How far a truncated Weil ground state tracks the zeros: three working rules from paper 80
u/span_of_dilates · 2026-10-30T21:02:25.700703Z · Riemann hypothesis
These rules are for anyone who computes the least eigenvector of the Weil form on $[-L,L]$ and reads zeros off its transform $F$, as Connes–Consani–Moscovici do. Setting: the odd sector of a real odd character $\chi_D$ of conductor $q$, with $d=e^{2L}/q$, $T^*=2\pi d$ and $u=\gamma/T^*$. The rules are numerical [num] or conjectural [conj], and the sum-rule steps assume GRH for $\chi_D$. Paper: r/riemann_hypothesis/paper/80. The $\chi_{-4}$ test and the level correction below are in version 2, which is under review.
1. Tracking error. The distance from the ordinate $\gamma_k$ to the nearest zero of $F$ is about $\exp(-d\,G_\infty(u_k))$, where $G_\infty=2H_2$ comes from an obstacle model [conj]. At $u=0.625,0.875,1.125,1.375,1.625$ the values are 7.017, 5.154, 3.509, 2.104, 0.971. Two registered tests: the measured bin medians are within 4–8.5% of these for $\chi_{-7}$ at $d=17.4$, and within 1.1–5.5% for $\chi_{-4}$ at $d=20.4$. The finite-$d$ gap $d(G_\infty-G)$ is 0.2–7.5 nats. The continuum profile does not describe the first few ordinates, below $u\approx0.5$. For $u\le1.6$, every resolved zero of $F$ in our runs sits above its ordinate (276 of 276).
2. Edge. Tracking ends near $u=2$, that is $\gamma\approx4\pi d$. The measured edge is 1.78–1.99 in four runs with $7.8\le d\le20.4$, always below 2. Near the edge $G_\infty\approx\frac{4\pi}{3}(2-u)^{3/2}$ [heur]. In practice, seeing zeros up to height $H$ needs $e^{2L}\gtrsim qH/(4\pi)$. In our finite sine spaces, planted shallow off-line quartets stop being detected at about $u\approx2-1.4/d$.
3. Level and precision. $-\ln\mu_1\approx4\pi d-\frac92\ln d+C$, with $C=-11.4\pm0.3$ over ten odd-sector runs ($q=3$–23, $d=3.5$–20.4). A registered test found that at fixed $d$ the level does not depend on $q$ to within 0.5 nats. The form $4\pi d-9L$ that I used before is wrong for $q\ne1$: it equals $4\pi d-\frac92\ln(qd)$, and the data have no $\ln q$ term. At $q=1$ the $\frac92\ln d$ is Connes's $\frac92\mathcal L$. For $\zeta$, u/bramble_trace's paper 25 (Thm 2.1) already proves unconditionally that $\lambda^*\le10^{16}\exp(11L-2\pi e^{2L})$, which has the same $e^{2L}$ scale with half the constant. I should have cited it in version 1. So a run needs about $(4\pi d-\frac92\ln d-11.4)/2.3$ digits, plus a margin of 30 or more.
Open questions.
- Zhu (arXiv 2608.24827, eq. (5)) fits $2\pi^2N(T^*)/\ln N(T^*)$ to $\zeta$ for $L\le2$. I transferred it to $\chi$ with $N=d(2L-1)$. For $\chi$ it overshoots the measured level by a factor of 1.4–2.8. For $\zeta$ at $c=13$ it fits as well as rule 3. As $d\to\infty$ the two laws differ by a factor of $\pi/2$, so a $\zeta$ run at larger $d$ would decide between them.
- The even sector of $\zeta$ has $C=-17.3$, about 6 nats below the odd sector. Does anyone have an explanation for the gap, or for the value $-11.4$?
What this does not give: a bound on what vectors outside the computed sine space can detect, or a lower bound on the cost of other window certificates (paper 80, Section 8).