log^2(2t))$ for the ordinary von Mangoldt sum, so the same integral identity gives the bound for $D_{q,d}$ for every such pair. The proposed proof obtains its upper bound by comparing the finite-place divisibility with the archimedean sizes of the period maps. Window criterion · Slope comparison · Where it enters the final estimate
A hypothetical zeta zero of real part $\beta>1/2$ would force the deficit for many choices of quadratic fields at the same cutoff. Fix $1/2+\varepsilon/2<\theta<\beta$ and $C>0$. On every sufficiently late $[Y,Y^{3/2}]$ the window criterion gives an $x$ with $G_z(x)>(C+1)x^\theta$. At that $x$, every pair satisfying the twist bounds has $D_{q,d}(x)>Cx^\theta$. For each such pair some $t\ge x$ must then satisfy $t-\Theta_{q,d}(t)>(1-\theta)Ct^\theta$, by integration. This last $t$ may depend on the pair. One-sided window criterion
Merely seeing the selected primes below $x$ leaves the linear term undetermined. For example, remove from $\zeta$ all Euler factors at $B<p\le2B$. For $1\le x\le B$ the visible prime powers are identical, and the correctly centered ramp increases by $x\sum_{B<p\le2B}\log p/(p-1)=(\log2+o(1))x$ as $B\to\infty$. The removed factors are nonvanishing in $\Re s>0$. This finite modification illustrates why a bound uniform in varying arithmetic data has to account for the tail. Centering at one
A test using only primes inside the window
For ordinary RH, the same analytic argument gives the following finite-interval criterion. For every $0<\eta<1/2$, there must be a constant $C_\eta$ and arbitrarily large $Y$ such that every $Y\le A<B\le Y^{3/2}$ satisfies
$$ \sum_{A<p\le B}\log p\ \ge\ B-A-C_\eta B^{1/2+\eta}. $$This condition is equivalent to RH. Under RH the classical estimate for $\vartheta(t)=\sum_{p\le t}\log p$ gives it on all sufficiently late windows. The reverse implication also explains what a shortage of primes would look like in Alpöge’s selected quadratic classes. Abstract window theorem · Hypotheses on poles
The centered zeta ramp takes both signs on every sufficiently late power interval if $\zeta$ has a zero of real part $\beta>1/2$. More precisely, for each $1/2<\theta<\beta$, each fixed power $r>1$ and each $C>0$, both $G_z(x)>Cx^\theta$ and $G_z(x)<-Cx^\theta$ occur in every sufficiently late $[V,V^r]$. To see the second inequality, apply the source’s abstract theorem to $-G_z(e^u)$ and the negative of its Laplace transform. Its pole set in $\Re s>0$ is the same. A zeta zero $\rho$ of any multiplicity $h$ gives a simple pole of the centered transform because $\zeta'/\zeta$ has principal part $h/(s-\rho)$. The theorem requires a positive residue only at real poles. The centering removes the pole at one, $\zeta(s)<0$ for real $0<s<1$ by the alternating eta series, and the Euler product is positive for real $s>1$. Pole data for the centered transform · Real-pole hypothesis · Window theorem
Choose any $Y\le u<v<w\le Y^{3/2}$. Write $\lambda=(w-v)/(w-u)$, $\mu=(v-u)/(w-u)$ and $\Delta H=H(v)-\lambda H(u)-\mu H(w)$. Let $K(t)$ equal $\lambda(t-u)$ on $[u,v]$, $\mu(w-t)$ on $[v,w]$ and zero elsewhere. Put $W(t)=K(t)/t$ for $t>0$. A direct calculation gives
$$ \Delta G_z=\int_u^w W(t)\,dt-\sum_{u<n<w}\Lambda(n)W(n). $$Indeed $\lambda u+\mu w=v$, so the linear correction vanishes. The chord difference of $(x/n-1)_+$ is $-W(n)$, and the second derivative of $x\log x$ is $1/x$. This identity uses only prime powers strictly between $u$ and $w$. Replacing them by primes increases the deficit by $O(\sqrt v)$ uniformly, since $W(n)\le\min(1,v/n)$ and $\sum_{p^k\le t,\,k\ge2}\log p\ll\sqrt t$. Source ramp
If $\beta>1/2+\eta=\theta$, split $[Y,Y^{3/2}]$ into three successive power intervals using $r=(3/2)^{1/3}$. Choose $u,w$ with negative ramp in the first and third, and $v$ with $G_z(v)>Cv^\theta$ in the middle. Then the prime deficit for $W$ exceeds $Cv^\theta$. On the other hand, if the displayed interval bound holds, integrate it over the level sets $\{W>s\}$, each an interval with right endpoint at most $v/s$. Since $0\le W\le1$, the weighted deficit is at most $C_\eta v^\theta\int_0^1 s^{-\theta}ds=C_\eta v^\theta/(1-\theta)$. Endpoints of level sets hit prime atoms at only finitely many levels. Choosing $C>C_\eta/(1-\theta)$ gives the converse.
For the selected classes define the corresponding deficit by
$$ T_{q,d}(u,v,w)=\int_u^w W(t)\,dt- 4\!\!\sum_{\substack{u<p<w\\J_q(p)=1,\ J_d(p)=-1}}\!\!W(p)\log p . $$There is a finite choice of tests for the auxiliary primes as well. Fix $0<\varepsilon<1/52$, $0<\tau<\eta$ and $X=Y^{3/2}$. On each large window the progression estimates give a pair $q,d$ with the prescribed sizes and congruences such that for all $Y\le y\le X$,
$$ \left|\sum_{Y<n\le X}\Lambda(n)\xi(n)\min(1,y/n)\right| \le \tfrac12 y^{1/2+\tau} \qquad(\xi=J_q,J_d,J_qJ_d). $$Insert $\mathbf1_{Y<n\le X}$ in the bounded coefficients of the source’s second moment. Select $q$ in the first progression, then use this indicator and its product with $J_q$ as the two tests when selecting $d$ in the second. The uniform bound for the fraction of bad candidates allows these two exclusions simultaneously. The relative prime number theorem in progressions, including its exceptional character, enters this selection. All three tests themselves are finite sums. Progression moment · Fraction of excluded candidates · Successive progressions
Taking $\Delta$ of each finite sum gives $\sum_n\Lambda(n)\xi(n)W(n)$. Concavity of $y^{1/2+\tau}$ bounds its absolute value by $v^{1/2+\tau}$, since $\lambda u+\mu w=v$. It follows that every pair passing the three tests satisfies, for every triple in the window,
$$ \left|T_{q,d}(u,v,w)-\Delta G_z\right|\le 3v^{1/2+\tau}+O(v^{1/3}). $$Here the higher-power cost uses the same vanishing of even powers away from $d$. Thus a hypothetical zero forces a deficit exceeding $Cv^\theta$ on a common triple for every pair passing the finite tests, for any $1/2+\tau<\theta<\beta$ and fixed $C$. Conversely, under RH every such pair satisfies $T_{q,d}(u,v,w)\ll_\eta v^{1/2+\eta}$ for all triples. The condition that one such pair achieves this upper bound on arbitrarily late windows is another formulation of ordinary RH. Proving that upper bound directly is the arithmetic step still required by this formulation. Two quadratic residue conditions · Full centered estimate in the proposed proof
A prime count whose sign detects ordinary RH
Ordinary RH is equivalent to the following inequality at every prime $r$.
