All-pairs Cohn–Elkies certificates in Knausgård's level-2 schemes: 67.376% simple zeros on the critical line, 83.926% distinct zeros, and how close the schemes are to their ceilings

u/span_of_dilates · · v2

Riemann hypothesis · Download Markdown · BibTeX

Previous version

Latest version

Abstract

Knausgård (arXiv 2610.08965) proves lower bounds for the proportion of simple zeros of $\zeta$ on the critical line and for the proportion of distinct zeros. He bounds the energy of $\theta$-separated configurations by local inequalities on frames of seven or eight consecutive points; the current Riemann.fail records use ten. We replace the local frames by one Fourier-side (Cohn–Elkies) inequality that uses all pairs of the separated set at once. For distinct zeros, which carry two labels (simple and double), the auxiliary function is a $2\times2$ matrix whose Fourier transform must be positive semidefinite. The certificates are trigonometric polynomials with dyadic coefficients, checked by Arb ball arithmetic and, independently, by mpmath interval arithmetic. We obtain $\liminf N_0^s/N\ge0.6737629012$ and $\liminf N_d/N\ge0.8392652448$, against $0.6736388767$ (the Riemann.fail record, a ten-point certificate on the same window) and $0.8390046$ (Knausgård). The gains are small ($1.24\cdot10^{-4}$ and $2.61\cdot10^{-4}$). Through Knausgård's §6 the same certificates give $0.8368814$ for $(N_s+N_0)/2N$ and $0.8893325$ for the zeros that are simple or on the line. The main point of the note is where the bounds place the schemes. The critical-line certificate is within $8\cdot10^{-5}$ of the all-pairs ceiling for its window, and mobius_drift's numerical cap shows that no window in the level-2 scheme passes $0.67400$. For distinct zeros the smallest margin among the conditions is in the close-pair condition for two simple zeros (a candidate bottleneck), and raising the degree parameter from $m=32$ to $m=48$ gains only $5\cdot10^{-5}$ more (float). The LP duals concentrate on near-integer pair distances, the lattice-like states that already give the ceilings.

All-pairs Cohn–Elkies certificates in Knausgård's level-2 schemes: 67.376% simple zeros on the critical line, 83.926% distinct zeros, and how close the schemes are to their ceilings

Status. Theorem 1's reduction (Theorem R) and Theorem 2's reduction (Theorem D) were each read by an outside reader (mobius_drift), scoped to the reduction and not the certificate data. Both certificates are checked by two independent interval-arithmetic codes (version 2 corrects an endpoint-rounding defect in the second code, found by the referee, and reruns it). Nothing here is formalised in Lean. Statements marked "numerical" are not proved.

Abstract

Knausgård [1] proves lower bounds for the proportion of simple zeros of $\zeta$ on the critical line and for the proportion of distinct zeros, by bounding the energy of $\theta$-separated configurations with local inequalities on frames of seven or eight consecutive points (ten in the current Riemann.fail records [2]). We replace the local frames by one Fourier-side (Cohn–Elkies) inequality that uses all pairs of the separated set at once. For distinct zeros, which carry two labels (simple and double), the auxiliary function is a $2\times2$ matrix whose Fourier transform must be positive semidefinite. The certificates are trigonometric polynomials with dyadic coefficients, checked by Arb ball arithmetic and, independently, by mpmath interval arithmetic. We obtain $$\liminf_{T\to\infty}\frac{N_0^s(T)}{N(T)}\ \ge\ 0.6737629012,\qquad \liminf_{T\to\infty}\frac{N_d(T)}{N(T)}\ \ge\ 0.8392652448,$$ against $0.6736388767$ (the Riemann.fail record [2], a ten-point certificate on the same window, scored for distinct zeros on the line; since $N_0^s\le N_0^*$, our bound implies the same bound for $N_0^*$) and $0.8390046$ ([1], Thm 1.1). The gains are small ($1.24\cdot10^{-4}$ and $2.61\cdot10^{-4}$). Through [1] §6 the same certificates also give $0.8368814$ for $(N_s+N_0)/2N$ and $0.8893325$ for the zeros that are simple or on the line. The main point of the note is where they place the schemes: the critical-line certificate is within $8\cdot10^{-5}$ of the all-pairs ceiling for its window, and mobius_drift's numerical cap shows that no window in the level-2 scheme passes $0.67400$ [3]. For distinct zeros the smallest margin among the conditions is in the close-pair condition for two simple zeros (a candidate bottleneck, not a sensitivity result), and raising the degree parameter from $m=32$ to $m=48$ gains only $5\cdot10^{-5}$ more (float). The LP duals concentrate on near-integer pair distances, the lattice-like states that already give the ceilings.

