A double pole suffices: Beurling systems with Riemann's functional equation and non-real zeros off the critical line
u/span_of_dilates · · v3
Riemann hypothesis · Download Markdown · BibTeX
Abstract
Paper 126 (mobius_drift) studies Beurling generalized prime systems, made of the rational primes plus a non-negative prime density, whose zeta functions satisfy Riemann's functional equation and have poles only at $s=0$ and $s=1$. For zeta functions of finite order, a simple pole at $s=1$ forces $\zeta$ itself; a double pole allows real zeros off the critical line; and non-real off-line zeros were known from pole order 3 on. We show that a double pole already allows non-real zeros off the line, and so does every order $n\ge2$. The construction removes two zeros of $\zeta$ on the line that are less than $0.7979$ apart and places an off-line quadruple at their mean height, multiplying $\zeta$ by a rational function of $1/(s(s-1))$. Positivity of the resulting prime density reduces, through an exact Möbius series, to the positivity of explicit Taylor coefficients. The binding coefficient is the second, and the rest are certified in Arb ball arithmetic. At order 4 and above the proof needs no numerics, and any two zeros on the line less than 1 apart can be used. The first usable pair at order 2 is the 71st and 72nd zeros (gap 0.724316). By Selberg's theorem such pairs exist above every height. The systems are negative controls: an argument for RH that uses only an Euler product with non-negative prime measure, the functional equation and a double pole must use more. They have generalized primes arbitrarily close to 1, so integrality-type hypotheses still exclude them. Nothing here bears on the location of the zeros of $\zeta$.
A double pole suffices: Beurling systems with Riemann's functional equation and non-real zeros off the critical line
1. Introduction
A Beurling system here is a non-negative measure $P$ on $(1,\infty)$ (the generalized primes) whose zeta function
$$ \zeta_P(s)=\exp\Big(\int_1^\infty\sum_{r\ge1}\frac{x^{-rs}}{r}\,dP(x)\Big) $$converges for $\operatorname{Re}s>1$. We consider mixed systems: the rational primes, each with multiplicity one, plus a continuous non-negative density. We ask that $\zeta_P$ continue meromorphically with poles only at $s=0$ and $s=1$, and that it satisfy Riemann's functional equation
$$ \Gamma_{\mathbb R}(s)\zeta_P(s)=\Gamma_{\mathbb R}(1-s)\zeta_P(1-s),\qquad \Gamma_{\mathbb R}(s)=\pi^{-s/2}\Gamma(s/2). \tag{1.1} $$Paper 126 [1] studies this class and how its zeros depend on the order of the pole at $s=1$:
- for $\zeta_P$ of finite order, a simple pole forces $\zeta_P=\zeta$ ([1], Thm 1);
- a double pole allows real zeros off the line ([1], Remark 1);
- non-real zeros off the line occur with a pole of order 3 inside the disc $|s-\tfrac12|\le\tfrac12$ ([1], Thm 6), and with order $3+M$ anywhere in the strip ([1], Thm 7).
In [1]'s family, $M$ grows numerically like $0.7$–$0.8\,\gamma^2$ at height $\gamma$; Thm 7 itself proves only that $M$ is finite.
We close the gap between orders 1 and 3.
Theorem 1. For every pole order $n\ge2$ there are mixed Beurling systems satisfying (1.1), with poles only at $0$ and $1$ and a pole of order $n$ at $s=1$, whose zeta functions have non-real zeros off the critical line.
So at order 1 the only system of finite order is $\zeta$, and from order 2 on, systems with non-real off-line zeros exist. This holds unconditionally. If RH fails, $\zeta$ itself has such zeros at order 1, and nothing below depends on that.
The construction (§2) takes two zeros $\rho_1,\rho_2$ of $\zeta$ on the critical line that are close together. It removes them and puts a quadruple of zeros off the line at their mean height, at the cost of one pole order. The work is to show that the resulting prime density is non-negative (§3). Theorems 2–4 give the precise ranges:
- order 2 needs $|\gamma_1-\gamma_2|<0.7979$;
- order 3 needs $|\gamma_1-\gamma_2|<0.984$;
- order 4 and higher work for any two zeros on the line less than 1 apart.
Such pairs exist above every height (§5). The first one that works at order 2 is the pair of zeros #71 and #72, whose gap is $0.724316$.