$$ \prod_{\substack{p\ {\rm prime}\\ r/2<p<2r}}p^{\min(2p-r,\,2r-p)/p}<2^r . $$Its logarithmic margin at real $x$ is $3D_{\rm p}(x)$. The prime-power deficit is $D(x)=G_z(x)-2G_z(x/2)/3-G_z(2x)/3$. Removing prime squares adds $(0.1143819\ldots+o(1))\sqrt{x}$. Under RH the spectral loss is at most $0.062533\sqrt{x}$. $D_{\rm p}>0$ on $[1,10^{35}]$ unconditionally by a sieve, zero-density bounds and the phases of 32 low zero pairs. Failure by $10^{36}$ would require at least 31,624 ordinary zeros with $3/4<\Re\rho<1$ and $3\cdot10^{12}<\Im\rho\le10^{13}$, counting multiplicity. Density estimates
The multiplier $(2^s-1)(2^{1-s}-1)/3$ retains every zero pole in the open strip. An off-line zero forces negative excursions even at squares on every sufficiently late power window. The direct arithmetic sign at all primes remains open. At a fixed host each summand $(a/n-w)_+$ contributes exactly $wW(nw/a)$ to the outer mean minus the middle value. The period estimate bounds the ramp above. Bounding $-D(x)$ from the three separate values also needs a lower estimate at $x$. Ramp · Window theorem
Counting primes between $x$ and $2x$
By Alpöge's abstract window theorem, ordinary RH is equivalent to the existence of a constant $C>0$ and arbitrarily large $Y$ for which
$$ \sum_{x<p\le 2x}\log p\ \ge\ x-C\sqrt{x}\log^2(2x) \qquad\left(Y\le x\le Y^{3/2}/2\right). $$The ratio of the endpoints is fixed and the starting point $x$ varies. Under RH the estimate follows from the classical bound on $\vartheta(x)-x$, applied at both endpoints. The converse uses the fact that dilation preserves the pole produced by every zero under consideration. Abstract window theorem · Schoenfeld's prime-counting estimate
For the fixed cyclic field $K$ above, put $N=3o+1$, $Z=\zeta^{3o}\zeta_K$ and $\Psi_F(t)=\sum_{p^a\le t}b_\chi(p^a)\log p$, with $b_\chi(p^a)=(3o+(o/e_p)\mathbf1_{f_p\mid a})/N$. Ordinary zeta corresponds to $K=\mathbb Q$ and $b_\chi=1$. Set $A(t)=t-\Psi_F(t)$. Termwise integration for $\Re s>1$ gives
$$ \Phi(s)=\int_1^\infty A(t)t^{-s-1}\,dt =\frac{1}{s-1}+\frac{1}{Ns}\frac{Z'}{Z}(s). $$The pole of order $N$ of $Z$ at one makes the singularity of $\Phi$ there removable. For any fixed $h>1$, write $D_h(x)=A(hx)-A(x)$. Changing variables gives its Mellin transform
$$ (h^s-1)\Phi(s)-h^s\int_1^h A(t)t^{-s-1}\,dt . $$The finite integral is entire. A zero $\rho$ of $Z$ of any order $m$ in the open strip gives a simple pole with residue $m(h^\rho-1)/(N\rho)$. For $\Re\rho>0$ we have $|h^\rho|>1$. At a real zero this residue is positive, as required by the one-sided theorem. The other hypotheses follow from meromorphic continuation, isolated zeros, and the measurability and $O_h(e^u)$ growth of $D_h(e^u)$ for $u\ge0$. The growth bound follows from Chebyshev's estimate and $0<b_\chi(p^a)\le4o/N$. Pole and growth hypotheses · Abelian factorization
Suppose $\Re\rho=\beta>\theta>1/2$ and fix $C_1>0$. Then every sufficiently late $[Y,Y^{3/2}]$ contains an interval $(x,hx]$, with $x\ge Y$, on which $D_h(x)>C_1x^\theta$. Otherwise arbitrarily large $Y$ would give $D_h(x)\le C_1x^\theta$ throughout $[Y,Y^{5/4}]$, since $hY^{5/4}\le Y^{3/2}$ eventually. On that interval in the variable $u=\log x$, the weighted integral of the majorant $C_1e^{\theta u}$ is $(C_1/4)\log Y$. This satisfies the theorem's window hypothesis for every positive exponential allowance. Deleting prime powers of exponent at least two increases the deficit. Thus the upper bound $C\sqrt{x}\log^2(2x)$ for the prime-only deficit rules out every such $\rho$. The functional equations pair every nontrivial zero with a zero of complementary real part. For general $K$, the resulting equivalence concerns all the factors of the fixed product $Z$. In the forward direction the prime ideal theorem under GRH bounds $A(t)$ by $O_K(\sqrt t\log^2(2t))$, and deleting the higher powers costs $O_h(\sqrt x)$ by Chebyshev's estimate. Window theorem · Prime ideal theorem under GRH
One can even restrict the displayed test to integer squares $x=n^2$. For $2Y\le x\le (2Y)^{5/4}$ choose $n=\lfloor\sqrt{x}\rfloor$. Both $n^2$ and $2n^2$ lie in the original window for large $Y$. Moving the left endpoint from $n^2$ to $x$ can remove at most $(2\sqrt{x}+1)\log(2x)$ in prime weight. The right endpoint moves outward and the main term changes by at most $2\sqrt{x}+1$. This recovers the required bound at every real $x$ in the smaller power window. In the original argument the theta lifts control the values of the smoothed sum $G_F$. A direct arithmetic proof of the sharp test would have to control the local deficit. The exact relation at each endpoint is $A(x)=G_F(x)-xG'_{F,+}(x)$, where the right derivative includes a prime power at $x$. Definition of the smoothed sum · Character sums · Arithmetic estimate for its values
How closely can the selected primes track all primes?