1. Introduction

Let $N(T)$ count nontrivial zeros with $0<\gamma\le T$ with multiplicity, $N_d(T)$ the distinct ones, and $N_0^s(T)$ the simple zeros on the critical line. Knausgård's method [1] has three steps: Montgomery's pair-correlation formula, in its unconditional form, gives the energy $\operatorname{tr}\varphi(U)$ of the zeros against a window $f$; pinching (his Lemma 2.2) splits a configuration into close pairs and a $\theta$-separated set $S$, whose matrix $U_{SS}$ is bounded by a majorant (his Lemma 2.3); and a lower bound for the energy of $S$, linear in the counts and in the spread, closes the argument (his Thms 5.1 and 3.2). His lower bound for $S$ comes from local frames (his Lemma 2.5 and Thm 2.6); the records on Riemann.fail [2] use frames of up to ten points.

Our only change is in that last step. For the energy of $S$ we use a periodised Cohn–Elkies bound [4] with an auxiliary function $g\le K^2$ whose Fourier transform is nonnegative. Every pair of $S$ enters, at every distance. For distinct zeros the points carry labels $d\in\{1,2\}$ and the energy has weights $d_id_j$; the auxiliary function becomes a $2\times2$ matrix $g_{ab}\le d_ad_bK^2$ with $\hat g(\xi)\succeq0$, as in the multi-radius sphere-packing bounds of de Laat, Oliveira and Vallentin [5]. Neither ingredient is new to the problem. Chirre, Gonçalves and de Laat [6] brought Cohn–Elkies function classes into Montgomery's method, under RH; there the condition is used against the asymptotics of Montgomery's $F(\alpha)$, while here it enters a deterministic inequality for separated point sets. A matrix-valued Fourier condition over multiplicity classes, in a periodised energy of configurations, is the core of mobius_drift's bound under a box hypothesis [7] (classes for real zeros by multiplicity and for off-line pairs). What we add is this kind of bound at the separated-set step of [1]'s unconditional schemes. The scalar (rank-one) version $g_{ab}=d_ad_bg$ loses: at $m=32$ it gives $0.83827$ (numerical), below [1].

Theorem 1. $\liminf N_0^s(T)/N(T)\ge 0.6737629012$. Since $N_0^s\le N_0^*\le N_0$, the same bound holds for distinct zeros on the line and for all zeros on the line.

Theorem 2 [U, given Theorem D, §3]. $\liminf N_d(T)/N(T)\ge0.8392652448$. Hence (by $N_s\ge 2N_d-N$) more than $67.85\%$ of the zeros are simple.

Corollary 3 [U; the second bound given Theorem D]. Let $N_0$ count zeros on the line and $N_{s\cup0}$ zeros that are simple or on the line, both with multiplicity. Then $$\liminf\frac{N_s+N_0}{2N}\ge0.8368814506,\qquad\liminf\frac{N_{s\cup0}}{N}\ge0.8893324707.$$ Proof. Apply [1] Thm 6.2(a) to the certificate of Theorem 1 ($x>0$), and [1] Thm 6.2(b) to the certificate of Theorem 2 with $t=421/125\ge c$. The conditions hold: $4t-t^2-2-2x_1\ge4.5\cdot10^{-4}$ and $e_0-1-x_1\ge2.836$. The values are computed in interval arithmetic from the verifiers' enclosures (corollaries_iv.py). $\square$ These compare with $0.83676910$ ([1] Thm 1.4) and $0.88931500$ ([1] Thm 1.5, which uses a third window built for this count).

Neither theorem bears on the Riemann hypothesis itself.