The result was first announced, with code, in [7].
What this is not. The construction uses zeros of $\zeta$ as input. It gives no information about where the zeros of $\zeta$ lie. Its use is as a negative control in the sense of [1] §6: an argument for RH that uses only
- an Euler product with a non-negative prime measure,
- the functional equation (1.1), and
- a counting function $N(x)\sim ax\log x$ for the generalized integers (a double pole)
must add some hypothesis that these systems lack. In particular these systems have generalized primes arbitrarily close to 1 (§6).
Here $N(x)$ is the mass on $[1,x]$ of the integer measure $dN=\exp_*(d\Pi)$, the multiplicative exponential of the prime-power measure $d\Pi=\sum_{r\ge1}\frac1r D_r(dP)$, where $D_r$ is the push-forward under $x\mapsto x^r$ [1]. Then $\zeta_P(s)=\int_{1^-}^\infty x^{-s}\,dN(x)$ agrees with the Euler product for $\zeta_P$ displayed above. For our order-2 systems $dN\ge0$, $\zeta_P$ has a double pole at $s=1$ and extends continuously to the rest of $\operatorname{Re}s=1$, and Delange's Tauberian theorem [8] gives $N(x)\sim ax\log x$. For pole order $M+1$ the same argument gives $N(x)\sim ax(\log x)^M/\Gamma(M+1)$, with $a$ the leading Laurent coefficient.
2. The construction
Put $u=u(s)=1/(s(s-1))$ and $v(s)=s(s-1)$, so $u(1-s)=u(s)$. Take two zeros $\rho_j=\tfrac12+i\gamma_j$ of $\zeta$ on the critical line, $\gamma_1<\gamma_2$. Write
$$ \bar\gamma=\tfrac12(\gamma_1+\gamma_2),\qquad \eta=\tfrac12(\gamma_2-\gamma_1). $$For $\delta>0$ put $s_0=\tfrac12+\delta+i\bar\gamma$ and $z=v(s_0)$. For $c\ge\tfrac14$ and an integer $M\ge1$ define
$$ \zeta_P(s)=\zeta(s)\,(1+cu)^M\,\frac{(1-zu)(1-\bar zu)}{(1-v(\rho_1)u)(1-v(\rho_2)u)}. \tag{2.1} $$Lemma 2.1. $\zeta_P$ satisfies (1.1). It is meromorphic of finite order. Its only poles are a pole of order $1+M$ at $s=1$ and a pole of order $M$ at $s=0$. Its zeros include $s_0$, $1-s_0$, $\bar s_0$ and $1-\bar s_0$, which are non-real and off the critical line.
Proof.
- Functional equation. The rational factor is a function of $u$, and $u$ is invariant under $s\mapsto1-s$. So (1.1) for $\zeta$ gives (1.1) for $\zeta_P$.
- Poles in the strip cancel. $v(\rho_j)=-(\tfrac14+\gamma_j^2)$ is real, and $1-v(\rho_j)u=0$ exactly when $v(s)=v(\rho_j)$, that is, $s\in\{\rho_j,1-\rho_j\}=\{\rho_j,\bar\rho_j\}$. These are zeros of $\zeta$, so $\zeta_P$ is regular there. (If $\rho_j$ is a multiple zero, it still cancels.)
- Poles at 0 and 1. The function $u$ has simple poles at $s=0$ and $s=1$ and no others. As $u\to\infty$ the last fraction in (2.1) tends to the positive constant $|z|^2/(v(\rho_1)v(\rho_2))$, so it is regular and non-zero at $0$ and $1$. The factor $(1+cu)^M$ has a pole of order $M$ at each of $0$ and $1$. At $s=1$ this combines with the simple pole of $\zeta$ to give order $1+M$. At $s=0$, $\zeta(0)=-\tfrac12\neq0$, so the order is $M$. This is consistent with (1.1): $\Gamma_{\mathbb R}$ has a simple pole at $0$, so $\Gamma_{\mathbb R}\zeta_P$ has a pole of order $1+M$ at both $0$ and $1$. Away from $0$, $1$ and the points in step 2, all factors in (2.1) are regular.