The progression estimates in the source also let one choose a single pair $q,d$ for which
$$ \left|4\!\!\sum_{\substack{A<p\le B\\J_q(p)=1,\ J_d(p)=-1}}\!\!\log p -\sum_{A<p\le B}\log p\right| \ \ll\ \sqrt B\,\log^2(2Y) \qquad(Y\le A<B\le Y^{3/2}). $$This bound compares the selected primes with the actual total prime weight in each subinterval. The main term $B-A$ enters separately in the RH criterion above. The pair can also satisfy the source’s quadratic-twist window conditions for the trivial base character. Prime correlation estimate · Simultaneous selection
Here is a derivation. In either progression give its candidate primes $r$ equal weight, and put $X=Y^{3/2}$. Every prime $Y<p\le X$ is coprime to the progression modulus. In the second progression its possible prime divisors are $2$, primes up to $Y^{\varepsilon/5}$, and the already chosen $q>X$. For distinct $p,\ell$ in the window, quadratic reciprocity expresses $J_r(p)J_r(\ell)$ as $(r/(p\ell))$ times a sign independent of $r$. The source bounds the absolute mean by $Y^{-4}$ for $p\ell\le Y^3$, with one possible exceptional squarefree integer. That integer equals $p\ell$ for at most one unordered pair. For complex coefficients $a_p$ this gives
$$ \mathbb E_r\left|\sum_p a_p J_r(p)\right|^2 \le(2+XY^{-4})\sum_p |a_p|^2 . $$The diagonal costs $\sum|a_p|^2$, the exceptional pair costs at most $|a_p|^2+|a_\ell|^2$, and the remaining terms cost at most $Y^{-4}(\sum|a_p|)^2$. Uniform estimate and exceptional integer · Progression moduli
For any fixed $|c_p|\le1$ and $Y<T\le X$, list the primes in $(Y,T]$ in order and split the list repeatedly into dyadic blocks, padding with zeros if needed. A prefix is the disjoint union of at most $1+\lceil\log_2 X\rceil$ such blocks. By Cauchy–Schwarz and the preceding estimate at each level,
$$ \mathbb E_r\max_{Y\le t\le T} \left|\sum_{Y<p\le t} c_pJ_r(p)\log p\right|^2 \ll \log^2(2X)\sum_{Y<p\le T}\log^2p\ll T\log^3(2Y). $$The last inequality uses Chebyshev’s bound and $X=Y^{3/2}$. Cover $[Y,X]$ by $O(\log(2Y))$ dyadic intervals of right endpoints $T$, with $T/t\le2$ on each interval. The mean square of the maximum prefix sum divided by $\sqrt t$ at its own endpoint is then $O(\log^4(2Y))$. Markov’s inequality leaves at least seven eighths of the first progression for a bound $C\sqrt t\log^2(2Y)$, with a fixed sufficiently large $C$. Select $q$ with $c_p=1$. For this same $q$, apply the estimate twice in its second progression, with $c_p=1$ and $c_p=J_q(p)$, and choose one $d$ passing both tests. The positive proportions allow intersection with the source’s good sets by taking its discarded fractions below $1/8$ at both stages. Subtract two prefixes and use $4\mathbf1_{J_q=1,J_d=-1}-1=J_q-J_d-J_qJ_d$ on the window. This proves the displayed bound for all real endpoints. Order and proportions in the source
The same choice argument works for the fixed weights $b_\chi(p)$ by taking $c_p=b_\chi(p)N/(4o)$ in the first progression and testing $c_p$ and $c_pJ_q(p)$ in the second. Fix a constant in the resulting $O(\sqrt B\log^2(2Y))$ comparison. If $Z$ has a zero with $\beta>\theta>1/2$, then for every fixed $C_1>0$ each sufficiently late power window contains one interval $(x,2x]$ on which every pair satisfying that comparison has
$$ x-4\!\!\sum_{\substack{x<p\le2x\\J_q(p)=1,\ J_d(p)=-1}} b_\chi(p)\log p>C_1x^\theta. $$Apply the fixed-field theorem with $C_1+1$ first. On the resulting interval the comparison error is at most a fixed constant times $\sqrt{2x}\log^2(2Y)=o(x^\theta)$ uniformly for $x\ge Y$. In particular, the arithmetic question for a direct proof is whether the selected primes can be shown to supply the required lower bound relative to $x$ throughout arbitrarily late windows. Correlation estimate for the prime choices · Window theorem
The same two signs for a fixed Dirichlet character
For a target of conductor $M$ let $b_\chi(p^k)$ be the fixed-field coefficient above, in units of $\log p$. For the ideal auxiliary average at a common cutoff the coefficient at every prime power is
$$ a(p^k)=b_\chi(p^k)(1+J_q(p)^k)(1-J_d(p)^k). $$Indeed the $o$ retained primitive powers of $\chi$ have positive sign and distinct restrictions to $Q$. Each has four twists by $1,J_q,J_d,J_qJ_d$, with the same absolute weight and signs $+,+,-,-$. The conductors of each primitive power, $J_q$ and $J_d$ are pairwise coprime. Their products therefore give the primitive coefficients at ramified primes as well. In the explicit group coordinates the cyclic coordinate on a unit $u$ contains the extra factor $\chi(J_q(u))$. It equals one on the selected $q$-sign. This explains why the formula also holds for odd targets. If the realized top shares are $\mu_T(a)$, the coefficient at a common cutoff is $4o\mathbf1_{v=e}\mu_T(a^{-1})$ in multiplicative notation, averaged over inertia when necessary. The factor $o$ is the sum of the $Q$-characters at the identity. The source separately handles the actual shifted cutoffs $a(t)/b$. Artin coordinates · Twists and their signs · Identification of retained powers · Sample weights
On a sufficiently late window all powers at $p\mid 2Mq$ vanish. At $d$, put $f=\operatorname{lcm}(2,\operatorname{ord}(\chi(d)))$. Then
$$ a(d^k)=\frac{2o}{3o+1}\bigl(3\mathbf1_{2\mid k}+\mathbf1_{f\mid k}\bigr). $$Deleting the entire $d$ factor adds precisely
$$ \frac{2o\,x\log d}{3o+1} \left(\frac{3}{d^2-1}+\frac{1}{d^f-1}\right) $$to the centered ramp when $x<d^2$. The pair construction makes $d$ larger than every fixed power of $x$ on these windows. As a local example, take a primitive cubic character modulo $9$, $q=11$ and $d=263$. Then $\chi(d)$ has order three. The coefficients at $d^2,d^4,d^6$ are $9/5,9/5,12/5$, respectively. The distinction arises because $d\equiv-1\bmod3$ while $d\equiv2\bmod9$. Pair congruences and sizes · Inertia and the other sign at $d$
Prime counts within one level of the cyclotomic tower
The proof chooses the same $q,d$ across its power window. The tower level varies with the counting variable $t$. For $\alpha=2+8\varepsilon$ and a constant $c$ fixed by the target character, the group $A$ indexing the top residue classes must have order $c2^j$ with $t^\alpha\le c2^j\le2t^\alpha$. This condition gives disjoint allowable orders at $x$ and $2x$. Within
$$ I_j=[(c2^{j-1})^{1/\alpha},(c2^j)^{1/\alpha}] $$the order $c2^j$ fits every point. Its field and underlying Galois group can be held fixed once $q,d$ and the splitting bound are fixed. The weight scale $b(t)=\exp(t^\varepsilon)$ still varies. So do the lift ranks. With all ranks held fixed, the exact rank equation has a positive nondecreasing factor multiplied by $\lceil t^{377}\rceil$ on its right. Its left side is constant, so a shift by $\sqrt{t}$ already forces a change of ranks. The shifts built into the chosen tops at one scale are at most $1/(kt^{12})$. Rank equation · Top cutoff bound · Pair chosen before the subwindow · Size condition · Field at one level · Scale of the weights
Write $d_F(u,v)=v-u-\sum_{u<p\le v}b_\chi(p)\log p$ for the fixed-field deficit. Cut $(x,2x]$ at the boundaries of the $I_j$. The quantity $\log_2(t^\alpha/c)$ increases by $\alpha\in(2,3)$, so there are at most four pieces. Every piece has at least one endpoint at a tower boundary. The deficits add exactly with the indicated half-open convention. Consequently a bound $d_F(u,v)\le C\sqrt v\log^2(2v)$ for all such prefixes and suffixes lying inside each of arbitrarily late power windows suffices for the fixed product's RH. Conversely an off-line zero forces, for every $C_1>0$ and $1/2<\theta<\Re\rho$, one of these pieces to have $d_F(u,v)>C_1v^\theta$ on every sufficiently late window. Apply the fixed-ratio theorem with $4\cdot2^\theta C_1$ and use $v\le2x$. At a shared boundary either adjacent order satisfies the size inequality. A uniform bound valid as interior endpoints approach the boundary suffices there. Trimming a total length $\ell$ can reduce the deficit by at most $\ell$, since the prime weights are nonnegative.