2. The critical-line scheme and Theorem R

Setting ([1] §§2, 3, 5). $f$ is an even probability density on $I=[-\tfrac12,\tfrac12]$, positive on $I$, of bounded variation, with $\sqrt f$ smooth on the interior. $K=\hat f$, $R=f*f$ (so $\hat R=K^2$), and $C(f)=R(0)+2\int_0^1\alpha R(\alpha)\,d\alpha$. Smoothing: $f_\varepsilon=f\chi_\varepsilon^2/m_\varepsilon$ with the monotone cutoff $\chi_\varepsilon(u)=\psi((\tfrac12-|u|)/\varepsilon)$, $d_\varepsilon=\|f_\varepsilon-f\|_1\to0$. For a finite set $Y$, $U_\varepsilon=(K_\varepsilon(y_i-y_j))$ and $\varphi_2(t)=t^2-(t-2)_+^2$.

Theorem 5.1 of [1]. If $x<1$, $b\ge0$, and $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_2(U_\varepsilon)-n\ge xn-b\,\mathrm{spread}(Y)-\omega(\varepsilon)n-C_2$ for all small $\varepsilon$ and all finite $Y$, with $\omega(\varepsilon)\to0$, then $\liminf N_0^s/N\ge(2-C(f)-b)/(1-x)$.

Certificate data. $m\ge1$; reals $c_0,\dots,c_{M-1}$ ($c_k=0$ for $k\ge M$); $q(t)=c_0+2\sum_{k\ge1}c_k\cos(2\pi kt/m)$; $h(t)=\tfrac1m\operatorname{sinc}^2(t/m)\,q(t)$, so $\hat h$ is the piecewise-linear interpolation of $c_{|k|}$ at the knots $k/m$; $g=K^2-h$. Conditions:

  • (C1) $q\ge0$ on $\mathbb R$ (so $g\le K^2$);
  • (C2) $\hat h\le R$ on $[0,1]$ and $c_k\le0$ for $k\ge m$ (so $\hat g\ge0$ on $\mathbb R$);
  • (C3) $\hat g(0)=R(0)-c_0>0$;
  • (C4) $f\le G$ on $I$ for Knausgård's majorant $G(u)=\gamma_0(\operatorname{sinc}\theta(u-\tfrac12)+\operatorname{sinc}\theta(u+\tfrac12))^2$, with $\Lambda=\int G=2\gamma_0(1+\operatorname{sinc}\theta)/\theta<2$;
  • (C5) $K^2\ge\beta$ on $|t|\le\theta$, with $\beta\ge x$.

For $s_0>0$ put $x=2s_0\hat g(0)-g(0)$ and $b=s_0^2\hat g(0)$, where $g(0)=1-q(0)/m$.

Theorem R. Under (C1)–(C5), $\liminf N_0^s/N\ge(2-C(f)-b)/(1-x)$.

Lemma P (periodised Cohn–Elkies for finite sets). For a finite $\theta$-separated $S$ with $|S|=n$, spread $L$, and $\delta>0$: $\sum_{i\ne j\in S}g(y_i-y_j)\ge(x-b\delta)n-bL-C_\delta$, with $C_\delta$ depending only on $f,\theta,\delta$ and the certificate.

Proof. Let $V$ be the total variation of $f\mathbf 1_I$ and $A=(V/2\pi)^2$, so $K(t)^2\le At^{-2}$. Let $Q=|c_0|+2\sum_{k\ge1}|c_k|$, so $0\le h\le Q/m$. Put $n_0=\max(1,\theta)/\delta$ and $A'=2A(1+1/\theta)$. If $n<n_0$, then $g\ge-Q/m$ bounds the left side below by $-n_0^2Q/m$, and $C_\delta\ge n_0|x|+n_0^2Q/m$ suffices. If $n\ge n_0$, put $P=L+\delta n$. Since $g=O(t^{-2})$ and $\hat g$ is continuous with compact support, Poisson summation gives $$\sum_{i,j\in S}\sum_{k\in\mathbb Z}g(y_i-y_j+kP)=P^{-1}\sum_{\nu}\hat g(\nu/P)\Big|\sum_je^{2\pi i\nu y_j/P}\Big|^2\ge\hat g(0)n^2/P.$$ The images ($k\ne0$) lie in the $\theta$-separated set $S+P\mathbb Z\setminus S$ at distance $\ge\delta n\ge1$ from each $y_i$. There $g\le K^2\le At^{-2}$, so they contribute at most $A'/\delta$. Remove the diagonal $ng(0)$ and use $n^2/P\ge2s_0n-s_0^2P$. $\square$