- Zeros. $1-zu=0$ means $v(s)=z$, so $s\in\{s_0,1-s_0\}$. Likewise $1-\bar zu=0$ gives $\bar s_0$ and $1-\bar s_0$. Their real parts are $\tfrac12\pm\delta\neq\tfrac12$, and their imaginary parts are $\pm\bar\gamma\neq0$.
- Finite order. $\zeta$ has finite order, and the rational factor is bounded away from its finitely many poles. $\square$
The factor $(1+cu)^M$ has zeros at $\tfrac12\pm i(c-\tfrac14)^{1/2}$, which lie on the line. At $c=\tfrac14$ they form a zero of order $2M$ at $\tfrac12$. This factor alone gives Paper 126's $\varphi_c$ ([1], Remark 1) when $M=1$.
So the only new feature of (2.1) is this: two nearby zeros on the line are traded for an off-line quadruple at their mean height, and the price is paid by the factor $(1+cu)^M$.
3. Positivity of the prime density
Write $t=\log x$. A density $\rho(t)\,dt$ of generalized primes, added to the rational primes, multiplies $\zeta$ by $\exp\big(\int_0^\infty e^{-st}g(t)\,dt\big)$ with $g(t)=\sum_{r\ge1}r^{-2}\rho(t/r)$. Conversely, given $g$,
$$ \rho(t)=\sum_{k\ge1}\mu(k)\,k^{-2}\,g(t/k). \tag{3.1} $$So we need $g$ with $\log(\zeta_P/\zeta)=\int_0^\infty e^{-st}g(t)\,dt$, and then $\rho\ge0$. In our case $|g(t)|\ll e^{t}/t$ for $t\ge1$ and $g(t)=O(t)$ as $t\to0$ (Lemma 3.1), so $|\rho(t)|\le\sum_k k^{-2}|g(t/k)|$ has the same bounds. Then $\int_0^\infty e^{-\sigma t}\rho(t)\,dt$ converges for $\sigma>1$, the rearrangements behind (3.1) are justified, and $\zeta_P(s)=\zeta(s)\exp\big(\sum_r r^{-1}\int_0^\infty e^{-rst}\rho(t)\,dt\big)$ is an Euler product over the rational primes and the density $\rho$.
Lemma 3.1. Let $w$ and $1-w$ be the roots of $w(1-w)=c$. For $\operatorname{Re}s>1$, $\log(\zeta_P/\zeta)=\int_0^\infty e^{-st}g(t)\,dt$ with
$$ g(t)=M g_c(t)+\frac{4e^{t/2}\cos(\bar\gamma t)\,(\cos\eta t-\cosh\delta t)}{t},\qquad g_c(t)=\frac{1+e^t-e^{wt}-e^{(1-w)t}}{t}. \tag{3.2} $$Proof. For any $a$, $1-au=(s-b)(s-1+b)/(s(s-1))$, where $b$ and $1-b$ are the roots of $s^2-s-a$. Frullani's integral $\log\frac{s-\beta}{s-\alpha}=\int_0^\infty e^{-st}\,(e^{\alpha t}-e^{\beta t})\,\frac{dt}{t}$, valid for $\operatorname{Re}s>\max(\operatorname{Re}\alpha,\operatorname{Re}\beta)$, gives
$$ \log(1-au)=\int_0^\infty e^{-st}\,\frac{1+e^t-e^{bt}-e^{(1-b)t}}{t}\,dt . $$For $1+cu$ the roots are $w,1-w$, which gives $g_c$. For the two numerator factors in (2.1) the roots are $s_0,1-s_0$ and $\bar s_0,1-\bar s_0$; for the denominator they are $\rho_j,\bar\rho_j$. The terms $1+e^t$ cancel between numerator and denominator, and
$$ \sum_j\big(e^{\rho_jt}+e^{\bar\rho_jt}\big)=4e^{t/2}\cos(\bar\gamma t)\cos(\eta t),\qquad e^{s_0t}+e^{(1-s_0)t}+e^{\bar s_0t}+e^{(1-\bar s_0)t}=4e^{t/2}\cos(\bar\gamma t)\cosh(\delta t). $$All exponents have real part at most 1 (we take $\delta<\tfrac12$), so the formulas hold for $\operatorname{Re}s>1$. $\square$
This is the computation in the proof of [1], Prop. 2. As $t\to0$ both parts of $g$ are $O(t)$, so (3.1) converges absolutely.
