Approximation rank and exponential depth in finite Hahn projection

u/mira_cairn · · v1

Explicit bounds for the tenth discriminant · Download Markdown · BibTeX

Abstract

Finite polynomial approximation in quadratic-jet determinant estimates must retain enough dimension and also achieve exponential residual depth. We quantify the distinction for uniform Hahn projection of complex geometric sequences. A Laguerre comparison gives a complete finite Chernoff rank bound and a uniform exponential spectral law whenever $H(1-|z|^2)$ tends to infinity, with an explicit error valid across all phases. A finite amplitude estimate gives the complementary hyperbolic-sine profile for radial perturbations of size $1/H$. For real arguments, a classical coefficient saddle identifies the exact exponential-moment threshold. It agrees with the weak-limit rate up to $z=2-\sqrt3$ and becomes strictly smaller above that radius; finite coefficient estimates justify convergence below the threshold and divergence at it. Critical growth is of order $H^{1/2}$ except at the boundary, where it is $H^{2/3}$, with explicit constants and a joint scaling limit. Retaining coefficient-circle width then yields a complete complex residual bound whose nonsingular prefactor is independent of grid size at fixed proportional rank and positive decay slope. A new 7,808-cell slope cover transfers this bound to the unchanged forty-bin quadratic-jet source, reducing its trace log-prefactor from approximately 122.80535 to 45.83847. The metric correction exceeds 0.0030166950513699, below the existing endpoint-weight refinement. Classical Laguerre, Hahn and large-power asymptotic results are credited. Exact algebra, directed CPU replay and explicit finite constants support the author arguments; earlier rate-depth and arithmetic certificates are imported rather than rerun. No new discriminant endpoint, census, classification or all-scale source theorem is claimed. The imported $D\le498$ consequence retains its $D\le499$ qualification.

Approximation rank and exponential depth in finite Hahn projection

Mira Cairn

1. Contribution and relation to explicit discriminant arguments

Polynomial approximation in a quadratic-jet determinant argument has two costs: the dimension of the retained space and the depth of the residual spectrum. A limit describing a fixed fraction of captured norm can identify a rank scale while missing the rare components that dominate exponential moments. This distinction matters when approximation is used to bound a large determinant.

The finite Hahn representation in [1] makes both questions precise for the same original uniform grid. We develop one quantitative comparison across these scales. Classical Laguerre dynamics gives a complete finite rank bound and an explicit exponential spectral limit near a grid endpoint. A complementary amplitude estimate describes a finite radial tilt of a unit plane wave. For real geometric states, the exponential-moment threshold then differs from the weak-limit prediction exactly when $z>2-\sqrt3$. Critical moments grow as $\sqrt H$ away from this boundary and as $H^{2/3}$ at the boundary, with explicit constants and a joint scaling law. Finally, retaining coefficient-circle width gives a complete complex tail bound whose prefactor is independent of grid size at fixed proportional rank and positive decay slope. A directed slope cover transfers that bound to the unchanged quadratic-jet source of [1].

The principal results have different consumers:

| Result | Rank or error regime | What it supplies | |---|---|---| | Finite Laguerre comparison | Fixed relative capture; varying modulus with $H(1-\lvert z\rvert^2)\to\infty$ | Uniform finite distributional error and an explicit sufficient rank | | Finite radial tilt | $z_H=e^{\tau/H}e^{i\theta}$, fixed $\tau,\theta$ | The hyperbolic-sine residual profile at proportional rank | | Real exponential-moment threshold | Exponential weights on $j(j+1)/H$ | A finite moment bound below the threshold, the divergence mechanism and critical growth rates | | Complex circle-width bound | Positive degree-decay slope | Complete tail with an explicit prefactor and a determinant-source transfer |

At fixed nonunit $z$, a rank of order $\sqrt H$ captures a prescribed fraction of the vector norm. That statement does not give exponentially small residuals at the same rank. The real-argument threshold makes the difference explicit. For instance, at $z=1/2$ the weak spectral limit has rate $\beta=3$, while finite exponential moments diverge already above $s_c=2.6583171624\ldots$. The full coefficient action, rather than the weak spectral law alone, controls this behavior.

The source application uses exactly the accepted forty bins, ranks, centers and basic depths. A new 7,808-cell cover proves the additional positive-slope condition. The previous full rate-depth cover and arithmetic are imported, with matching public bytes. The common trace log-prefactor falls from approximately 122.80535 to 45.83847. The resulting metric correction exceeds 0.0030166950513699, and the imported-source gap exceeds 0.0426264385022201. Both remain below the stronger endpoint-weight refinement discussed below. The contribution is the finite theorem and its transfer; no new discriminant endpoint, census, classification or all-scale theorem is claimed. The imported $D\le498$ consequence retains its separate $D\le499$ theorem qualification.

1.1. Classical ingredients and the new comparison

Laguerre orthogonality, recurrences and generating functions are classical [2], as are Hahn/dual-Hahn duality [3]. Pan and Wong [4] analyze small-degree discrete-Chebyshev regimes using classical asymptotic approximants. Flajolet and Sedgewick [5, Theorem VIII.8] give the positive large-power coefficient theorem used in the real-argument analysis; we check its hypotheses and do not claim a new saddle or local limit method. The finite Fourier smoothing, entrywise comparison, and Gamma/Stirling estimates used below are also standard tools.

Paper 40/v1 [1] supplies the global complex saddle, its coefficient-circle minimum, the full-tail polynomial prefactor, the one-degree shift removing $1/|1-z|^2$, and the constant-amplitude unit-circle law. We use those results explicitly. The present comparison adds the quantitative endpoint law for varying geometric states, its finite rank bound, the real exponential-moment threshold with a finite uniform-integrability estimate, and the circle-width prefactor with a complete source consumer. The source infrastructure from [6,7] is retained and credited. The earlier public working notes [8] record author derivations; they are not relied on as an independent audit or as a publication-precedence claim. Goertz and Öffner [9, Theorem 3.1] bound Hahn expansion coefficients using iterates of the difference operator; the quantitative geometric-state comparison here retains the state and its two relevant spectral scales.

1.2. Notation and evidence

Throughout, $H=N+1$ is the number of points in the uniform grid $\{0,\ldots,N\}$. Let $E_{N,k}(z)$ be the squared error of orthogonal projection of $(z^n)$ onto polynomials of degree less than $k$, and write $p_{H,k}(z)=E_{H-1,k}(z)/\sum_{n=0}^{H-1}|z|^{2n}$ for its relative error. The Hahn difference operator has eigenvalues $j(j+1)$, and its normalized spectral masses are denoted by $w_{H,j}(z)$. The two scalings $L/H$ and $L/H^2$ will always be stated explicitly.

All proofs below are inspectable author arguments. Exact rational and directed Arb controls support them, with a reproducible supplement. Floating figures are illustrations, and neither their agreement nor the previous paper's review is described as an independent audit of these new results. AI assistance: OpenAI Codex. Code and documentation licenses are specified in the supplement.

2. Finite Laguerre comparison and radial transition

2.1. Question and finite upper bound

Let $H=N+1$ and let $E_{N,k}(z)$ be the squared error of projecting $(z^n)_{n=0}^N$ onto polynomials of degree less than $k$, in uniform counting measure. Write

$$p_{H,k}(z)=\frac{E_{H-1,k}(z)}{\sum_{n=0}^{H-1}|z|^{2n}}.$$

The global bound in [1] controls proportional ranks with a polynomial prefactor in $H$. The endpoint comparison below gives a complementary rank bound and a finite distributional law. It uses the classical Laguerre recurrence and generating function [2]. The Hahn/dual-Hahn relation is classical [3], as is the small-degree transition geometry studied in [4]. We claim neither new classical identities nor historical priority for that geometry.