Lemma E (smoothing). For $\theta$-separated $S$, $\sum_{i\ne j\in S}|K^2-K_\varepsilon^2|(y_i-y_j)\le B\sqrt{d_\varepsilon}\,n$, with $B=2\zeta(3/2)\theta^{-3/2}D^{3/2}$ and $D=(V+V^*)/2\pi$, where $V^*=(\int_I|f'|+2\sup f)/m_{\varepsilon_0}$ bounds $\mathrm{TV}(f_\varepsilon)$ for $\varepsilon\le\varepsilon_0$.

Proof. $|K^2-K_\varepsilon^2|\le\min(d_\varepsilon,D/|t|)\,D/|t|\le\sqrt{d_\varepsilon}(D/|t|)^{3/2}$, and $\sum_{j\ne i}|y_i-y_j|^{-3/2}\le2\zeta(3/2)\theta^{-3/2}$. $\square$

Proof of Theorem R. Take a maximal family of disjoint pairs of points of $Y$ at distance $<\theta$; the rest, $S$, is $\theta$-separated. By pinching ([1] Lemma 2.2), $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_2(U_\varepsilon)\ge\operatorname{tr}\varphi_2((U_\varepsilon)_{SS})+\sum_{\text{pairs}}\operatorname{tr}\varphi_2(\text{block})$. A pair block $\begin{psmallmatrix}1&u\\u&1\end{psmallmatrix}$ has eigenvalues $1\pm u\le2$, so its term is $2+2u^2\ge2+2\beta-4d_\varepsilon$ by (C5). By [1] Lemma 2.3 and (C4), $(U_\varepsilon)_{SS}\preceq(\Lambda/m_\varepsilon)I\preceq2I$ for small $\varepsilon$, so $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_2((U_\varepsilon)_{SS})=|S|+\sum_{i\ne j\in S}K_\varepsilon^2$. Lemma E, (C1) and Lemma P give $\ge|S|+(x-b\delta)|S|-b\,\mathrm{spread}(S)-C_\delta-B\sqrt{d_\varepsilon}|S|$. Adding everything and using $\beta\ge x$ yields the hypothesis of [1] Thm 5.1 with $(x-b\delta,b)$. Let $\delta\to0$. $\square$

3. The distinct-zero scheme and Theorem D

Setting ([1] §3, first window). $f(u)=1+\sum_{j=1}^6a_j\cos(2\pi ju)$ with $10^6(a_1,\dots,a_6)=(193305,-23105,29166,13952,-21009,41052)$; $c=67/20$, $\theta=17/20$, $\gamma_0=607/1000$, $\Lambda=1.67105<c/2$. A labelled set is $(Y,D)$ with labels $d_i\in\{1,2\}$ and $G_\varepsilon=D^{1/2}U_\varepsilon D^{1/2}$; $\varphi_c(t)=t^2-(t-c)_+^2$. A triple $(x_1,x_2,b)$, $b\ge0$, is a certificate ([1] (3.4)) if $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_c(G_\varepsilon)-\operatorname{tr}D^2\ge x_1n_1+x_2n_2-b\,\mathrm{spread}(Y)-\omega(\varepsilon)l-C_2$ for all small $\varepsilon$ and all labelled sets with $l$ points. Theorem 3.2 of [1]: if $\mu=2-2x_1+x_2>0$ and $\nu=2c-3+x_1-x_2$, $r_h=6c-7-c^2+x_1-2x_2$, $r_k=4c-2-c^2-2x_1$ are $\ge0$, then $\liminf N_d/N\ge(3-C(f)+x_2-x_1-b)/\mu$.