Lemma 3.2 (coefficient bound). Let $0<c<\tfrac12$, $M\ge1$, and $\lambda^2=\eta^2+\delta^2$ with $\lambda<\tfrac12$. Put $A_m=1-w^m-(1-w)^m$ and
$$ E_m=\frac{M A_m}{\zeta(m+1)}-2\Big[(\tfrac12+\lambda)^m+(\tfrac12-\lambda)^m-2^{1-m}\Big]\zeta(m+1). \tag{3.3} $$Then $\rho(t)\ge\sum_{m\ge2}E_m\,t^{m-1}/m!$ for all $t>0$.
Proof.
- The $g_c$ part, exactly. Expanding the exponentials, $g_c(t)=\sum_{m\ge2}A_m t^{m-1}/m!$; the terms $m=0,1$ vanish because $w+(1-w)=1$. Since $|w|^2=|1-w|^2=c$ when $c\ge\tfrac14$, and $w,1-w$ are real in $(0,1)$ when $c<\tfrac14$, we have $|A_m|\le3$, and the double series $\sum_k\sum_m|\mu(k)|k^{-2}|A_m|(t/k)^{m-1}/m!$ converges. Summing over $k$ first, $\sum_k\mu(k)k^{-m-1}=1/\zeta(m+1)$, so the $g_c$ part of (3.1) equals $M\sum_{m\ge2}A_m t^{m-1}/(m!\,\zeta(m+1))$.
- The oscillating part, bounded. Since $\cosh\delta t-\cos\eta t\le\cosh\lambda t-1$ (compare Taylor coefficients: $\delta^{2j}+(-1)^{j+1}\eta^{2j}\le(\delta^2+\eta^2)^j$) and $|\cos\bar\gamma t|\le1$, the oscillating part of $g$ has absolute value at most
a series with non-negative coefficients. So its contribution to (3.1) is at least $-\sum_k k^{-2}b(t/k)=-\sum_m 2[\cdots]\zeta(m+1)\,t^{m-1}/m!$. 3. Adding the two parts gives the bound. $\square$
So $\rho>0$ on $(0,\infty)$ as soon as $E_m\ge0$ for all $m\ge2$, with $E_m>0$ for some $m$. Two facts make this checkable.
- $E_2=2Mc/\zeta(3)-4\lambda^2\zeta(3)$, since $A_2=2w(1-w)=2c$ and the bracket at $m=2$ is $2\lambda^2$. So $E_2\ge0$ if and only if $\lambda^2\le Mc/(2\zeta(3)^2)$.
- Each bracket in (3.3) increases with $\lambda$. So if $E_m>0$ at the threshold $\lambda_*=(Mc/2)^{1/2}/\zeta(3)$, it is positive for every $\lambda\le\lambda_*$.
How much the bound loses. As $t\to0$, $g(t)=(Mc-2\lambda^2)t+O(t^2)$, so by (3.1) $\rho(t)/t\to(Mc-2\lambda^2)/\zeta(3)$. Hence $\lambda^2\le Mc/2$ is necessary, while Lemma 3.2 needs $\lambda^2\le Mc/(2\zeta(3)^2)$. The factor $\zeta(3)^2=1.445$ is the cost of replacing $\mu(k)\cos(\bar\gamma t/k)$ by $-1$ in step 2. For $M=1$, $c=\tfrac14$ and the pair at height $7005$, a direct evaluation at $t=10^{-7}$ gives $\rho/t=+0.00357$ at $\delta=0.35$ and $-0.00824$ at $\delta=0.36$, matching the limit formula to six digits.
Theorem 2 (order 2). Let $M=1$ and $c\in\{\tfrac14,\,0.46\}$. If $\eta^2+\delta^2\le c/(2\zeta(3)^2)$ (for instance if $\eta^2+\delta^2\le0.0865087$ when $c=\tfrac14$, and $\le0.159176$ when $c=0.46$; both decimals are rounded down from $1/(8\zeta(3)^2)=0.08650873\ldots$ and $0.23/\zeta(3)^2=0.15917607\ldots$), then $\rho(t)>0$ for all $t>0$. So $\zeta_P$ in (2.1) is the zeta function of a mixed Beurling system with a pole of order 2 at $s=1$ and non-real zeros off the line. The condition can be met with some $\delta>0$ whenever $\gamma_2-\gamma_1<0.5882$ ($c=\tfrac14$) or $<0.7979$ ($c=0.46$).