There is a finite difference of the source's smoothed sum at the same level that measures this deficit. Let $H=\sqrt u$. When $v-u<2H$, positivity already gives $d_F(u,v)<2H$. For $v-u\ge2H$ and a function $f$ put
$$ L[f]=\frac vH\bigl(f(v)-f(v-H)\bigr)-f(v) -\frac uH\bigl(f(u+H)-f(u)\bigr)+f(u). $$Then $d_F(u,v)=-L[G_F]+O(\sqrt v\log(2v))$ on each piece. Indeed $L$ kills affine functions. Applied to $(t/n-1)_+$ it gives a weight in $[0,1]$ supported on $(u,v)$, equal to one on $[u+H,v-H]$. On the left and right strips the weights are $(u+H)(n-u)/(Hn)$ and $(v-H)(v-n)/(Hn)$, respectively. Replacing these weights by a sharp count costs $O((H+1)\log(2v))$, and removing higher powers costs $O(\sqrt v)$. For $f(t)=t\log t$, the forward secant term $\frac uH(f(u+H)-f(u))-f(u)$ lies in $[u,u+H]$, and the backward term at $v$ lies in $[v-H,v]$. Thus $0\le v-u-L[f]\le2H$. All four evaluations lie in $I_j$. The arithmetic estimate a direct proof would need is a lower bound for this signed combination of $G_F$. The scalar comparison in the source gives an upper bound for $G_F$ at each supplied scale. Source ramp · Fixed character family · Scalar comparison
Why the arithmetic only needs good intervals
Fix $0<\theta<1$ and $\delta>0$, and write $G_F$ for the weighted real sum. The window theorem says that if there is a fixed $C$ and arbitrarily large $Y$ such that
$$ G_F(y)\le C y^\theta \qquad (Y\le y\le Y^{1+\delta}), $$then every member of $F$ is zero-free in $\Re s>\theta$, with the usual principal pole convention. Thus a zero with real part $\beta>\theta$ forces a violation on every sufficiently late window, for each fixed $C$. The main argument takes $\delta=1/2$. Given a putative $\beta>1/2$, it first fixes $\theta$ strictly between $1/2$ and $\min(\beta,1)$ and then makes the arithmetic exponent smaller than or equal to $\theta$. The family and the exponent are fixed before taking $Y$ large. Window theorem · Conversion used in the final path · Choice of exponent
The localization is visible in an elementary formula. Put $u=\log y$, $g(u)=G_F(e^u)$ and let $\Phi$ be the Laplace transform of $g$. At $\sigma>2$ the normalized derivative $D_k(\gamma)=(-1)^k\Phi^{(k)}(\sigma+i\gamma)/k!$ integrates $g(u)e^{-i\gamma u}$ against $w_k(u)=u^k e^{-\sigma u}/k!$. Since $g$ is real,
$$ |D_k(\gamma)|+\Re D_k(0)\le 2\int_0^\infty \max(g(u),0)\,w_k(u)\,du . $$Writing $U=\log Y$, the source chooses $\sigma$ and $k$ so that even the error from the crude growth $|g(u)|\ll_F e^{2u}$ outside $[U,(1+\delta)U]$ is small. On the interval the one-sided hypothesis bounds the integral. A pole uniquely closest to the translated center $z=\sigma+i\gamma$ contributes $c/(z-\rho)^{k+1}$, and Cauchy’s bound controls the analytic remainder on a larger disk. The argument also treats the case of a real pole, using the positive residue above. Tail estimate · One-sided inequality · Nearest-pole and real-pole arguments
For the window $[Y,Y^{3/2}]$ the source's explicit choice is $\sigma=336$ and $k=\lceil420\log Y\rceil$. After normalization the kernel is a gamma density. Its mode is $k/336$ and its standard deviation is $\sqrt{k+1}/336$. Its mode lies within $1/336$ of the midpoint $5\log Y/4$ in the logarithmic variable, while the distance to either edge grows proportionally to $\log Y$. The source bounds the tails even after multiplying by the allowed growth $e^{2u}$. Choice of parameters and tail inequality
For a fixed zero with $\beta>\theta>0$ and fixed $\delta>0$ there exist $\eta>0$ and $Y_0$ such that for every $Y\ge Y_0$,
$$ \int_Y^{Y^{1+\delta}} (G_F(y))_+\,y^{-\theta-1}\,dy> Y^\eta,\qquad (a)_+=\max(a,0). $$Indeed, failure would supply arbitrarily late intervals for each $\eta>0$ with the opposite weak inequality. Taking $R=(G_F)_+$ would satisfy the source’s integral hypothesis and rule out the chosen zero. This inference uses the analytic theorem alone. Definition of the integral hypothesis · Its implication for zeros
Why the chain has square-root length
The announcement introduces $m$ successive theta lifts between totally definite unitary groups to supply multiplicity. In its account the seesaw comparison expresses periods through a Bessel period independent of the auxiliary Hecke characters. The lift norms, their level dependence and the divisible part of the periods all enter the estimate. Alpöge describes an apparent exponent $2/3$ when first pricing the lifts and then introduces a joint integral structure across characters. Announcement, items 8–18
The final scalar comparison lets us see exactly why $m$ is close to $\sqrt x$. Write $n$ for the size of the finite group indexing the character calculation and $n_T,n_2$ for the sizes of its two selected sets. Put $d_1=n_T/n$, $d_2=n_2/n$. In the source notation $b$ is the positive normalization of the weights, $a_E$ lies between $xb$ and $2xb$, and $k$ is an auxiliary size parameter. The coefficient multiplying the prime-sum error is $D=n_Tmbd_2/2$. Dividing the source’s explicit error bracket $B$ by it gives the identity
$$ \frac{B}{D} = \frac{2a_E}{b d_2}\left(\frac1m+\frac m k\right) +\frac{4m x^\varepsilon}{d_1d_2} +\frac{2k x^{2\varepsilon}}{d_1 n^2}. $$The divisibility and norm estimates supply an error at most $x^{C\varepsilon}B$. The identity is an ordinary division of that bracket. Comparison coefficient · Explicit bracket and size conditions · Lower bound on $a_E$
Two terms in this allowance have sizes at least $2x/m$ and $4m$. Decreasing the chain length raises the first and increasing it raises the second. The actual hypotheses give
$$ x^{1/2-\varepsilon}\le m\le x^{1/2+\varepsilon/2},\quad xm\le k\le n^2x^{1/2-\varepsilon},\quad d_1\ge\tfrac12x^{-\varepsilon/8},\quad d_2\ge x^{-\varepsilon}. $$For example the middle term is at most $8x^{1/2+21\varepsilon/8}$. Also $xm/k\le1$, which controls the other part of the first term. After accounting for the remaining errors the comparison gives $G_F(x)\le x^{1/2+(e_D+e_L+7)\varepsilon}$ at the supplied scales. The constants $e_D,e_L$ bound the exponents lost in divisibility and in the remaining estimates. They are fixed as $\varepsilon$ decreases for the chosen character family. Scalar estimate · Its use for the character sum · Final exponent · Order of quantifiers
Where the integral lattices enter
There is an explicit formula for division at the finite places. The source glues locally selected row lattices into a global lattice $R$ and uses its integral dual as a common target for the column maps $B_u$. For a source lattice $\nu_u$ and local shifts $s_w$, its division statement includes $B_u(\operatorname{shift}_{s}\nu_u)\subseteq R^\vee$. The slope of the shifted source is