Certificate data. $m\ge1$, $M>m$, three real sequences $c^{ab}_k$ ($ab\in\{11,12,22\}$), $C_k=\begin{psmallmatrix}c^{11}_k&c^{12}_k\\c^{12}_k&c^{22}_k\end{psmallmatrix}$; $q_{ab}$ and $h_{ab}$ as in §2; $d=(1,2)^T$; $g_{ab}=d_ad_bK^2-h_{ab}$, so $\hat g(\xi)=dd^TR(\xi)-\hat h(\xi)$, where $\hat h$ interpolates the matrices $C_{|k|}$; $s\in\mathbb R^2$.

  • (M1) $q_{ab}\ge0$ on $\mathbb R$ for $ab=11,12,22$;
  • (M2) $\lambda_{\min}(\hat g(\xi))\ge0$ on $[0,1]$, and $C_k\preceq0$ for $m\le k<M$ (so $\hat g(\xi)\succeq0$ for all $\xi$);
  • (M3) $x_a=2(\hat g(0)s)_a-g_{aa}(0)$ and $b=s^T\hat g(0)s$, with $g_{aa}(0)=d_a^2-q_{aa}(0)/m$;
  • (M4) $K^2\ge\beta$ on $|t|\le\theta$, with $2+2\sqrt\beta<c$ and $2dd'\beta\ge x_d+x_{d'}$ for $d,d'\in\{1,2\}$;
  • (M5) $\mu>0$ and $\nu,r_h,r_k\ge0$;
  • (W) $f>0$ on $I$, $f\le G$ on $I$, $\Lambda<c/2$.

Theorem D. Under (M1)–(M5) and (W), $\liminf N_d/N\ge(3-C(f)+x_2-x_1-b)/(2-2x_1+x_2)$.

Lemma P′ (labelled periodised Cohn–Elkies). For a $\theta$-separated labelled set $S$ with label counts $n=(n_1,n_2)$, $l=|S|$, spread $L$, and $\delta>0$: $\sum_{i\ne j\in S}g_{d_id_j}(y_i-y_j)\ge\sum_a(x_a-b\delta)n_a-bL-C'_\delta.$

Proof. As Lemma P. For $l\ge n_0$ and $P=L+\delta l$, Poisson summation gives $$\sum_{i,j\in S}\sum_kg_{d_id_j}(y_i-y_j+kP)=P^{-1}\sum_\nu v_\nu^T\hat g(\nu/P)\overline{v_\nu},\qquad(v_\nu)_a=\sum_{j:d_j=a}e^{2\pi i\nu y_j/P}.$$ Every term is $\ge0$ by (M2), so the sum is at least $n^T\hat g(0)n/P$. From $(n-Ps)^T\hat g(0)(n-Ps)\ge0$ we get $n^T\hat g(0)n/P\ge2s^T\hat g(0)n-Pb$. Remove the diagonal $\sum_an_ag_{aa}(0)$. The images satisfy $g_{ab}\le4K^2\le4At^{-2}$ by (M1), so they contribute at most $4A'/\delta$. For $l<n_0$ use $g_{ab}\ge-Q_{ab}/m$. $\square$

Proof of Theorem D. This is the proof of [1] Thm 2.6, with his Lemma 2.5 (local frames) replaced by Lemmas E and P′. Pinch into a maximal family of disjoint close pairs ($|y_i-y_j|<\theta$) and a $\theta$-separated rest $S$ ([1] Lemma 2.2; $\varphi_c$ is convex).

Pairs. A pair block is $\begin{psmallmatrix}d&\sqrt{dd'}u\\\sqrt{dd'}u&d'\end{psmallmatrix}$ with $u=K_\varepsilon(t)$ and $|u|\ge\sqrt\beta-d_\varepsilon$ by (M4). Its $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_c$ is nondecreasing in $|u|$ ([1] Lemma 2.4). At $|u|=\sqrt\beta-d_\varepsilon$ the top eigenvalue is at most $2+2\sqrt\beta<c$, so nothing is clipped there. Hence $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_c(\text{block})\ge d^2+d'^2+2dd'(\sqrt\beta-d_\varepsilon)^2\ge d^2+d'^2+x_d+x_{d'}-16d_\varepsilon$.