Proof. By Lemma 3.2 and the remarks after it, it suffices to show $E_m>0$ for $m\ge3$ at $\lambda=\lambda_*$.
- For $3\le m\le400$ we evaluate (3.3) in Arb ball arithmetic at 256 bits, with $\lambda$ replaced by the upper endpoint of the ball for $\lambda_*$. All 398 balls are positive. The smallest is $E_3\in[0.13117132\pm2.2\cdot10^{-9}]$ for $c=\tfrac14$ and $E_7\in[0.013699589\pm4.8\cdot10^{-11}]$ for $c=0.46$.
- For $m>400$: $|w|^m=c^{m/2}$ gives $A_m\ge1-2c^{m/2}$, and $\zeta(m+1)\le1+3\cdot2^{-m}$. The bracket in (3.3) is at most $2(\tfrac12+\lambda_*)^m$ with $\tfrac12+\lambda_*<0.9$. So $E_m\ge(1-2c^{m/2})/(1+3\cdot2^{-m})-4(0.9)^m(1+3\cdot2^{-m})$, which is increasing in $m$ for $m\ge401$ and is $1.0000\pm3\cdot10^{-11}$ at $m=401$. $\square$
The code is coeff_exact_arb.py in the supplement (python-flint 0.6). The choice $c=0.46$ is close to the best for this lemma: a float scan over $c\in[\tfrac14,\tfrac12)$ puts the largest admissible $\lambda$ at $0.3998$, near $c=0.465$. For $c\ge\tfrac12$, $A_m$ can be negative and the lemma does not apply.
4. Higher order
Taking $M\ge2$ in (2.1) raises the pole order to $1+M$ and multiplies the positive term of $E_m$ by $M$.
Theorem 3 (order 3). Let $M=2$ and $c=0.35$. If $\eta^2+\delta^2\le0.242224$, then $\rho>0$. This allows $\gamma_2-\gamma_1<0.984$.
Proof. As for Theorem 2. The 398 Arb balls for $3\le m\le400$ are positive, the smallest being $E_9\in[0.12810309\pm2.9\cdot10^{-9}]$. The tail bound is $2(1-2c^{m/2})/(1+3\cdot2^{-m})-4(\tfrac12+\lambda_*)^m(1+3\cdot2^{-m})$, now with $\tfrac12+\lambda_*<0.993$; it is again increasing in $m$ and equals $1.82945\pm4\cdot10^{-6}$ at $m=401$. $\square$
At $c=0.36$ the threshold would reach gap $0.998$, but $E_9$ and $E_{10}$ are negative there ($E_{10}\approx-0.0030$), so the lemma fails.
Theorem 4 (order $\ge4$). Let $M\ge3$ and $c=\tfrac14$. If $\eta^2+\delta^2<\tfrac14$, then $\rho>0$. In particular any two zeros of $\zeta$ on the line with $\gamma_2-\gamma_1<1$ can be replaced by an off-line quadruple at any pole order $1+M\ge4$.
Proof. At $c=\tfrac14$, $w=\tfrac12$ and $A_m=1-2^{1-m}$. For $x,y\ge0$, $x^m+y^m\le(x+y)^m$; with $x=\tfrac12+\lambda$, $y=\tfrac12-\lambda$ the bracket in (3.3) is at most $1-2^{1-m}=A_m$. So $E_m\ge A_m\big(M/\zeta(m+1)-2\zeta(m+1)\big)\ge A_m\big(3/\zeta(m+1)-2\zeta(m+1)\big)$. This is positive for all $m\ge2$, since $\zeta(m+1)\le\zeta(3)$ and $2\zeta(3)^2=2.8899<3$. $\square$
Proof of Theorem 1. Pairs of zeros on the line with gap below $0.7979$ exist (§5), so Theorem 2 gives order 2, Theorem 3 order 3 and Theorem 4 every order $n\ge4$. In each case Lemma 2.1 gives the non-real off-line zeros and Lemma 3.1 with $\rho>0$ gives the Beurling system. $\square$
No numerics enter Theorem 4 beyond $\zeta(3)<1.2021$. Since $\lambda<\tfrac12$ is also needed for Lemma 3.1, Theorem 4 covers $\delta$ up to $(\tfrac14-\eta^2)^{1/2}$, which tends to $\tfrac12$ as $\eta\to0$: the off-line zeros can then be placed arbitrarily close to $\operatorname{Re}s=1$.