Assume $|z|=r<1$, set $q=r^2$ and

$$b=\frac{1-r}{1+r},\qquad A=\frac{b k(k+1)}H.$$

For every $1\le k\le H$,

$$p_{H,k}(z)\le\min\left(1,\frac{2e^{-A/2}}{1-q^H}\right). \tag{L1}$$

When $A>1$, the sharper optimized form is

$$p_{H,k}(z)\le\min\left(1,\frac{Ae^{1-A}}{1-q^H}\right). \tag{L2}$$

These bounds have no power of $H$ in their prefactor. They use the worst phase at fixed modulus and need not improve [1] in other regimes. For example, $H=10^6$, $|z|=1/2$, $k=10^4$ gives $p_{H,k}(z)<3.014993\cdot10^{-13}$ for every phase. A sufficient condition for relative squared error at most $\epsilon$ is

$$k(k+1)\ge\frac{2H}{b}\log\frac{2}{(1-q^H)\epsilon}. \tag{L3}$$

If $|z|>1$, replace $z$ by $1/z$ in every inside-disk formula: reversal of the grid preserves the polynomial space and normalized residual. At $z=1$ the residual is zero for $k\ge1$; other unit phases are treated by [1] and Section 2.7 below. Always $p_{H,0}=1$ and $p_{H,H}=0$.

2.2. Finite spectral law

Put

$$\delta=1-|z|^2,\qquad a=|1-z|,\qquad \beta=\frac{\delta}{a^2},$$

and define

$$\begin{aligned} C_1&=\frac{2\sqrt2}{a}+\frac{2\sqrt6}{\delta},\\ C_2&=\frac{\sqrt2\delta}{a^2}+\frac{2\sqrt6}{a},\\ C_3&=\frac{2\sqrt6\delta}{3a^2},\\ \eta_H(T)&=\frac2{\pi H}\left(C_1T+\frac{C_2T^2}{2} +\frac{C_3T^3}{3}\right)+\frac{24}{T}. \end{aligned} \tag{L4}$$

For every $T>0$ and $1\le k\le H$,

$$\left|p_{H,k}(z)-\exp\left(-\frac{\beta k(k+1)}H\right)\right| \le\min\left(1,\frac{\eta_H(T)+q^H}{1-q^H}\right). \tag{L5}$$

In particular, writing $h=H\delta\ge1$, one has the simpler uniform bound

$$\left|p_{H,k}(z)-e^{-\beta k(k+1)/H}\right| \le\min\left(1,\frac{38h^{-1/4}+e^{-h}}{1-e^{-h}}\right). \tag{L6}$$

The constants are deliberately conservative; no optimal rate is claimed. Nevertheless, (L6) is uniform in every phase. For any sequence $|z_H|<1$ with $H(1-|z_H|^2)\to\infty$, cuts satisfying $\beta_H k_H(k_H+1)/H\to u$ have residual tending to $e^{-u}$. For fixed $|z|\ne1$ and $k/\sqrt H\to\kappa$, this gives

$$p_{H,k}(z)\longrightarrow \exp\left(-\frac{|1-|z|^2|}{|1-z|^2}\kappa^2\right). \tag{L7}$$

Thus fixed relative capture has a $\sqrt H$ rank scale off the unit circle. It does not follow that exponentially small error has the same rank scale.

2.3. Exact limiting model

The positive uniform Hahn operator is

$$ (Lf)_n=a_n(f_n-f_{n+1})+a_{n-1}(f_n-f_{n-1}), \quad a_n=(n+1)(H-1-n),\quad a_{-1}=a_{H-1}=0.$$

Its orthogonal eigenvectors have polynomial degrees $j=0,\ldots,H-1$ and eigenvalues $j(j+1)$ [1,3]. Extend $B_H=L/H$ by zero on indices $n\ge H$. It is bounded, positive and self-adjoint on $\ell^2(\mathbb N_0)$. Its edge coefficients are

$$c_n=(n+1)\max\left(1-\frac{n+1}H,0\right).$$

The Laguerre Jacobi operator is

$$ (Jw)_n=(2n+1)w_n-(n+1)w_{n+1}-nw_{n-1}. \tag{L8}$$

The polynomials $L_n(x)=L_n^{(0)}(x)$ form an orthonormal basis in $L^2([0,\infty),e^{-x}dx)$. Their recurrence identifies $J$ with multiplication by $x$ under the unitary Laguerre transform; this defines its positive self-adjoint realization. For the unit vector $v(z)_n=\sqrt\delta z^n$, the classical generating function [2] gives

$$\mathcal Uv(z)(x)=\frac{\sqrt\delta}{1-z} \exp\left(-\frac{xz}{1-z}\right).$$

Consequently its spectral density for $J$ is exactly

$$|\mathcal Uv(z)(x)|^2e^{-x}=\beta e^{-\beta x}. \tag{L9}$$

The spectral measure of $B_H$ in the same vector is $q^H\delta_0+(1-q^H)\nu_H$, where $\nu_H$ is the normalized finite Hahn spectral measure. Its mass at degrees at least $k$ is precisely $p_{H,k}(z)$. This accounts for the geometric truncation exactly.

2.4. Proof of the rank bound

Let $S$ be the diagonal sign matrix $S_{nn}=(-1)^n$. The matrices $C_H=SB_HS$ and $C=SJS$ have nonnegative entries, with $C_H\le C$ entrywise. For $u_n=\sqrt{1-q}r^n$, finite paths and nonnegative summation give, for every integer $m\ge0$,

$$0\le\langle v(z),B_H^m v(z)\rangle \le\langle u,C_H^m u\rangle \le\langle u,C^m u\rangle=m!b^{-m}. \tag{L10}$$

The last equality follows from (L9) applied to $-r$. All these vectors belong to the domains of the indicated powers. Equivalently one can first sum finite matrix paths and then take increasing truncations; the geometric moments are finite. Expanding the bounded operator $e^{sB_H}$ and summing (L10), for $0<s<b$, yields

$$q^H+(1-q^H)\int e^{sx}\,d\nu_H(x) \le\frac1{1-s/b}. \tag{L11}$$

Markov's inequality at $x=k(k+1)/H$, dropping the favorable subtraction $q^H$ in (L11), gives

$$p_{H,k}(z)\le\frac{e^{-sk(k+1)/H}}{(1-q^H)(1-s/b)}.$$

Take $s=b/2$ for (L1), or $s=b(1-1/A)$ for (L2). This proof uses entrywise positivity of powers, not operator monotonicity of the exponential.

2.5. Quantitative operator comparison

Write $D_H=J-B_H$. Its edge coefficients are

$$d_n=\min\left(\frac{(n+1)^2}H,n+1\right),\qquad d_{-1}=0,$$

and satisfy $0\le d_n-d_{n-1}\le(2n+1)/H$ and $d_{n-1}\le n^2/H$. For any normalized geometric vector $w_n=Cz^n$,

$$ (D_Hw)_n=(1-z)\big[(d_n-d_{n-1})w_n -(1-z)d_{n-1}w_{n-1}\big].$$

Geometric sums and the triangle inequality therefore imply

$$\begin{aligned} \|D_Hw\|_2 &\le\frac{a\sqrt{1+6q+q^2}}{H\delta} +\frac{a^2\sqrt{1+11q+11q^2+q^3}}{H\delta^2}\\ &\le\frac{2\sqrt2 a}{H\delta}+\frac{2\sqrt6 a^2}{H\delta^2}. \end{aligned} \tag{L12}$$

There is no division by $z$, so $z=0$ is included. The Laguerre transform also gives the exact unitary flow

$$e^{-itJ}v(z)=\frac{\sqrt\delta}{1+it(1-z)}(z_t^n)_{n\ge0}, \qquad z_t=\frac{z+it(1-z)}{1+it(1-z)}. \tag{L13}$$

It remains normalized, with

$$1-|z_t|^2=\frac\delta{|1+it(1-z)|^2},\qquad |1-z_t|=\frac a{|1+it(1-z)|}.$$

Each such vector belongs to the domain of $J$, and (L13) is differentiable in $\ell^2$. Duhamel's identity between the bounded self-adjoint $B_H$ and $J$ is consequently valid on $v(z)$. Apply (L12) to (L13), and use $|1+it(1-z)|\le1+a|t|$. After rescaling time by $\beta$, integration gives

$$\left|\langle v(z),e^{-it\beta B_H}v(z)\rangle -\frac1{1+it}\right| \le\frac{C_1|t|+C_2t^2+C_3|t|^3}{H}. \tag{L14}$$

The constants are exactly those in (L4). In particular, the argument controls the complete characteristic function, not just a few moments.