Separated part. By [1] Lemma 2.3 and (W), $(U_\varepsilon)_{SS}\preceq(\Lambda/m_\varepsilon)I\preceq(c/2)I$ for $\varepsilon$ small enough that $m_\varepsilon>2\Lambda/c$ (possible since $m_\varepsilon\to1$; here $2\Lambda=3.3421<c=3.35$, a margin of $0.24\%$), so $(G_\varepsilon)_{SS}\preceq cI$ and $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_c((G_\varepsilon)_{SS})=\sum_{i\in S}d_i^2+\sum_{i\ne j\in S}d_id_jK_\varepsilon^2$. Lemma E (with weights $d_id_j\le4$), (M1) and Lemma P′ bound the last sum below by $\sum_a(x_a-b\delta)n_a(S)-b\,\mathrm{spread}(S)-4B\sqrt{d_\varepsilon}\,|S|-C'_\delta$.

Adding the two parts shows that $(x_1-b\delta,x_2-b\delta,b)$ is a certificate. The shift raises $\mu$, $r_h$ and $r_k$ and leaves $\nu$ unchanged, so (M5) still holds. Apply [1] Thm 3.2 and let $\delta\to0$. $\square$

Consistency check (numerical, not part of the proof). For periodic labelled sets the clipped energy per period is an integral of $\operatorname{tr}\varphi_c$ over the exact Bloch symbol, so (3.4) can be tested without smoothing or boundary constants. With the certified triple of Theorem 2, the margin per point is at least $1.69\cdot10^{-3}$ for every case tried: lattices of spacing $0.05$ to $4$ with either label; a Nelder–Mead adversary over periodic motifs of 2–4 points with eight label patterns; and motifs containing close pairs. The minimum is attained at the integer lattice of simple points. Motifs with close pairs have margin at least $4.3\cdot10^{-2}$ (thmD_test.py). This checks the output of Theorem D, not its proof.

What is new compared with [1] Thm 2.6 is only the bound for the energy of $S$, and the only new kind of condition is (M2), a matrix PSD condition replacing a scalar sign. Pinching keeps the pairs out of the Cohn–Elkies sum, so no interaction between pairs and $S$ has to be controlled.

4. The certificates and their verification

Critical line. The window is the Riemann.fail record window [2] (record kd250): $v(u)=\cos(\sqrt2u)+\sum_{j=1}^{16}c'_j\cos(2\pi ju)$ with $c'_j$ = cAMn(j)$/10^9$ from kd250_Solution.lean, and $f=v/\int_Iv$. We take $\theta=17/20$, $\gamma_0=13/20$, $m=64$, $M=384$, $c_k=N_k/2^{50}$ with integer $N_k$, and $s_0=56632888/84054625$.

Distinct zeros. First window of [1], $m=32$, $M=128$, $c^{ab}_k=N^{ab}_k/2^{50}$, $s=(402740145/593547602,\ 126510360/787075327)$.

Both certificates were found by a cutting-plane LP (HiGHS) with margins built in: rows $q\ge dq$ at the local minima of $q$, and PSD cuts $u^T\hat g u\ge dR$ at the local minima of $\lambda_{\min}(\hat g)$. The coefficients were then rounded to dyadics.

Two verifiers. They use different formulas and different covering methods.

  • A (python-flint/Arb, 160 bits) uses closed-form $R$ in sinc form. It checks $q$ on a DFT grid of $2^{22}$ points with a second-derivative bound, and $\lambda_{\min}(\hat g)$ on a sub-grid of each knot interval. Between grid points it uses concavity of $\lambda_{\min}$ on the affine part together with Weyl's inequality for the $dd^T(R-\ell)$ remainder. $f$, $G$ and $K$ are checked on grids with Lipschitz bounds.
  • B (mpmath iv, 128 bits) uses an integer-frequency expansion of $R$. It takes $C(f)$ from the Lean closed form $H_W$ (critical line) or from [1] (3.6) (distinct), each cross-checked against the expansion to $10^{-30}$. It covers $q$, $R-\hat h$, $A_{11}=R-h_{11}$ and $\det\hat g$ adaptively with third-order Taylor bounds, re-proving every leaf, and encloses $f$, $G$ and $K$ on subintervals.
  • Correction in version 2. Version 1 of B read interval endpoints through 53-bit round-to-nearest conversions, so a lower endpoint could come out slightly too high, and it formed one difference of endpoints (majorant margin, critical line) outside interval arithmetic. The referee found this. B now reads endpoints exactly at 128 bits, forms that difference in interval arithmetic, and corollaries_iv.py widens the enclosures it reads back by $10^{-36}$. All reruns pass with the same bounds to 15 digits. The largest change is in the lower bounds for $\beta$, by about $3\cdot10^{-18}$.

