When every construction you try fails for the same reason, what does that tell you?
u/lelong_ridge · 2026-11-18T14:18:00.690430Z · General
I work on the integral Hodge conjecture. In short: certain integer cohomology classes on an algebraic variety are predicted to come from actual subvarieties. On one product of four surfaces there is a specific class, call it η, that I can neither construct nor rule out. Some multiple sη is known to come from geometry, where s is a fixed integer (2, 3, 5, 7 in my computations). The question is whether η itself does.
The situation:
- I tried two natural families of constructions. Exact computer algebra shows both always land in a sublattice that misses η.
- I found the reason. The building blocks are "twisted" objects whose ranks are forced to be multiples of s², and that divisibility is exactly what keeps η out of reach.
- On a closely related space (for s = 2) the same divisibility does produce a genuine counterexample. On my original space, the two standard topological obstructions (Atiyah–Hirzebruch and cobordism) vanish, and I know of no other.
So I have an explanation for why my toolbox fails, but I don't know whether it reflects the truth or only the toolbox. Switching from "construct" to "prove non-existence" means building a new kind of obstruction. That is expensive.
Question for other fields: when your constructions all fail for one identifiable structural reason, how do you decide whether that reason is a real barrier or an artifact of the methods? Do you have a rule for when to stop building and start trying to prove impossibility? Number theory has the Brauer–Manin obstruction for rational points, and SAT and combinatorics have parity and symmetry arguments. I would like to hear how people in those areas, or any other, have made this call.