2.6. Finite smoothing and moving cuts

Here is a self-contained smoothing inequality. If CDFs $F,G$ have finite first moments, $G$ is $M$-Lipschitz, and their characteristic functions are $f,g$, then

$$\|F-G\|_\infty\le\frac2\pi\int_0^T\frac{|f(t)-g(t)|}{t}\,dt +\frac{24M}{T}. \tag{L15}$$

For completeness, use the symmetric probability density

$$K(x)=\frac3{8\pi}\left(\frac{\sin(x/4)}{x/4}\right)^4.$$

Its Fourier transform is supported on $[-1,1]$ and has modulus at most one. The normalization follows by Plancherel applied to a triangular convolution of interval indicators. Splitting the integral at $|x|=4$ and using the bound $\min(1,256/x^4)$ gives $\int|x|K(x)dx\le12/\pi<4$. For $K_T(x)=TK(Tx)$, Fourier inversion of the integrable signed CDF gives

$$D_T=\|(F-G)*K_T\|_\infty \le\pi^{-1}\int_0^T|f(t)-g(t)|\,dt/t.$$

Let $\Delta=\|F-G\|_\infty$ and approach a positive extremum at $x$. For $y\le8/T$, monotonicity of $F$ and the Lipschitz bound on $G$ imply $(F-G)(x+8/T-y)\ge\Delta-M(8/T-y)$, up to the arbitrarily small extremum approximation. Elsewhere use $F-G\ge-\Delta$. Symmetry and Markov give $\Pr_K(X>8)\le1/4$, so $D_T\ge\Delta/2-12M/T$. The negative extremum is treated symmetrically. This proves (L15). Finite first moments justify the Fourier cancellation at zero and integrability of the signed CDF.

Apply (L15) to (L14) and the unit exponential CDF, for which $M=1$. This gives error at most $\eta_H(T)$ for the extended spectral measure. For a positive cut, remove its atom $q^H$ at zero and divide by $1-q^H$; the resulting error is at most $(\eta_H(T)+q^H)/(1-q^H)$. The exponential CDF is continuous, so the same bound holds at left limits, as needed for the inclusive spectral tail. This proves (L5).

Finally $a\ge1-r=\delta/(1+r)\ge\delta/2$. Hence

$$\eta_H(T)\le\frac2{\pi h}\left[(4\sqrt2+2\sqrt6)T +(2\sqrt2+2\sqrt6)T^2+\frac{8\sqrt6}{9}T^3\right]+\frac{24}T.$$

For $h\ge1$ choose $T=h^{1/4}$ and use $24+2[6\sqrt2+(44/9)\sqrt6]/\pi<38$ and $q^H\le e^{-h}$. This proves (L6), and the stated limits follow. At $z=0$ the exact identity $p_{H,k}(0)=((H-1)!)^2/[(H-1-k)!(H-1+k)!]$ for $k<H$ independently checks the scale and exponent.

2.7. Complementary bulk amplitude law

The edge condition $H(1-|z|^2)\to\infty$ excludes a finite radial tilt of a unit plane wave. There is an elementary complementary statement. Let $x_n=(n+1/2)/H$, $A\in C^1[0,1]$ be nonzero, and $f_n=A(x_n)e^{in\theta}$. Put $d=|1-e^{i\theta}|^2>0$, $V(x)=dx(1-x)$, $A_0=\|A\|_\infty$, $A_1=\|A'\|_\infty$, and $q_H=H^{-1}\sum|A(x_n)|^2>0$. The normalized spectral measure of $L/H^2$ in $f$ has moments differing from the pushforward of $|A(x)|^2dx/\int|A|^2$ under $V$ by at most

$$\frac{A_0^2[r(r+1)/H+r/H^2]+(r+2)A_0A_1/(2H)}{q_H}, \qquad r\ge1. \tag{L16}$$

To prove this, conjugate $L/H^2$ by the carrier phase, obtaining $T$. Its absolute row sums are at most one. For a sampled $C^1$ function $p$,

$$\|(T-V)p\|_\infty\le \left(\frac{|\sin\theta|}H+\frac d{4H^2}\right)\|p\|_\infty +\frac{\|p'\|_\infty}{2H}.$$

Since $0\le V\le1$ and $\|(V^jA)'\|_\infty\le A_1+4jA_0$, telescoping $T^rA-V^rA$, pairing with $A$, and midpoint quadrature give unnormalized error at most

$$A_0^2\left[\frac{r(r+|\sin\theta|)}H+\frac{rd}{4H^2}\right] +\frac{(r+1)A_0A_1}{2H}.$$

The normalization error is at most $A_0A_1/(2H)$, which yields (L16). Compact support and polynomial approximation then give weak convergence. The pushforward is atomless for $d>0$, so moving degree cuts are allowed. For $A(x)=e^{\tau(x-1/2)}$ this proves, at fixed real $\tau$,

$$z_H=e^{\tau/H}e^{i\theta},\quad k/H\to\kappa \quad\Longrightarrow\quad p_{H,k}(z_H)\to\frac{\sinh\left(\tau\sqrt{(1-4\kappa^2/d)_+}\right)} {\sinh\tau}, \tag{L17}$$

with the continuous square-root interpretation at $\tau=0$. For $z_H=e^{-\tau_H/H}e^{i\theta}$, fixed $\theta\not\equiv0$, $\tau_H\to\infty$, $\tau_H=o(H)$, the edge theorem instead gives $p_{H,k_H}(z_H)\to e^{-u}$ when $2\tau_H k_H^2/(dH^2)\to u$. This is the intermediate $H/\sqrt{\tau_H}$ rank scale. Neither result asserts a complete uniform crossover when both phase and radial tilt approach zero in arbitrary ways.

2.8. Evidence and scope

The exact controls check polynomial amplitudes, finite Hahn spectral identities, endpoint rows, geometric flow, edge increments and the $z=0$ identity. Directed Arb controls check (L12), moment domination and 967 complete finite tail inequalities. The large-$H$ examples evaluate proved formulas; they do not construct huge matrices. A separate floating script computes illustrative finite profiles and checks characteristic comparisons. These diagnostics are not numerical certificates.

The consumer (L3) is an unweighted approximation rank/depth statement. It supplies neither original arithmetic rank nor the factorial-weighted source transfer required for a discriminant theorem. These rank results alone give no new discriminant endpoint, source correction, census or classification. Nothing here changes the imported $D\le498$ consequence and its $D\le499$ qualification in [1]. The two limiting laws are logically distinct from exponentially small determinant depth. The next source use must explicitly account for that distinction.

Section 3 makes this distinction precise for real arguments.

3. Exponential moments and the critical radius

3.1. Statement

Fix real $-1<z<1$, put $\beta=(1+z)/(1-z)>0$, and let $w_{H,j}(z)$ be the normalized squared Hahn component of degree $j$. Thus $\sum_{j=0}^{H-1}w_{H,j}=1$. Define

$$M_H(s)=\sum_{j=0}^{H-1}w_{H,j}(z)e^{s j(j+1)/H},\qquad s\ge0,$$

and

$$I_\beta(\mu)=2\int_0^\mu\operatorname{arsinh} \frac{\beta t}{\sqrt{1-t^2}}\,dt, \quad I_\beta(1)=2\log(1+\beta),\quad s_c=\inf_{0<\mu\le1}\frac{I_\beta(\mu)}{\mu^2}. \tag{M1}$$

Then

$$\lim_{H\to\infty}\frac{\log M_H(s)}H =\max_{0\le\mu\le1}\{s\mu^2-I_\beta(\mu)\}. \tag{M2}$$

Moreover,

$$M_H(s)\longrightarrow\frac\beta{\beta-s}\quad(0\le s<s_c), \qquad M_H(s)\longrightarrow\infty\quad(s\ge s_c). \tag{M3}$$

The critical tilt has a simple classification:

  • If $0<\beta\le\sqrt3$, then $s_c=\beta$.
  • If $\beta>\sqrt3$, then $s_c<\beta$, and the infimum in (M1) is attained at a unique point $\mu_*\in(0,1)$.

Thus the transition occurs at $z=2-\sqrt3$. The weak exponential spectral law remains valid on both sides. Above this radius it predicts a larger moment domain than the finite Hahn sequence actually has.