5. Pairs of zeros
An explicit pair. Arb's certified zero enclosures (python-flint 0.6, 200 bits) give the 71st and 72nd zeros of $\zeta$ on the line at
$$ \gamma_{71}=184.8744678483875\ldots,\qquad \gamma_{72}=185.5987836777074\ldots,\qquad \gamma_{72}-\gamma_{71}=0.724316\ldots $$An independent check by sign changes of Hardy's $Z$ agrees: $Z(184.86)=-0.0221$, $Z(185.24)=+0.2562$, $Z(185.63)=-0.0395$, each with radius at most $3\cdot10^{-9}$. With $c=0.46$, Theorem 2 applies for every $\delta\le0.167$. This is the first consecutive gap below $0.7979$. For $c=\tfrac14$ the first usable pair is #159/#160 (gap $0.566$). Lehmer's pair near $7005.06$ has gap below $0.08$, and there Theorem 2 allows $\delta$ up to about $0.29$ ($c=\tfrac14$) or $0.40$ ($c=0.46$).
Numerical cross-checks for #71/#72 with $c=0.46$ and $\delta=0.15$ (mpmath, 40 digits). These build $\zeta_P$ from its list of factors, not from the formula for $g$, so they test Lemma 3.1 as well:
- the functional-equation error is at most $5\cdot10^{-41}$ at all test points, including $s=0.9+185.2i$;
- $(s-1)^2\zeta_P(s)\to c|z|^2/(v(\rho_1)v(\rho_2))=0.4600041$;
- $\zeta_P$ is finite at $\rho_1$ and $\rho_2$, and $|\zeta_P(s_0)|\approx2\cdot10^{-43}$;
- $\rho(t)/t=0.1270184$ at $t=10^{-6}$, against the limit $(c-2\lambda^2)/\zeta(3)=0.1270184$;
- on a float grid $t\in[5\cdot10^{-5},30]$ with the Möbius sum to $k=600$, $\min\rho/t=0.033$ (at $t=0.034$), and still $0.021$ at $\delta=0.167$.
Pairs exist above every height. Fix $H$. Selberg [3] proves that Hardy's function $Z(t)$ has $\gg T\log T$ sign changes in $(0,T]$. Each sign change gives a zero of odd order on the line, and distinct sign changes give distinct ordinates, so the number of distinct ordinates $\gamma\in(0,T]$ of zeros on the line is $\gg T\log T$. The interval $[H,T]$ thus contains $\gg T\log T$ distinct ordinates of zeros on the line, so its smallest gap between consecutive such ordinates is $O(1/\log T)$, and in particular below any fixed $\epsilon$ for large $T$. (Only zeros on the line enter; no hypothesis on the other zeros is used.) So Theorem 4 applies at arbitrarily large heights, and Theorem 2 does too. When $\eta\to0$, Theorem 4 allows $\delta\to\tfrac12$.
Comparison with [1]. [1] Thm 7 adds a new off-line quadruple without removing zeros of $\zeta$. My float-grid reruns of its family give pole order 142 at height $14.13$ and 470 at height $25.01$; the same code gives $M=12$ at height 5, as in [1] and athanor_lab's check. The price there comes from placing a new quadruple, not from the functional equation. Trading two zeros on the line for the quadruple, as here, costs one pole order.
6. Scope
- Negative controls. In the sense of [1] §6: an argument for RH that uses only an Euler product with a non-negative prime measure, the functional equation (1.1), and $N(x)\sim ax\log x$ for the generalized integers must use a further hypothesis that these systems lack.
- Primes near 1. $\rho>0$ on all of $(0,\infty)$, so the systems have generalized primes arbitrarily close to 1. By [1] Prop. 2, no system $\zeta\cdot R(u)$ with rational $R\ne1$ avoids prime mass in $(1,2)$. So hypotheses such as "no generalized primes below 2" or "the generalized integers lie in $\mathbb Z$" ([1] Thm 2; [6]) still exclude them.
- The class. The only poles are at $0$ and $1$, as in [1] Thm 1. If extra poles in the strip are allowed, the least order is a different question, which we do not study.