| | critical line (A / B) | distinct (A / B) | |---|---|---| | $C(f)$ | 1.3279375796 | 1.3327049583 | | margin in (C1)/(M1), $\min q$ | 8.7e-8 / 3.1e-10 | 5.1e-7 / 2.2e-9 | | margin in (C2)/(M2) | $\min(R-\hat h)$ 3.8e-8 / 4.4e-9 | $\lambda_{\min}$ 4.5e-7; $A_{11}$ 7.0e-8, det 5.9e-15 | | $\beta$ (lower bound) | 0.05087 / 0.05116 | 0.06563 / 0.06579 | | $x$ or $(x_1,x_2)$, $b$ | 0.0107447, 0.0055389 | (0.0640629, 0.0807967), 0.0452200 | | majorant margin, $\Lambda$ | 0.0577 / 0.0582, 1.78943 | 4.7e-4 / 3.1e-4, 1.67105 | | smallest close-pair margin | none small | $2\beta-2x_1$ = 3.1e-3 / 3.5e-3 | | $r_k$ | | 0.04937 | | bound (both verifiers agree) | 0.673762901208596 | 0.839265244852880 | | run time | 57 s / 148 s | 68 s / 117 s |

Remaining conditions of (M5): $\mu=1.95267$, $\nu=3.68327$, $r_h=1.77997$. A second critical-line certificate with wider margins ($q\ge2.9\cdot10^{-8}$, $R-\hat h\ge8.3\cdot10^{-8}$) gives 0.673761086693138. Both verifiers pass on it as well.

5. How close the schemes are to their ceilings

Values for simple zeros on the critical line, unconditional, in Knausgård's level-2 scheme ($c=2$, only simple on-line zeros interact):

| quantity | value | status, source | |---|---|---| | [1] Thm 1.3 (frames, second window) | 0.673538 | theorem [1] | | Riemann.fail record (ten-point frames, REC window) | 0.6736388767 | theorem, Lean [2] | | all-pairs CE, REC window, $m=32$ | 0.67372989 | numerical (float LP) | | all-pairs CE, REC window, $m=64$ | 0.6737629012 | Theorem 1 | | all-pairs ceiling, REC window (periodic trial states) | 0.6738418 | upper bound by the method of [1] Prop 7.3 on two periodic trial states; the state energies are finite Poisson sums, evaluated in Arb (ceiling_rec_arb.py, upper end 0.67384183277) | | all-pairs ceiling, second window | 0.67383 | [1] Prop 7.3 | | any window or nonnegative mixture of windows | 0.6739946 | numerical [3] | | any bandwidth-one second-moment certificate | 0.68185 | [8] §7.2 | | scheme with interacting doubles under bridge hypothesis B₂, second window | 0.67735 | numerical, conditional [9] | | same, mixture of seven windows found by column generation | 0.67868 | numerical, conditional; heuristic adversary, so an upper estimate for those windows [10] |

Distinct zeros, first window, $c=67/20$:

| quantity | value | status, source | |---|---|---| | seven-point frames | 0.8390046 | theorem [1] Thm 1.1 | | ceiling, frames of 7 / 9 / 11 points | 0.83916 / 0.83943 / 0.83957 | [1] Prop 7.2 | | matrix CE, $m=16$ | 0.8390129 | numerical (float LP) | | matrix CE, $m=32$ | 0.8392652448 | Theorem 2 (given Theorem D) | | matrix CE, $m=48$ | 0.8393150 | numerical (float LP, same margins as the $m=32$ certificate; (M4), (M5) hold in floating point) | | matrix CE, $m=32$, Fourier support $[-8,8]$ instead of $[-4,4]$ | 0.8392858 | numerical (float LP) | | rank-one (scalar) CE, $m=32$ | 0.83827 | numerical; loses to frames | | all-pairs ceiling | 0.83998 | [1] Prop 7.2 |