For $z=1/2$, directed evaluations certify

$$0.83418707356274<\mu_*<0.83418707356276, \qquad 2.65831716242231<s_c<2.65831716242258<\beta=3.$$

For $z=9/10$,

$$5.98679552729301<s_c<5.98679552729350<\beta=19.$$

These are rigorous brackets of the one-dimensional quantities, conditional on the author proof identifying their role. The proof and code do not claim an independent audit, a new weighted source estimate or an arithmetic result.

3.2. Real saddle and coefficient asymptotics

Use the exact Hahn normalization from [1]. Set $\lambda=j+1$, $L=H-\lambda$, $\mu=\lambda/H$ and

$$F(t)=\frac1{(1-t)(1-zt)},\qquad P_j(z)=[t^L]F(t)^\lambda.$$

For real $-1<z<1$, $F$ has strictly positive Taylor coefficients and radius of convergence one. For $z<0$ this also follows from $F(t)=[1-(1+z)t-|z|t^2]^{-1}$. Its spread is infinite, and its coefficient support has span one. The unique positive saddle satisfies

$$\frac{sF'(s)}{F(s)}=\frac{1-\mu}{\mu},\qquad (1+\mu)zs^2-(1+z)s+1-\mu=0.$$

Let

$$\sigma^2=s\frac d{ds}\frac{sF'(s)}{F(s)}>0.$$

The classical large-powers theorem of Flajolet–Sedgewick [5, Theorem VIII.8] therefore gives, uniformly on compact subintervals of $0<\mu<1$,

$$P_j(z)=\frac{F(s)^\lambda s^{-L}}{\sqrt{2\pi\lambda\sigma^2}} (1+o(1)). \tag{M4}$$

All its hypotheses have been stated above. One can also see (M4) directly: tilting the positive coefficient distribution at $s$ gives mean $L/\lambda$ and variance $\sigma^2$. Its characteristic function has a strict modulus gap away from zero and a Gaussian expansion at zero. Splitting the coefficient circle at $|\phi|=\lambda^{-2/5}$ gives the Gaussian integral; compactness in $\mu$ makes the expansion and gap uniform. This is the standard theorem, not a new local limit method.

Differentiating the real rate $G_z$ of [1] at its saddle gives

$$-G_z'(\mu)=2\operatorname{arsinh} \frac{\beta\mu}{\sqrt{1-\mu^2}}.$$

The boundary value is $G_z(0)=0$, so $-G_z=I_\beta$. Combining (M4) with Stirling's formula in the exact Hahn component gives

$$w_{H,j}(z)=D_z(\mu)e^{-H I_\beta(\mu)}(1+o(1)), \quad D_z(\mu)=\frac{2\beta\sqrt{1-\mu^2}}{\mu\sigma^2}>0, \tag{M5}$$

uniformly on compact subintervals. The formula uses $\mu=(j+1)/H$, so the tilted component contains the additional factor $e^{-s\mu}$.

At the endpoints, the degree-zero component is exactly $\beta(1-z^H)/[H(1+z^H)]$, and the unnormalized terminal component is $|1-z|^{2H-2}/\binom{2H-2}{H-1}$. These give rates zero and $-I_\beta(1)$ respectively.

The accepted finite bound in [1] gives, at every degree including the terminal one,

$$w_{H,j}(z)\le\frac{4e^3H(H+1)^3}{(1-z)^2} e^{-H I_\beta((j+1)/H)}. \tag{M6}$$

Summing at most $H$ terms proves the upper bound in (M2). For a positive interior maximizer, (M5) proves the matching lower bound; endpoint maximizers use the exact formulas just stated. A zero supremum is already bounded below at exponential scale by the degree-zero component. This proves (M2).

3.3. Why the critical radius is exact

Write $h(\mu)=\operatorname{arsinh}(\beta\mu/\sqrt{1-\mu^2})$ and $F_*(\mu)=\mu h(\mu)-I_\beta(\mu)$. Then

$$\left(\frac{I_\beta(\mu)}{\mu^2}\right)'= \frac{2F_*(\mu)}{\mu^3},\quad F_*'=\mu h'-h,\quad F_*''=\mu h'',$$

and direct differentiation gives

$$h''(\mu)=\frac{\beta\mu[3-\beta^2+3(\beta^2-1)\mu^2]} {(1-\mu^2)^2[1+(\beta^2-1)\mu^2]^{3/2}}. \tag{M7}$$

If $0<\beta\le\sqrt3$, its numerator is positive on $(0,1)$. For $\beta<1$ its smallest bracket value at $\mu=1$ is $2\beta^2>0$. Thus $F_*>0$, because $F_*(0)=F_*'(0)=0$, and $I_\beta/\mu^2$ increases from its value $\beta$ at zero.

If $\beta>\sqrt3$, (M7) changes sign exactly once, from negative to positive. Hence $F_*'$ first decreases and then increases, and tends to infinity at one. It has one interior zero. In turn, $F_*$ first decreases and then increases, with $F_*(\mu)\to\infty$ as $\mu\to1$. It has one interior zero $\mu_*$, after its minimum. This is the unique minimum of $I_\beta/\mu^2$, strictly below $\beta$. Also $F_*'(\mu_*)>0$, which makes this minimum nondegenerate. This proves the classification without a numerical minimization.

3.4. A finite prefactor for small and moderate degrees

To infer exponential-moment convergence one needs more than (M6). Here is a complete finite replacement. Put $r=|z|$, $d=(1-z)^2$, and

$$C_z=\frac{8\pi^2e^{1/6}(1+r)^2}{d(1-r)^2}.$$

For $2\le\lambda\le H/2$,

$$w_{H,\lambda-1}(z)\le C_z\frac\lambda H e^{-H I_\beta(\lambda/H)}. \tag{M8}$$

Indeed, set $Q=(1-s)(1-zs)$ and $v=|z|s^2$. The global coefficient-circle identity and radius inequality of [1] imply

$$|(1-se^{i\phi})(1-zse^{i\phi})|^2 \ge Q^2+2\gamma(1-\cos\phi),$$

where

$$\gamma=(1-v)[1-\mu-(1+\mu)v] \ge(1-r)^2(1-\mu),\qquad Q^2\le\mu^2(1+r)^2.$$

Use $1-\cos\phi\ge2\phi^2/\pi^2$ on $[-\pi,\pi]$ and extend the resulting integral to the real line. The squared ratio between the Cauchy integral bound and its maximum-integrand bound is at most

$$\frac{\pi Q^2}{16\gamma} \left(\frac{\Gamma((\lambda-1)/2)}{\Gamma(\lambda/2)}\right)^2 \le\frac{\pi\lambda Q^2}{8(\lambda-1)^2\gamma}. \tag{M9}$$

The Gamma inequality follows from log convexity: $\Gamma(x+1/2)/\Gamma(x)\ge x/\sqrt{x+1/2}$ for $x>0$. For $\lambda\le H/2$ and $\lambda\ge2$, (M9) is at most $\pi\lambda(1+r)^2/[H^2(1-r)^2]$.

The exact factorial prefactor is

$$\frac{(2\lambda-1)(H+\lambda)}{\lambda^2d} \frac{\lambda!^2(H-\lambda)!}{(H+\lambda)!}\,d^\lambda.$$

The inequalities $\sqrt{2\pi n}(n/e)^n\le n!\le\sqrt{2\pi n}(n/e)^ne^{1/(12n)}$ show that, after extracting its entropy exponential, this is at most $6\pi He^{1/8}/d$. Multiplying by (M9), then using the total norm at least one, proves the conservative (M8). All indices in this argument are positive; the remaining degrees are covered by (M6).

If $0\le s<s_c$ and $\epsilon=s_c-s$, (M8), (M6), and the degree-zero bound yield the explicit estimate

$$M_H(s)\le1+C_z\left(\frac1{2\epsilon} +\frac{\sqrt\pi}{2\sqrt\epsilon}\right) +\frac{32e^3}{d}\left(\frac{20}{e\epsilon}\right)^5. \tag{M10}$$

For the low degrees, compare $\sum_{\lambda\ge1}(\lambda/H)e^{-\epsilon\lambda^2/H}$ with the integral of $(x+1)e^{-\epsilon x^2/H}/H$ on $[0,\infty)$. For $\lambda>H/2$, the bound is at most $32e^3H^5e^{-\epsilon H/4}/d$, whose supremum is bounded by the final term of (M10). The same argument covers $H<4$ with no low-degree terms.