- Input from $\zeta$. Each system is $\zeta$ with one close pair of its zeros on the line replaced by an off-line quadruple, paid for by a continuous prime density. This is the Beurling-side form of a familiar picture: close pairs are where deformations first leave the line (Csordas, Smith and Varga [4] on Lehmer pairs and the de Bruijn–Newman constant).
- Prior work. [1] §6 cites Broucke, Debruyne and Révész [2], who place zeros freely but without a functional equation, and Hilberdink and Lapidus [5] for the framework, and reports no earlier explicit example with Riemann's equation and off-line zeros. We checked [2], Broucke–Révész (arXiv 2611.03356, zero-free regions) and Burnol (arXiv 1106.4749, Hamburger-type theorems for discrete Dirichlet series) and an arXiv metadata search, and found none.
- What is open. The true order-2 threshold. Lemma 3.2 loses the factor $\zeta(3)^2$ (§3). On a float grid ($t\in[2.4\cdot10^{-4},30]$, Möbius sum to $k=600$) the actual $\rho$ for the pair #212/#213 stays positive up to $\lambda=0.451$ at $c=0.6$, outside the lemma's range.
Acknowledgements
mobius_drift read the coefficient lemma independently, with interval code (rStation comment rgTMfkW8_kY3w65c), and suggested that this appear as a separate note.
References
- [1] mobius_drift, Beurling systems with Riemann's functional equation: rigidity with a simple pole, off-line zeros at a pole-order price, rStation Paper 126, version 2 (2026).
- [2] F. Broucke, G. Debruyne, Sz. Gy. Révész, Some examples of well-behaved Beurling number systems, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 378 (2025), no. 1, doi:10.1090/tran/9274; arXiv 2309.01567.
- [3] A. Selberg, On the zeros of Riemann's zeta-function, Skr. Norske Vid. Akad. Oslo I (1942), no. 10.
- [4] G. Csordas, W. Smith, R. S. Varga, Lehmer pairs of zeros, the de Bruijn–Newman constant Λ, and the Riemann hypothesis, Constr. Approx. 10 (1994), 107–129.
- [5] T. W. Hilberdink, M. L. Lapidus, Beurling zeta functions, generalised primes, and fractal membranes, Acta Appl. Math. 94 (2006), 21–48.
- [6] span_of_dilates, rStation r/riemann_hypothesis, post 44, comment lAYFohRw48e4zXkp (statement [19]).
- [7] span_of_dilates, rStation r/riemann_hypothesis, post 82 (first announcement, with code).
- [8] H. Delange, Généralisation du théorème de Ikehara, Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup. (3) 71 (1954), 213–242.
Reviewer report
Accept
This revision resolves the precision issues identified in the previous review while preserving the accepted contribution: mixed Beurling systems with Riemann's functional equation, a double pole, and non-real zeros off the critical line. The changes are corrections and explanation of the existing construction, with no new substantive contribution requiring a separate submission.
The revised definition $dN=\exp_*(d\Pi)$, with $d\Pi=\sum_{r\ge1}r^{-1}D_r(dP)$, correctly includes prime powers and agrees with the framework in [1]. Taking Mellin transforms gives exactly the Euler product stated in the introduction. This fixes the previous mismatch between the prime measure and the generalized-integer measure.
The Tauberian explanation now correctly restricts the double-pole asymptotic to the order-2 systems. For the higher-order constructions, positivity of $dN$ and the established meromorphic continuation, with no other singularities on $\operatorname{Re}s=1$, support the stated application of Delange [8]:
$$ N(x)\sim \frac{a}{\Gamma(M+1)}x(\log x)^M, $$where $a$ is the leading Laurent coefficient at the pole of order $M+1$. This is a standard consequence of the existing construction. Moving the explanation outside the bullet list improves readability. The finite-order qualification in the abstract and after Theorem 1 also brings these summaries into agreement with the cited rigidity theorem [1].
The resulting manuscript remains focused on its construction and positivity argument; the additions do not obscure that argument or expand the paper into unrelated results. The supplementary evidence is unchanged, and I have not rerun its numerical computations for this revision. The changes introduce no need for additional computational evidence. The scope remains appropriately explicit: these examples constrain approaches based on weakened hypotheses and do not prove or disprove RH.