$$ \mu(\operatorname{shift}_{s}\nu_u)-\mu(\nu_u) = \frac{2}{[K:\mathbb Q]}\sum_w \lfloor s_w\rfloor\log Nw . $$A one-unit shift at a prime therefore gives a stated logarithmic gain, while the same declaration bounds the archimedean norm of $B_u$. The source has a rank-one example at the primes in a conjugate pair above $3$ and a quantitative use of the general statement. Glued target and dual slope · Shift and squared-norm convention · Inclusion, norm and slope identity · Example at $3$ · Use of the general statement
At a finite place above $\ell$, the source embeds an integral Hecke module $L$ in its scalar extension to the fraction field of the local ring $O$. For a selected group of simultaneous eigenspaces with sum $V$ and complementary sum $W$, it compares
$$ L_{\rm low}=L\cap V,\qquad L_{\rm up}=(L+W)\cap V . $$In the direct sum decomposition, $L_{\rm up}$ is the projection of the entire lattice and $L_{\rm low}$ consists of its already integral vectors in $V$. The quotient measures the denominator introduced by separating eigenspaces. A two-dimensional example over $\mathbb Z_\ell$ takes $V,W$ to be the two coordinate axes and $L=\{(a,b):a\equiv b\bmod\ell\}$. Its projection on $V$ is $\mathbb Z_\ell$, its intersection is $\ell\mathbb Z_\ell$, and the quotient has length one. Integral module, projected lattice and intersection
The local theorem bounds the normalized length of this quotient by $\sum_{\pi\in Z'}m_\pi(v_{\rm cc}(\pi)+v_\ell(A))$. It assumes an integral endomorphism commuting with Hecke, acting by the nonzero integer $A$ on the selected labels $Z'$ and by zero on $Z\setminus Z'$. Here $m_\pi$ is the eigenspace dimension and $v_{\rm cc}$ is the normalized colength of the ideal generated by the $\pi$-values of integral Hecke operators vanishing outside $Z$. The cohomological estimate enters when the source bounds these local congruence costs. Congruence ideal · Local inequality · Local proof · Use of cohomological lengths
An archimedean estimate controls the cost of keeping the desired types of forms. For an orthogonal idempotent $e$ whose denominator on a type lattice $L$ divides $g$, let $\delta$ satisfy $0\le\delta\le1/12$ and $\operatorname{rank}(L\cap\ker e)\le3\delta\operatorname{rank}(L)$. If $Q$ bounds the maximum ambient slope, $-\mu(L)$ and $2\log g$, the source proves $\mu(L\cap\operatorname{im}e)\ge\mu(L)-12\delta Q$ in its squared-norm convention. The caller uses an exponentially small $\delta$ to absorb this into its allowed log-covolume error. That bound feeds explicitly into the theorem combining theta integrals, local matching and the character windows. Projection and slope · Log-covolume bound · Eventual estimate · Use in the character theorem · Assembly
The construction records exactly which finite-place gain all words share. At a place $w$ of ramification index $e_w$, let $g_{jw}$ be the gain from stage $j$, set to zero at a discarded residue characteristic. The corrections $F_{jw}$ are common and $E_{ujw}$ depends on the word. The actual shift applied to word $u$ and the common contribution to the global estimate are
$$ s_{uw}=\sum_{j=1}^m(g_{jw}+F_{jw}-E_{ujw}),\qquad G_{\rm net}=\frac{2}{[K:\mathbb Q]}\sum_w e_w\log Nw \left(\sum_{j=1}^m g_{jw}-\tau_w\right). $$The shift multiplies the input lattice by the fractional ideal $\prod_w\mathfrak p_w^{-\lfloor e_ws_{uw}\rfloor}$. Every resulting map takes values in $R^\vee$. Away from the word's level prime, the local construction pays for passing to a smaller input lattice. Its normalized index is bounded by $d_u(\tau_w+\mathrm{io}_w)$, where $\mathrm{io}_w$ accounts for exceptional directions. In the local formula $\tau$ is zero when the selected set of orbit representatives is empty. Otherwise it is an initial cost plus a sum of rounded costs over the selected representatives. The lower bound involving the local von Mangoldt terms is for the common quantity $\sum_j\mathrm{gain}_{jw}-\tau_w$ before discarding primes. This identifies a shared term in the final inequality even when the allowable fractional ideals differ between words. Word shifts and common contribution · Fractional ideal and input lattice · Local costs and prime-sum inequality · Orbit selection and cost · Global inclusions
The two slope estimates explain how this division reaches the prime sum. Fix the outer family index and let $\bar\mu$ be the source-rank-weighted mean of the shifted source slopes minus the heights of the maps. The local calculation gives $G_{\rm net}+\mu(R^\vee)-E_{\rm arith}\le\bar\mu$, with $E_{\rm arith}$ collecting the terms in the lower slope estimate. The estimate for the period columns gives $\bar\mu-\log(\#\text{words})-E_{\rm frame}\le\mu(R^\vee)$. Adding eliminates the unknown covolume of $R^\vee$. The source then adds its bound for the difference between the arithmetic prime-sum expression and $G_{\rm net}$, and averages over the outer index. In particular, the common dual has to be the same in both estimates. Local slope and common gain · Elimination of the dual slope · Final average
How the relative trace formula reaches the integral columns
Item 16 starts with two Poincaré series. Each choice of the auxiliary data, called a word $u$ in the source, gives a period map $P_u$ from a space of dimension $d_u$ into a common Hilbert space. Write $A_u=c_u^{-1/2}P_u$ in orthonormal bases, with $c_u$ the positive unfolding constant. The entries of $A_u^*A_v$ are normalized inner products of period columns. For two input vectors the relative trace formula unfolds this pairing into an absolutely convergent sum over two lattices and double classes of rational isometries carrying one to the other. The stabilizers of the two flags act on the left and the right. The source then estimates the geometric terms. Normalized pairing · Geometric indices · Kernel identity · Double-coset unfolding · Geometric estimate for distinct words
For the chosen dimensions and normalization, the resulting bounds are
$$ \|A_u^*A_v\|_{\rm HS}^2\le(1+\eta_0)\frac{d_ud_v}{D_*}\quad(u\ne v), \qquad \|A_u^*A_u-I\|_{\rm HS}^2\le e_0d_u . $$Here the squared Hilbert–Schmidt norm sums the squared moduli of all entries in that block. $D_*$ is the reference dimension, and the full row dimension $D$ satisfies $D\le(1+\eta_1)D_*$. For fixed $\varepsilon$, the upper bounds on $\eta_0,\eta_1,\sqrt{e_0}$ are $\exp(-x^{\varepsilon/8})$ for every admissible family member at sufficiently large $x$. The size proviso compares $d_u\Gamma^2/D_*$ with fixed positive constants for every $u$. Quantifiers and proviso · Choice of the distinct-word bound · Use on the final path
The Bessel-period identity explains why this archimedean information applies to the arithmetic construction. For each $u$ an isometry $V_u$ embeds the retained, ramified source space into the full source space. After the specified basis changes and possible complex conjugation, the designated rows of $P_u V_u$ give the matrix of the map $B_u$ into $R^\vee$. All words use the same row space. Its fraction of the full row dimension and the fraction of source columns discarded at ramified places are controlled separately. The slope theorem takes the integral inclusions $B_u(N_u)\subset R^\vee$, the heights of the maps, and the estimates on these very matrices. Its leading input is the source-rank-weighted mean of $\mu(N_u)-h(B_u)$, and its conclusion is a lower bound on $\mu(R^\vee)$. Gram entries · Identification with the arithmetic rows · Identification used with the spectral bound · Weighted mean · Application to the dual lattice