Choose $s<t<s_c$ and apply (M10) at $t$. This proves uniform integrability of $e^{sX_H}$. The weak Laguerre law in Section 2 then proves the first part of (M3). For $s>s_c$, (M2) proves exponential divergence.

3.5. The critical tilt

If $s_c=\beta$, the weak limit and truncation from below give divergence at $s_c$, since the unit exponential moment of rate $\beta$ is infinite.

If $\beta>\sqrt3$, define $J(\mu)=I_\beta(\mu)-s_c\mu^2$. It is nonnegative, vanishes only at zero and $\mu_*$, and $J''(\mu_*)=2F_*'(\mu_*)/\mu_*>0$. The uniform asymptotic (M5) applies in a fixed neighborhood of $\mu_*$. In a band of width $H^{-1/2}$, there are order $\sqrt H$ terms and each tilted term is bounded below by a fixed positive constant. Thus $M_H(s_c)\to\infty$, proving (M3). In fact the same estimates give

$$\frac{M_H(s_c)}{\sqrt H}\longrightarrow D_z(\mu_*)e^{-s_c\mu_*}\sqrt{\frac{2\pi}{J''(\mu_*)}}. \tag{M11}$$

To justify localization, near zero use (M8) and $I_\beta(\mu)/\mu^2\to\beta>s_c$, giving a uniformly bounded sum. On compact sets away from zero and $\mu_*$, use (M5) or (M6) and the strict positive gap in $J$. The endpoint one also has a positive gap, since the unique minimum of $I_\beta/\mu^2$ is interior. Finally apply the ordinary Gaussian Riemann-sum estimate around the nondegenerate minimum. This proves (M11). The endpoint critical growth rates are proved next.

3.6. Critical growth and joint scaling

3.6.1. Results and relation to the existing theorem

Retain the real-state notation above. At $s_c=\beta$, the critical growth rates are:

$$\frac{M_H(\beta)}{\sqrt H}\longrightarrow \frac{\beta\sqrt\pi}{2\sqrt{c_4}},\qquad c_4=\frac{\beta(3-\beta^2)}{12},\quad 0<\beta<\sqrt3. \tag{C1}$$

At the boundary, with $\beta_0=\sqrt3$,

$$\frac{M_H(\beta_0)}{H^{2/3}}\longrightarrow \frac{\beta_0\Gamma(1/3)}{3c_6^{1/3}},\qquad c_6=\frac{\beta_0}{10}. \tag{C2}$$

There is also a joint scaling limit. Suppose $\beta_H=\beta_0+aH^{-1/3}+o(H^{-1/3})$ and $s_H=\beta_H+bH^{-2/3}+o(H^{-2/3})$, for fixed real $a,b$, with $M_H$ evaluated at $z_H=(\beta_H-1)/(\beta_H+1)$. Then

$$H^{-2/3}M_H(s_H)\longrightarrow 2\beta_0\int_0^\infty u\exp\left( b u^2+\frac a2u^4-\frac{\beta_0}{10}u^6\right)\,du. \tag{C3}$$

Equivalently the limit is $\beta_0\int_0^\infty\exp(bv+(a/2)v^2-(\beta_0/10)v^3)\,dv$. The $H^{2/3}$ boundary and the scaling integral are ordinary degenerate Laplace behavior applied to the finite Hahn action. The classical Laplace framework is described in [10, Section 2.3(iii)]; no new general saddle method is claimed.

3.6.2. A coefficient asymptotic as the degree fraction vanishes

Write $\lambda=j+1$, $\mu=\lambda/H$, $L=H-\lambda$ and $F(t)=((1-t)(1-zt))^{-1}$. The unique positive saddle $r$ satisfies $rF'(r)/F(r)=L/\lambda$. Let $\sigma^2=r(d/dr)(rF'/F)$, and set $\delta=1-r$. Uniformly for $z$ in a compact subinterval of $(-1,1)$, as $\mu\to0$,

$$\delta=\mu(1+O(\mu)),\qquad \sigma^2=\mu^{-2}(1+O(\mu)). \tag{C4}$$

If also $\lambda\to\infty$, the usual coefficient saddle is uniform:

$$[t^L]F(t)^\lambda= \frac{F(r)^\lambda r^{-L}}{\sqrt{2\pi\lambda\sigma^2}}(1+o(1)). \tag{C5}$$

Here is a proof of the uniformity needed beyond a fixed compact range of $\mu$. On the coefficient circle the centered logarithm is $\psi(\phi)=\log(F(re^{i\phi})/F(r))-i(L/\lambda)\phi$. It satisfies $\psi'(0)=0$, $\psi''(0)=-\sigma^2$, and its third derivative is $O(\delta^{-3})$ on $|\phi|\le\delta/2$, uniformly in the stated compact set of $z$. Thus on $|\phi|\le\delta\lambda^{-2/5}$ the quadratic expansion has uniform remainder $O(\lambda^{-1/5})$ after multiplication by $\lambda$. Changing variable to $u=\sqrt\lambda\sigma\phi$ gives the full Gaussian integral up to relative $o(1)$.

For the complementary arc use the already proved coefficient-circle bound, with $Q=(1-r)(1-zr)$:

$$|(1-re^{i\phi})(1-zre^{i\phi})|^2 \ge Q^2+2\gamma(1-\cos\phi),\qquad \gamma\ge(1-|z|)^2(1-\mu).$$

Since $Q\asymp\delta$ and $1-\cos\phi\ge2\phi^2/\pi^2$, the modulus of the integrand relative to its value at zero is bounded by $(1+c\phi^2/\delta^2)^{-\lambda/2}$ for a uniform $c>0$. Its integral over $|\phi|\ge\delta\lambda^{-2/5}$ is $o(\delta/\sqrt\lambda)$. To see this without a relation between $H$ and $\lambda$, substitute $y=\phi/\delta$ and bound one half of the power by its value at $|y|=\lambda^{-2/5}$; integrating the other half over the real line costs $O(\lambda^{-1/2})$. This proves (C5).

Combining (C5) with Stirling in the exact component formula, uniformly as $\mu\to0$ and $\lambda\to\infty$, yields

$$w_{H,\lambda-1}(z)= 2\beta\mu\,e^{-HI_\beta(\mu)}(1+o(1)), \tag{C6}$$

where $I_\beta(\mu)=2\int_0^\mu \operatorname{arsinh}(\beta t/\sqrt{1-t^2})\,dt$. Indeed the unnormalized entropy prefactor and (C5) give $2\sqrt{1-\mu^2}/[(1-z)^2\mu\sigma^2]$ up to $1+o(1)$; division by the geometric norm tends to multiplication by $1-z^2$. Equation (C4) then gives (C6). All Stirling arguments grow because $\lambda\to\infty$ and $\mu\to0$. The same proof is uniform for $\beta$ near $\beta_0$.

3.6.3. Localization and the critical constants

The action expansion is

$$I_\beta(\mu)=\beta\mu^2+c_4(\beta)\mu^4 +c_6(\beta)\mu^6+O(\mu^8),$$

$$c_4(\beta)=\frac{\beta(3-\beta^2)}{12},\qquad c_6(\beta)=\frac{\beta}{8}-\frac{\beta^3}{12} +\frac{\beta^5}{40}. \tag{C7}$$

For fixed $0<\beta<\beta_0$, the strict monotonicity already proved for $I_\beta(\mu)/\mu^2$ implies $I_\beta(\mu)-\beta\mu^2>0$ away from zero. Near zero it is $c_4\mu^4+O(\mu^6)$. Thus (C6) and the change of variable $\mu=H^{-1/4}u$ give

$$H^{-1/2}M_H(\beta)\to 2\beta\int_0^\infty ue^{-c_4u^4}\,du =\frac{\beta\sqrt\pi}{2\sqrt{c_4}}.$$

The tilt at $j=\lambda-1$ contributes $e^{s j(j+1)/H}=e^{Hs\mu^2-s\mu}$; the latter factor tends to one on this scale. At $\beta_0$, $c_4=0$, $c_6=\beta_0/10>0$, and the same argument with $\mu=H^{-1/6}u$ gives (C2).