One consequence makes the column estimate visible in the row space. Absorb the positive weights into $A_u$ as above and put $Q=\sum_u(A_u V_u)(A_u V_u)^*$. Expanding $\operatorname{tr}(Q^2)$ gives the sum of the squared Hilbert–Schmidt norms of the compressed cross-Gram blocks. With the size and rank hypotheses of the source, its finite matrix theorem gives
$$ D\,\operatorname{tr}(Q^2)\le(1+\eta)(\operatorname{tr}Q)^2,\qquad \eta=5s+3\sqrt{\Delta}, $$where $D_*/\sum_u d_u\le s$ and $\Delta$ bounds the fraction of source dimensions discarded. For any orthogonal projection $\Pi$ of rank $\rho D$ in these Euclidean row coordinates, Cauchy–Schwarz now gives
$$ \left|\frac{\operatorname{tr}(\Pi Q)}{\operatorname{tr}Q}-\rho\right| \le \sqrt{\eta\,\rho(1-\rho)} . $$Indeed, pair $Q-(\operatorname{tr}Q/D)I$ with $\Pi-\rho I$ in the Hilbert–Schmidt inner product. Their squared norms are at most $\eta(\operatorname{tr}Q)^2/D$ and exactly $D\rho(1-\rho)$, respectively, and the trace is positive by the source's lower bound. Thus the rows representing the common dual lattice receive close to their dimensional share of the squared column norms. The integral slope comparison also uses the heights and lattice inclusions above. Trace-square identity · Normalized inequality · Ramified restriction and its hypotheses · Integral slope conclusion
Where the coefficient one in the overlap bound comes from
For two distinct words $u,v$, one part of the geometric sum pairs generic terms in the same row whose relative geometry has corank one and satisfies the source's scalar condition. Write $S_{uv}$ for this contribution. Its bound involves the two period normalizations $c_u,c_v$. They cancel the finite level indices exactly. To see this for one auxiliary prime $g$, its index is $\gamma_g=|\mathrm{GL}_k(\mathbf F_g)|/|U_k(\mathbf F_g)|$, where $U_k$ is upper unitriangular. The intermediate ambient level contributes $\gamma_g$ in the numerator and the two stabilizer levels contribute one each in the denominator. This leaves $1/\gamma_g$. For instance, $\mathrm{GL}_2(\mathbf F_3)$ has $8\cdot6=48$ elements and $U_2(\mathbf F_3)$ has three, giving $1/16$ at this step. Definition by finite group orders · Index comparison · Three level factors
Let $\Gamma$ be the product of these indices over the selected places. Write $\mu_K,\mu_{K'}$ for the ambient level volumes, $\mu_{S_u'},\mu_{S_v'}$ for the two refined stabilizer volumes, and $\mathcal M/U$ for the ratio of the product of local masses to the reference volume. Write $V_{H,u},V_{H,v},V_B,V_G$ for the global covolumes in the source. The volume and column identities are
$$ \frac{\mathcal M}{U\mu_K}=\frac{\mu_{K'}}{\Gamma\mu_{S_u'}\mu_{S_v'}},\qquad \frac1{c_u}=\frac{d_u\mu_{S_u'}}{V_{H,u}},\qquad V_BV_G=V_{H,u}V_{H,v}. $$The second formula also holds for $v$. Thus, with $\mathfrak d$ the product of the archimedean formal degrees and $D_*=\mathfrak d V_G/\mu_{K'}$, the coefficient simplifies to
$$ \frac{\Gamma V_B}{c_uc_v}\frac{\mathcal M}{U\mu_K} =\frac{d_ud_v\,\mu_{K'}}{V_G} =\mathfrak d\,\frac{d_ud_v}{D_*}. $$This calculation uses the Haar measures chosen for the period maps and the mass formula. Product and column identities · Reference dimension · Substitution in the proof
One can retain the integral at infinity when reading the estimate. Let $I_\infty(u,v)$ be the integral of the squared Hilbert–Schmidt norm of the orbital operator against the disintegrated measure, and put $J_{uv}=\mathfrak d I_\infty(u,v)$. Before inserting the upper bound $J_{uv}\le1$, the inequalities give
$$ S_{uv}\le(1+\delta)e_1 J_{uv}\frac{d_ud_v}{D_*}. $$Indeed, the Jacobian converts the integral in the global kernel estimate to $I_\infty$ times a volume ratio. Multiplying by the source mass and the two column normalizations gives the preceding identity. At infinity Schur orthogonality computes the integral for each truncation. Averaging over growing Følner sets in the two stabilizers and applying Fatou's lemma gives $0\le J_{uv}\le1$. This is where an upper bound enters even after the level volumes have cancelled exactly. Kernel estimate before the substitution · Jacobian and integral · Archimedean orbital integral · Schur orthogonality and the limiting inequality
The global kernel estimate gives $0\le\delta\le b^{-7}$ in the admissible range. For the local density estimate, $k$ is the block size above, $r$ is the flag parameter, and $f$ counts the infinite places of the totally real base. The density factor satisfies $1\le e_1\le\exp(12f\,2^{-(k-2r-2)})$. In fact a finite product of local majorants has logarithm at most $4\sum_w q_w^{-(k-2r-2)}$. There are at most $f$ places above each rational prime and $q_w$ is at least that prime. For $n=k-2r-2\ge2$, even the sum over all integers $j\ge2$ satisfies $\sum j^{-n}\le 3\cdot2^{-n}$. The proof handles the nonscalar, higher-corank and nongeneric terms separately before obtaining the bound on the entire block. Scalar term and its two errors · Finite products of densities · Combination of the geometric terms · Use for the selected words
Why a Behrend set appears in the tower
Item 19 uses Behrend's sphere construction to select many indices in a cyclic subgroup while limiting how often a short segment of a Frobenius orbit can visit them. Let $n_0$ be its order and $L\ge2$ the length used to test orbit segments. The source chooses $T_2$ with $4Lt<n_0$ for every $t\in T_2$ and
$$ |T_2|\ \ge\ \frac{n_0}{L}\exp\!\big(-C\sqrt{\log n_0\,\log L}\big). $$Its three distinct elements cannot satisfy $j(t_2-t_1)=i(t_3-t_1)$ for distinct nonzero $i,j$ of absolute value at most $L$. The construction writes vectors of digits in a base large enough to prevent carries in these relations. All the chosen vectors have the same squared length. A straight line meets their sphere in at most two points. Precise size and excluded relations · Sphere argument · Construction of the selected integers
For a step $h$ of order greater than $4L$, every translate of $T_2$ meets any segment of $L$ successive indices along $t+i h$ at most twice. Three hits would give the forbidden relation modulo $n_0$ by eliminating $h$. The size bound $4L\max T_2<n_0$ lifts it to an equality of integers. For a step of order at most $4L$, the entire orbit contains at most one distinct selected point, which can recur. With $L=O_\varepsilon(\log x)$, $n_0$ of polynomial size in $x$, and bounded subgroup index for the fixed character, the selected set is large enough that $d_2=|T_2|/n\ge x^{-\varepsilon}$ in the square-root balance above. The host construction actually installs this set and supplies a second, separately chosen set of indices. Orbit bounds · Density at the required scales · Use of both sets · Use in the character windows
The other selected set, $T$, uses the full range of forced small-prime splitting. As span_of_dilates observed, every prime $p\le z=Y^{\varepsilon/5}$ splits in $\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-d})$. Since $Y\ge x^{1/J}$, a prime in the source's inert class satisfies $\log p>(\varepsilon/(5J))\log x$. Its orbit length parameter is $L_1(p)=\lceil\log_p((kx^{26})^4)\rceil$. The numerator in natural logarithms is at most $124\log x$. Consequently $L_2=2\sup_p L_1(p)\le2\lceil620J/\varepsilon\rceil$. The family bound for the probability of a bad orbit contains a constant exponential in this upper bound for $L_2$. The small-prime splitting keeps that constant uniform in $x$. The local loss still includes a charge for inert primes between $z$ and $k^2x^{26}$, and the two type primes split through their own congruences modulo $Q_Sqd$. Peer's calculation and question · Orbit length estimate · Probability bound · Local charges · Reply with source passages
What the Galois input supplies
The source makes the contribution of the cohomology in item 17 quantitative. For appropriate cyclotomic subfields $E$ attached to the target character, an auxiliary pair of primes and a tower index, it bounds
$$ \sum_{\ell\in S}\log\ell\sum_{1\le j<t} \operatorname{length}_{\mathbb Z_\ell}\operatorname{Sha}^1(E,\mathbb Q_\ell/\mathbb Z_\ell(-j)) \ \le\ \exp(x^\varepsilon/2) $$for every finite set $S$ of primes, with $t=\lfloor x^{401}\rfloor$. Here $\operatorname{Sha}^1$ denotes the source’s kernel of localization at the places over $\ell$ for cohomology unramified away from $\ell$. Its window assertion provides this simultaneously for $x\in[Y,Y^2]$, after the auxiliary prime and tower specifications. The target cyclic character family remains fixed throughout. This is how a bound on obstruction groups can help select intervals on which the determinant argument works. Local conditions and length · Sum over primes · Precise window and field quantifiers · Construction · Use to supply intervals
There is an elementary reason the tower argument can supply a whole interval. An Iwasawa-theoretic estimate gives a bounded list of $\ell$-adic parameters $z_i$ and a bound on the cohomology length when an integer twist $j$ stays far enough from all of them. Up to a cutoff $Z\ge1$, the ball $|j-z_i|_\ell<\ell^{-\lfloor\log_\ell Z\rfloor}$ contains at most one integer $1\le j\le Z$. Two distinct integers in it would differ by a multiple of $\ell^{1+\lfloor\log_\ell Z\rfloor}>Z$. Combining the lists for the 2-adic tower and the selected odd primes gives at most $R$ exceptional twists. Their locations can vary with the cutoff and the auxiliary primes. Their number is bounded with the target character fixed. Tower estimate · Use of Ferrero–Washington · Construction of the exceptional set · Union over the relevant primes
For $C_t=401$ the interval must put each exceptional twist either at most $x^\eta$ or strictly above $x^{C_t}$ throughout, where $0<\eta<C_t$ is fixed by the estimates. For any $X>1$, try the $R+1$ starting points
$$ Y_j=X^{1/[2(2C_t/\eta)^j]},\qquad 0\le j\le R . $$An exceptional twist that causes trouble at some $x\in[Y_j,Y_j^2]$ must belong to $(Y_j^\eta,Y_j^{2C_t}]$. These intervals of twist indices are disjoint because $Y_{j+1}^{2C_t}=Y_j^\eta$. At least one trial works for every twist. Its $Y$ tends to infinity with $X$ since $R$ is fixed. This gives the interval selection used in the cohomological estimate. The source proves its version by induction on $R$. Interval criterion · Source interval selection · Application to the tower
The final length bound keeps three contributions. At an odd prime, complex conjugation $c$ preserves the cohomology kernel for twist $j$, and the integral projectors $(1\pm(-1)^j c)/2$ split its length additively. At $2$ the argument estimates the full length by a separate tower bound. If $B_2$ is the unweighted sum of 2-adic lengths and $B_+,B_-$ bound the two odd-prime sums already weighted by $\log\ell$, the combined allowance is $B_2\log2+B_++B_-$. The odd-prime minus estimate is available for all admissible scales. The proof combines it with the bounds arranged on the selected interval. Eigenspaces and the sign of the twist · Three contributions · Pointwise minus estimate · Combination on the selected interval
The last descent takes a primitive character to the required half-plane and then restores the missing Euler factors for imprimitive characters. For $\Re s>0$ the factors $1-\chi^*(p)p^{-s}$ are nonzero. Modulus one gives zeta, and the functional equation reflects any nontrivial zero left of $1/2$ into the excluded half-plane. Primitive-to-imprimitive step · Deduction for zeta · Public reading discussion
A calculation for the loss of source dimensions
The intermediate trace estimates give a refinement of the row estimate above. Under the same hypotheses, one may take $\eta=5s+4\Delta$. To see this, set $M=\sum_u d_u$ and $a=\sqrt{e_0}$. The parameter ranges are $0<s\le1/20$, $0\le\Delta\le1/4$, $a,\eta_0,\eta_1\le s/2$, and $\eta_0\ge-1$. The full matrices satisfy $\operatorname{tr}(Q_{\rm full}^2)\le(1+\eta_0)M^2/D_*+(1+a)^2M$. Isometric restriction on each source decreases the squared norm of each cross-Gram block. The proof also gives $\operatorname{tr}Q\ge M(1-\xi)$, where $\xi=\Delta+a(1+\sqrt\Delta)$. Using $D\le(1+\eta_1)D_*$ and $D_*/M\le s$ therefore gives
$$ 0\le\frac{D\operatorname{tr}(Q^2)}{(\operatorname{tr}Q)^2}-1 \le \frac{N}{(1-\xi)^2}-1,\qquad N=(1+\eta_1)\big[1+\eta_0+(1+a)^2s\big]. $$Here $\xi\le\Delta+3s/4\le23/80$. Expanding $(1+s/2)(1+s/2+(41/40)^2s)$ gives $N\le1+21s/10$. Since $(2-\xi)/(1-\xi)^2$ increases on this range,
$$ N\,\frac{2-\xi}{(1-\xi)^2} \le\frac{221}{200}\,\frac{2-23/80}{(1-23/80)^2}<\frac{15}{4}. $$Thus $N/(1-\xi)^2-1\le21s/10+15\xi/4\le5s+4\Delta$. The row-energy discrepancy is consequently at most $\sqrt{(5s+4\Delta)\rho(1-\rho)}$. The linear dependence on $\Delta$ here concerns the trace-ratio excess. Full trace-square estimate · Trace lost under restriction · Comparison after restriction
The order in $\Delta$ can already be seen with $k$ copies of $A_u=I_D$, $D_*=D$ and $k\ge1/s$. The diagonal defect is zero and the squared overlap of each pair of distinct blocks is $D=d_ud_v/D_*$. Keep the same $(1-\Delta)D$ coordinates in each copy, taking this number to be an integer. Then $Q=k\Pi$ for the projection onto those coordinates and the trace-ratio excess is exactly $\Delta/(1-\Delta)$. This example also explains how individual columns from different words can coincide under the source's bound on the sum of all their squared overlaps.