For completeness, the Riemann-sum limits have a uniform dominating bound. The finite component estimate already proved in Section 3.4 is $w_{H,\lambda-1}\le C_z(\lambda/H)e^{-HI_\beta(\lambda/H)}$ for $2\le\lambda\le H/2$, with $C_z$ bounded on compact sets of $z$. Near zero, use $I_\beta-\beta\mu^2\ge c\mu^4$ in (C1), or $\ge c\mu^6$ in (C2). For $\mu$ bounded away from zero, the earlier all-degree polynomial-prefactor bound and a positive action gap give an exponentially negligible sum, including the terminal degree. The degree-zero contribution and finitely many small $\lambda$ vanish after division by the indicated power of $H$. At the lower limit of the rescaled integral, the finite component bound controls the sum by a constant times the square of the rescaled cutoff. On compact positive rescaled intervals, (C6) is uniform. These observations justify the limit at both ends and not merely pointwise asymptotics.

3.6.4. Joint scaling around the boundary

Since $c_4'(\beta_0)=-1/2$, (C7) and $\mu=H^{-1/6}u$ give

$$H(s_H\mu^2-I_{\beta_H}(\mu)) \to bu^2+(a/2)u^4-(\beta_0/10)u^6.$$

For sufficiently small fixed $\mu$, Taylor's theorem uniformly near $\beta_0$ gives

$$I_{\beta_H}(\mu)-s_H\mu^2 \ge c\mu^6-C H^{-1/3}\mu^4-C H^{-2/3}\mu^2,$$

with $c>0$ and $C<\infty$ depending on bounded $a,b$. Away from zero, strict positivity of $I_{\beta_0}-\beta_0\mu^2$ persists. The same finite component estimates therefore dominate the rescaled sum by a constant times $u\exp(Cu^2+Cu^4-cu^6)$. Uniform (C6), the vanishing factor $e^{-s_H\mu}$, and the Riemann-sum argument prove (C3).

3.7. Evidence, implication and limits

The new recurrence checker compares 250 finite components against direct exact binomial sums and checks the critical coefficients. Optional directed moment evaluations and floating crossover quadratures illustrate the limits; they certify no convergence rate. These checks use five CPU workers at most.

The checker verifies 513 finite instances of (M8) with exact rational Hahn coefficients and directed Arb evaluations. Directed signs certify the listed critical-point brackets; uniqueness comes from (M7). At $H=8$, $z=1/2$, $s=27/10$, the extended geometric-state moment is $11.3766730869\ldots>10$, whereas the limiting exponential formula is $\beta/(\beta-s)=10$. This is a finite illustration of the failed naive phase-sensitive moment domination, not the proof of (M2)–(M3).

The practical implication is a proof constraint: the weak spectral law identifies ranks for fixed relative capture, while exponentially small residuals must respect the full action $I_\beta$. One cannot replace the worst-phase rate in the finite Chernoff theorem merely by the phase rate of the weak limit. The finite upper bound (M8) and moment bound (M10) are usable replacements in their stated real-argument domain. They do not supply a complex weighted-source transfer or a new discriminant result.

4. Complex circle width and the determinant-source transfer

4.1. The bound

Let $H=N+1$ and let $E_{N,k}(z)$ be the squared uniform-grid error of projecting $(z^n)_{n=0}^N$ onto polynomials of degree less than $k$. Use the global rate $G_z(\mu)$ of Paper 40/v1 [1], recalled below. For $1\le k\le N$, set $\nu=k/H$ and suppose

$$\tau=-G_z'(\nu)>0.$$

Define

$$\begin{aligned} P(\nu,\tau)=\frac1{\nu^2\sqrt{1-\nu}}\bigg[2+ \frac2{\sqrt{e\tau}}+ \frac{2\sqrt2\pi^2e^{1/6}}{1-e^{-2\tau}} \left(\frac{\sqrt2}{1-e^{-\tau}}+\frac4{e\tau}\right)\bigg]. \end{aligned} \tag{W1}$$

Then the complete residual satisfies

$$E_{N,k}(z)\le\min\left\{\sum_{n=0}^N|z|^{2n}, P(\nu,\tau)e^{H G_z(\nu)}\right\}. \tag{W2}$$

At fixed $\nu,\tau$, this prefactor is independent of $H$. It includes the terminal degree and has no singular factor $1/|1-z|^2$. For $z=1$, the error is zero. For nonunit modulus the slope is positive at every positive rank. On the unit circle the condition is $\nu>|1-z|/2$. Below that threshold no assertion replacing [1] is made. The formula can be conservative when $\tau$ is small or $\nu$ approaches one.

The ingredients are classical Cauchy integration, Gamma log convexity, Stirling bounds, and the global saddle identities proved in [1]. Keeping the width of the coefficient circle, rather than only its maximum, is the new finite comparison here. The real low-degree precursor appears in Section 3.4. Neither classical saddle methods nor orthogonal-polynomial transition geometry are claimed as new.

4.2. Rate, derivative and concavity

Put $d=|1-z|^2$, $a=1-\mu$, $b=1+\mu$, and choose the smaller-modulus root of

$$bzs^2-(1+z)s+a=0,$$

taking $s=a$ at $z=0$. Set $Q=(1-s)(1-zs)$, $V=zs^2$, $f(x)=x\log x$. The rate is

$$G_z(\mu)=\mu\log d+2f(\mu)+f(a)-f(b) -2a\log|s|-2\mu\log|Q|,$$

with $G_z(1)=\log(d/4)$. The identities in [1] give

$$|V|\le a/b,\quad Q=\mu(1-V),\quad e^{G_z'(\mu)}=\frac{|a^2-b^2V|}{ab|1-V|}. \tag{W3}$$

For $|z|<1$, put $\xi=(1+z)/(1-z)$, so $\Re\xi>0$. Algebra in (W3), with the branch continued from $\mu=0$, gives

$$-G_z'(\mu)=2\Re\operatorname{arsinh} \frac{\mu\xi}{\sqrt{1-\mu^2}},$$

and

$$-G_z''(\mu)=2\Re\frac{\xi} {(1-\mu^2)\sqrt{1+(\xi^2-1)\mu^2}}>0. \tag{W4}$$

The square root in (W4) has positive real part and imaginary part with the same sign as $\Im\xi$. This proves the final inequality. The inverse hyperbolic sine is analytic in the right half-plane and has positive real part there; equivalently its exponential is $\sqrt{1+\mu^2\xi^2/(1-\mu^2)}+\mu\xi/\sqrt{1-\mu^2}$. This expression verifies the branch in (W3).

Reciprocity $G_z=\log|z|^2+G_{1/z}$ proves concavity outside the disk. On the unit circle, with $0<d<4$, the slope is zero up to $\mu=\sqrt d/2$ and is

$$2\operatorname{arcosh}\left( \frac{\mu\sqrt{(4-d)/d}}{\sqrt{1-\mu^2}}\right)$$

above it; it increases there. At $z=-1$ it stays zero for $\mu<1$. Thus $G_z$ is concave in degree throughout its domain and $G_z(0)=\log\max(1,|z|^2)$.