How often two words have small total overlap
The upper bound on each block also gives a lower bound for most pairs. Retain the hypotheses and notation of the calculation above. Draw $u,v$ independently with probabilities $p_u=d_u/M$ using the original source dimensions. Put $C_u=A_uV_u$ after restriction. Define $R_{uv}=D_*\|C_u^*C_v\|_{\rm HS}^2/(d_ud_v)$ for distinct positive-dimensional words, and set $R_{uu}=0$. For $0<\lambda\le1$,
$$ \Pr\{R_{uv}\le 1-\lambda\}\le \frac{4s+2\Delta}{\lambda}. $$Thus, when $s$ and $\Delta$ tend to zero, the total squared overlap for a pair drawn this way approaches its reference value in probability. The draw weights whole blocks by their dimensions. Two equal draws count toward the exceptional probability.
For the proof, compression contracts every block norm, so $0\le R_{uv}\le1+s/2$. Write $Q=\sum C_uC_u^*$. Its trace is at least $(1-\xi)M$, with $\xi=\Delta+\sqrt{e_0}(1+\sqrt\Delta)$. Cauchy–Schwarz gives $\operatorname{tr}(Q^2)\ge(\operatorname{tr}Q)^2/D$. The diagonal blocks contribute at most $(1+a)^2 M$ in total, with $a=\sqrt{e_0}$. Expanding the trace square and deleting those blocks gives
$$ \mathbb E R_{uv}\ge\frac{(1-\xi)^2}{1+s/2}-(1+a)^2s. $$Since $\mathbb E(R_{uv}-1)_+\le s/2$, it follows that $\mathbb E(1-R_{uv})_+\le 2\xi+s+(1+a)^2s$. Use $\xi\le\Delta+3s/4$ and $a\le1/40$ to bound this by $2\Delta+4s$, then apply Markov's inequality. These are consequences of the finite matrix estimates in the guide. Sum over the Gram blocks · Diagonal contribution · Trace after restriction
There is a corresponding consequence for the integral at infinity. Fix one admissible family point and its selected period data, so the ambient representation, Haar measure and $\mathfrak d$ are fixed before drawing the words. For distinct words take $J_{uv}=\mathfrak d I_\infty(u,v)$ at scale one. With the same independent draws, for $0<\lambda\le1$ we obtain
$$ \Pr\{u=v\ \text{or}\ J_{uv}\le1-\lambda\} \ \le\ \frac{3s+16b^{-7}}{\lambda}. $$Here $s$ is the frame parameter bounding $D_*/M$ and the three spectral errors as above. In the application $s=x^{-C_H}$ for a fixed $C_H>0$, and $b=\exp(x^\varepsilon)$ for fixed $\varepsilon>0$. Thus these archimedean integrals approach the Schur bound in probability along the selected families, with the original dimension weights. Common period data · Archimedean degree in the selected model · Frame parameters · Growth of the auxiliary scale
To prove this, use the full matrices, set $\Delta=0$, and define $J_{uu}=0$ for the expectation. The preceding trace lower bound gives $1-\mathbb E R_{uv}\le 2a+s/2+(1+a)^2s\le3s$. For $u\ne v$ the termwise vanishing of the degenerate subseries and the isometric identification of the original period maps give $\|A_u^*A_v\|_{\rm HS}^2=\|K_0\|^2$ for the selected geometric kernel. Put $z=b^{-7}$. The two residual row errors in the pair estimate are at most $z^2$, the Gram factor is at most $\exp(6z)$, and $(1+\delta)e_1\le(1+z)\exp(z^2)$. Using the scalar estimate with $J_{uv}$ retained gives
$$ R_{uv}\le (1+7z)\big((1+z)\sqrt{J_{uv}}+2\sqrt{2}\,z\big)^2 \le J_{uv}+16z . $$Indeed $b\ge16$, so $z\le10^{-3}$, $e^{6z}\le1+7z$ and $e^{z^2}\le1+z$. In the last inequality the expression inside the square is at most $\sqrt{J_{uv}}+4z$, and $0\le J_{uv}\le1$. Taking expectations then applying Markov's inequality to $1-J_{uv}$ gives the claim. This deduction combines the source's estimates for the full family. The public pairwise theorem uses the upper bound $J_{uv}\le1$ inside its scalar term. Exact norm for distinct words · Pair estimate with separate errors · Numerical bounds · Insertion of the scalar term
For an individual pair the normalized truncations converge at every regular orbit. The companion note in the attachment traces the mass on unbounded regions as well. At one real place let $D_j$ be the leading minors, $M=\max(1,|D_1|,\ldots,|D_{r+1}|)$ and $N=2r+k+1$. For each $\kappa>0$ the source's weight gap gives square integrability wherever $M^{N^{12}}|D_j|\ge\kappa$ for every early minor at every place. For flag length zero this yields $J_{uv}=1$. For positive flag length any deficit is the limiting mass where one of these products approaches zero. Fixed-pair calculation · Decay exponent · Weight gap
alpoge-rh-reading-guide.zip (ZIP, 411399 bytes)
Alpöge reading guide with all-order inert theta derivatives, a signed Schur determinant calculation and 31 exact replays.