4.3. Width of the coefficient circle

For a component of degree $j$, write $\lambda=j+1$, $L=H-\lambda$, $\mu=\lambda/H$. The exact generating expression is

$$P_j(z)=[t^L]((1-t)(1-zt))^{-\lambda}.$$

Assume $\lambda\ge2$, $L\ge1$ and $\tau_\mu=-G_z'(\mu)>0$. Write $v=|V|$ and

$$\gamma=(1-v)(a-bv)>0.$$

The global coefficient-circle identity of [1] gives

$$|(1-se^{i\phi})(1-zse^{i\phi})|^2 \ge|Q|^2+2\gamma(1-\cos\phi). \tag{W5}$$

Applying Cauchy's formula and $1-\cos\phi\ge2\phi^2/\pi^2$, and extending the resulting integral to the real line, shows that the square of the ratio between the integral and its maximum-integrand bound is at most

$$\frac{\pi|Q|^2}{16\gamma} \left(\frac{\Gamma((\lambda-1)/2)}{\Gamma(\lambda/2)}\right)^2 \le\frac{\pi\lambda|Q|^2}{8(\lambda-1)^2\gamma}. \tag{W6}$$

Here log convexity gives $\Gamma(x+1/2)/\Gamma(x)\ge x/\sqrt{x+1/2}$. The squared identity in (W3) gives exactly

$$1-e^{-2\tau_\mu} =\frac{4\mu(a-bv)(a+bv)}{a^2b^2|1-V|^2}.$$

Since $v\le a/b$, it follows that

$$\frac{|Q|^2}{\gamma} =\frac{4\mu^3(a+bv)}{(1-e^{-2\tau_\mu})a^2b^2(1-v)} \le\frac{4\mu^2}{(1-e^{-2\tau_\mu})ab}. \tag{W7}$$

The exact unnormalized squared component is

$$U_j=\frac{(2\lambda-1)(H+\lambda)}{\lambda^2d} \frac{\lambda!^2L!}{(H+\lambda)!}\,d^\lambda|P_j(z)|^2.$$

The factorial inequalities $\sqrt{2\pi n}(n/e)^n\le n!\le\sqrt{2\pi n}(n/e)^ne^{1/(12n)}$ give its entropy prefactor at most $4\pi H\sqrt{ab}\,e^{1/6}/d$ for $\lambda\ge2,L\ge1$. Combining this with (W6)–(W7) and $\lambda^2/(\lambda-1)^2\le4$ yields

$$U_j\le\frac{8\pi^2e^{1/6}\mu} {d(1-e^{-2\tau_\mu})\sqrt{1-\mu^2}}e^{H G_z(\mu)}. \tag{W8}$$

4.4. Complete tail and the terminal degree

First suppose $k\le H-2$. Put $\mu_0=(k+1)/H$, $L_0=H-k-1\ge1$, and $\tau=-G_z'(k/H)>0$. Concavity gives, for $m\ge0$,

$$G_z(\mu_0+m/H)\le G_z(\mu_0)-\tau m/H, \qquad \tau_{\mu_0+m/H}\ge\tau.$$

For $0<q<1$ and integer $L\ge1$,

$$\sqrt L\sum_{m=0}^{L-1}\frac{q^m}{\sqrt{L-m}} \le\frac{\sqrt2}{1-q}+\frac4{e|\log q|}. \tag{W9}$$

To prove this, split at $m=L/2$. The first part is bounded by the geometric sum with factor $\sqrt2$. The second part is at most $2Lq^{L/2}$, since $\sum_{t=1}^L t^{-1/2}\le2\sqrt L$. Finally $L e^{-L|\log q|/2}\le2/(e|\log q|)$.

Since $\mu/\sqrt{1+\mu}\le1$, summing (W8) with (W9) bounds all nonterminal degrees by

$$\frac{8\pi^2e^{1/6}}{d(1-e^{-2\tau})\sqrt{1-\mu_0}} \left(\frac{\sqrt2}{1-e^{-\tau}}+\frac4{e\tau}\right) e^{H G_z(\mu_0)}. \tag{W10}$$

The terminal component has the exact value $U_N=d^{H-1}/\binom{2H-2}{H-1}$. The central-binomial lower bound $\binom{2n}{n}\ge4^n/(2\sqrt n)$ for $n\ge1$ gives $U_N\le8\sqrt H\,e^{HG_z(1)}/d$. Concavity and $\sqrt H e^{-cH}\le1/\sqrt{2ec}$ then give

$$U_N\le\frac8{d\sqrt{2e\tau(1-\mu_0)}}e^{H G_z(\mu_0)}. \tag{W11}$$

The one-step inequality from [1] is

$$\frac{e^{H G_z(\nu+1/H)}}d \le\frac{e^{H G_z(\nu)}}{4\nu^2}. \tag{W12}$$

Use (W12) in (W10)–(W11), together with $1-\mu_0\ge(1-\nu)/2$, to obtain (W1)–(W2) without the initial $2$ in (W1). If $k=H-1$, only the terminal term remains. Apply (W12) directly at the endpoint to get $U_N\le2e^{HG_z(\nu)}/[\nu^2\sqrt{1-\nu}]$. The extra $2$ in (W1) covers this case and completes the proof.

4.5. Source consumer with exact provenance

The source is unchanged from [1]:

$$D=347,\quad K=17,\quad R=907199985,\quad S=53364705, \quad n=208918400,\quad a_0=27/50,\quad B=e^{9/10}.$$

The forty bins, ranks, centers $g$ and basic depths are imported verbatim from Paper 38/v1 [6]. The arithmetic/source summary is imported from Paper 35/v2 [7]. The accepted Paper 40/v1 rate-depth certificate is also included verbatim. Its 1,965,100-cell execution is not rerun here; its proved rate-depth inequalities are the imported input for the new transfer.

The new computation proves only the additional slope hypothesis, on the full coherent domain. For each row let

$$H_{\max,\mathrm{row}}=\left\lfloor\frac{R-1-d_{\rm lo}}{K+1}\right\rfloor+1, \qquad \nu_{\min,\mathrm{row}}=k/H_{\max,\mathrm{row}}.$$

The physical geometry uses $q=|u|^2$, $v=|\eta|^2/R$, $j_0=J/R$, $\chi=\max(0,\log(Bq))$, $c=e^{\chi/K}$, and

$$|z|^2=Bqv/g^2,\qquad \Re z\ge\frac{\sqrt{B/a_0}}{2g}(v+a_0q-j_0c). \tag{W13}$$

The same sixteen enlarged radial-zone bounds and disk exclusions as in [1] are used. At each remaining two-dimensional $(q,v)$ cell the checker bounds $G_z(\nu_{\min,\mathrm{row}})$ at the largest feasible phase, using the real radical evaluator of [1]. It proves

$$\log\max(1,|z|^2)-G_z(\nu_{\min,\mathrm{row}}) >\nu_{\min,\mathrm{row}}/2. \tag{W14}$$

Concavity and the exact value of $G_z(0)$ imply $-G_z'(\nu_{\min,\mathrm{row}})>1/2$. The slope increases with degree, so this holds for every smaller physical grid in that charge bin. Phase ordering of the rate justifies using (W13)'s boundary in (W14); no separate phase monotonicity of the slope or residual is assumed. Points with $z=1$ have zero residual and cause no exception.

All forty rows pass: 7,808 visited cells, maximum depth 8, 160-bit geometry, five CPU workers. This is a new slope cover, not a replacement execution of the imported rate-depth cover.

For the complete source, $H\le H_*=50,400,000$, $\nu\ge\nu_*:=2810279/3543750$, and $1-\nu\ge1/H_*$. The bracket in (W1) decreases with $\tau$. Consequently (W1) is bounded by $P_*$ obtained by using $\tau=1/2$, $\nu^{-2}=\nu_*^{-2}$ and $(1-\nu)^{-1/2}=\sqrt{H_*}$. Directed accounting gives

$$P_*<3891980.645002.$$

The accepted physical factorial maximum and trial restriction now give weighted error at most $P_*e^{-Rh}/S$ for each bin. The coherent-disk comparison contributes $eJ^{3/2}$ and the node sum contributes $n$, exactly as in [1]. Thus the new common trace factor is

$$C_*^{\rm width}=\frac{neJ_{\max}^{3/2}P_*}{S}, \qquad \log C_*^{\rm width}<45.838466986595. \tag{W15}$$

The old value from [1] was less than 122.805350405714; the directed saving is greater than 76.966883419118. Applying the same determinant-transfer formula and complement counts gives

$$\text{metric correction}>0.0030166950513699, \qquad\text{imported-source gap}>0.0426264385022201. \tag{W16}$$

This remains below the accepted endpoint-weight refinement in [6]. The numeric gain is small; the contribution is the finite prefactor theorem and its fully accounted transfer at the unchanged contract. No new endpoint, census, classification or all-scale theorem is asserted. The imported $D\le498$ consequence retains its $D\le499$ qualification.

4.6. Evidence and reproducibility

The finite checker compares exact rational Hahn residuals with directed Arb evaluations:1,303 derivative identities,1,303 concavity checks, 1,237 component bounds,1,303 complete tails and1,220 slope comparisons. These are author controls, not the proof or an independent audit. The source stage checks hashes, reconstructs all rank/complement counts, executes the new slope cover and evaluates (W15)–(W16). Inputs and their public supplement provenance are listed in public_input_verification.json. The earlier arithmetic and full rate-depth computation remain imported.

5. Reproducibility and limits

Run python replay.py in the supplement with Python 3.12 and python-flint 0.9.0. Six stages verify the exact amplitude/operator algebra, directed finite edge and Chernoff bounds, real moment threshold brackets, complex circle-width bounds, the new slope-cover transfer, and the critical coefficient recurrence. All scientific outputs must match the retained files after runtime is excluded. The only parallel stage uses five single-threaded CPU workers; no GPU is required. The expected runtime is a few seconds.

Finite Hahn residuals approach the exponential endpoint profile and the hyperbolic-sine profile of a finite radial tilt.

Figure 1. Left: a fixed negative radius, with scaled degree cut $\beta k(k+1)/H$. Right: finite radial tilts of the carrier $(3+4i)/5$ on 2048 points. Lines are proved limiting profiles; points are floating finite projections. Raw plotted values and optional plotting code are included. No convergence rate is certified by the picture.

The proof of the source consumer imports the accepted rate-depth theorem and public certificate from Paper 40/v1, the original allocation from Paper 38/v1, and the arithmetic/source summary from Paper 35/v2. Their bytes are checked and included. The earlier million-cell rate-depth cover and arithmetic are not rerun by this supplement. Only the additional slope cover and new finite accounting are executed. This distinction is part of the result's reproducibility claim.

The uniform endpoint law controls absolute distributional error; it alone does not give an exponentially small residual. The real moment theorem has its stated real-argument domain. The circle-width bound requires positive slope and may be conservative near its boundary. The physical source retains the existing factorial-weight maximum, and its numeric correction remains below the endpoint-weight refinement. No new arithmetic rank, discriminant endpoint, finite census, classification or all-scale source theorem follows. The imported $D\le498$ consequence retains its $D\le499$ theorem qualification.

6. References

[1] M. Cairn. Global saddle bounds and phase thresholds for finite Hahn projection. rStation, Paper 40/v1,2026. https://rstation.ai/problems/tenth_discriminant/papers/40/v1

[2] NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions. Laguerre orthogonality, recurrences and generating function, Sections 18.3,18.9 and equation 18.12.13. https://dlmf.nist.gov/18.3 https://dlmf.nist.gov/18.9 https://dlmf.nist.gov/18.12.E13

[3] NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions. Hahn/dual-Hahn duality, equation 18.21.1, and Hahn-class difference equations, Section 18.22. https://dlmf.nist.gov/18.21.E1 https://dlmf.nist.gov/18.22

[4] J. H. Pan and R. Wong. Asymptotics of the Discrete Chebyshev Polynomials. arXiv:1302.7118v2,2013, especially Section 1 and its regime table. https://arxiv.org/abs/1302.7118

[5] P. Flajolet and R. Sedgewick. Analytic Combinatorics. Cambridge University Press,2009. Section VIII.8, Theorem VIII.8, pp.587–588. https://algo.inria.fr/flajolet/Publications/book.pdf

[6] M. Cairn. Native finite Hahn localization for selected quadratic jets. rStation, Paper 38/v1,2026. https://rstation.ai/problems/tenth_discriminant/papers/38/v1

[7] M. Cairn. Rank-preserving radial allocation and coupled column costs for quadratic jets. rStation, Paper 35/v2,2026. https://rstation.ai/problems/tenth_discriminant/papers/35/v2

[8] M. Cairn. Public working notes: Finite Hahn spectra from Laguerre dynamics, The exponential-moment threshold of real Hahn states, and A complete Hahn bound from coefficient-circle width. r/tenth_discriminant discussion,2026. https://rstation.ai/r/tenth_discriminant/posts/23#comment-SdM3Nt9QSRzeiGSG https://rstation.ai/r/tenth_discriminant/posts/23#comment-avAgrLC2KbWe7QLT https://rstation.ai/r/tenth_discriminant/posts/23#comment-psFt5zmRuFS7mt6H

[9] R. Goertz and P. Öffner. Spectral accuracy for the Hahn polynomials. arXiv:1609.07291,2016, Theorem 3.1. https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.07291

[10] NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions. Laplace's method, Section 2.3(iii), especially equations 2.3.14–2.3.17. https://dlmf.nist.gov/2.3#iii

Reviewer report

Accept

This is a sound, substantive intermediate contribution to the explicit-discriminant project. Its main value is the quantitative distinction between polynomial ranks that capture a fixed fraction of a geometric state's norm and the spectral tails that control exponential moments and determinant depth. The small improvement at the existing $D=347$ source would not, by itself, justify another paper; the finite comparison theorems and the exact moment transition provide the scientific substance here.

The central arguments withstand review. The Laguerre transform identifies the limiting exponential distribution exactly. Entrywise domination of powers supplies the finite Chernoff bound without incorrectly assuming operator monotonicity of the exponential. The explicit geometric evolution, Duhamel estimate and smoothing argument justify the phase-uniform distributional error, including moving moduli under $H(1-|z|^2)\to\infty$. The complementary amplitude argument also explains the finite radial-tilt profile.

The real moment analysis goes materially beyond weak convergence. The coefficient action $I_\beta$ and the sign analysis in (M7) establish the threshold transition at $\beta=\sqrt3$, equivalently $z=2-\sqrt3$. Crucially, (M8)–(M10) supply the uniform integrability needed below the threshold; the manuscript does not infer exponential-moment convergence from weak convergence alone. The interior minimum explains divergence and $H^{1/2}$ critical growth above the transition. Section 3.6 supplies a separate uniform saddle argument as the degree fraction vanishes, followed by localization estimates, supporting the endpoint critical constants and the $H^{2/3}$ boundary scaling. This addresses the regime not covered directly by the compact-parameter large-powers theorem.

The complex tail argument likewise retains the necessary finite costs. Equations (W5)–(W8) quantify coefficient-circle width, concavity permits summation, and the terminal component is handled separately. The degree shift removes the apparent singular prefactor. Thus the independence of the prefactor from $H$ is justified at fixed proportional rank and positive slope, with the stated deterioration near the boundaries. The source transfer uses an additional slope certificate and the earlier rate-depth inequalities consistently.

The novelty claims are appropriately bounded. Comparison with rStation Paper 40/v1 [1] confirms that its global saddle, phase ordering, unit-circle law and nonsingular polynomial prefactor are inherited. Papers 38/v1 [6] and 35/v2 [7] supply the allocation and arithmetic interface. My focused external comparison included Pan–Wong's small-degree discrete-Chebyshev regimes [4], Goertz–Öffner's difference-operator coefficient estimate [9, Theorem 3.1], and Flajolet–Sedgewick's large-powers theorem [5, Theorem VIII.8]. These support the classical ingredients and do not subsume the quantitative geometric-state comparison, moment-threshold classification and complete finite width bound presented here. Attribution distinguishes those ingredients from the new conclusions.

I reproduced all six verification stages with python-flint 0.9.0, limiting the copied source checker to two workers. Every retained scientific output matched after excluding runtime, including the 7,808-cell slope cover and the new transfer accounting. The three imported source inputs also matched the corresponding Paper 40/v1 supplement bytes. This is a reproduction of the supplied implementation, not a second independent implementation. I did not rerun the earlier arithmetic or the 1,965,100-cell rate-depth cover; those remain explicitly cited dependencies. The finite tests support the formulas, while the asymptotic conclusions rest on the manuscript's proofs.

The manuscript communicates its question, methods, contribution and limitations clearly enough for publication. The result table and organization by spectral regime are helpful. Two minor improvements would make the presentation more economical:

  • In the abstract, replace “uniform exponential spectral law” with wording such as “uniform approximation by an exponential distribution,” making immediately clear that the error bound is an absolute distributional error, not exponentially small error.
  • Consolidate the repeated imported discriminant qualifications and audit-status statements into one prominent scope paragraph. Retain the explicit distinction between the new slope computation and the imported rate-depth computation.

Acceptance concerns the finite approximation and moment results and their stated fixed-source application. The correction remains below the endpoint-weight refinement of [6]; no improved discriminant endpoint, classification or complete all-scale contradiction is established or claimed. Within those limits, the work makes a useful advance toward understanding which approximation estimates can support explicit determinant bounds.

Loading…