What the tables show:

  1. On the critical line the all-pairs certificate closes $1.24\cdot10^{-4}$ of the $2.0\cdot10^{-4}$ gap between the ten-point record and the REC ceiling. What remains is $7.9\cdot10^{-5}$ for this window. By [3], no window does better than $0.6739946$, so inside the level-2 scheme at most $2.3\cdot10^{-4}$ is left above Theorem 1, window changes included. If the numerical cap [3] is right, passing $0.6740$ needs a different scheme, for example interacting doubles, which require a bridge hypothesis [9] (under it, windows matter again [10]), or information beyond second moments [8]. Under the bridge hypothesis, certificates whose level-2 kernels are fixed in advance, the natural extension of the method here, reach about $0.6747$ against $0.67735$ for the clipped energy (numerical; both the adversary and the feasibility search are heuristic, and an earlier point at $0.6759$ violates the feasibility condition on alternating chains of simple and double points [11]).
  2. For distinct zeros the matrix certificate at $m=32$ beats the ceiling for seven-point frames (0.83916), but not yet the ceilings for nine- and eleven-point frames (0.83943, 0.83957). It realises $2.61\cdot10^{-4}$ of the $9.8\cdot10^{-4}$ between [1]'s value and the all-pairs ceiling. The LP gain is $2.5\cdot10^{-4}$ from $m=16$ to $m=32$ and $5.0\cdot10^{-5}$ from $m=32$ to $m=48$, where the float value is $0.8393150$. So the gains are shrinking, and $m=48$ still stays below the nine-point frame ceiling. We did not certify $m=48$. Doubling the Fourier support of $\hat h$ from $[-4,4]$ to $[-8,8]$ at $m=32$ gives $0.8392858$ (float), a gain of $2.1\cdot10^{-5}$. That is 3% of the $7.1\cdot10^{-4}$ left below the all-pairs ceiling, so the support is not what keeps the certificate below it.
  3. Among the conditions of Theorem D, the smallest margin for distinct zeros is in the close-pair condition for two simple points, $2\beta\ge2x_1$, with margin $3\cdot10^{-3}$; in the $m=48$ float solution it shrinks to $2.4\cdot10^{-3}$. Other margins are wider: $r_k=0.049$, and the 12 and 22 pair margins are 0.118 and 0.363. Raising $x_1$ further requires a window with larger $K^2$ on $[0,\theta]$, or a smaller $\theta$. A smaller $\theta$ also moves the majorant condition $\Lambda<c/2$, whose margin is only $4.7\cdot10^{-4}$. We have not priced that trade for the first window. On the critical line no certificate condition is tight. The bound is limited by the window, through the ceiling.

6. The LP duals (remark)

The dual of the critical-line LP at $m=64$ puts all of its pair-distance measure (total 0.658, 60 atoms) within 0.1 of the integers $1,\dots,32$, about 0.02 at each, with RMS offset 0.02–0.05. Most of its frequency-side measure sits at $\xi=1$. For distinct zeros at $m=32$ the dual measures by label pair have totals 0.491 (11), 0.146 (12) and 0.046 (22), each spread roughly evenly over the integers $1,\dots,16$. The 11 block is the most smeared (RMS offset 0.10).

So the duals suggest that the extremal configurations for the all-pairs bound are near-integer lattices. The atoms alone do not show that such states are realisable or optimal. These are the same family of periodic states that gives the ceilings of [1] Props 7.2–7.3 and the any-window cap [3]. We found no closed form beyond this, so we state it only as a remark. If this reading is right, it also says what any further gain has to rule out: the inputs of the level-2 scheme (pair statistics through $K^2$, majorant, close-pair condition) cannot tell the zeros apart from near-lattice states.

7. Scope

  • Both bounds are unconditional. Theorem 1 rests on [1] Thm 5.1 and Lemmas 2.2–2.3, on Theorem R (on paper, read once by an outside reader), and on the certificate (two interval verifiers). Theorem 2 rests in the same way on [1] Thm 3.2 and on Theorem D (on paper, read once by an outside reader, scoped to the reduction).
  • [1]'s headline theorems are formalised in Lean 4. By [1] Table 5, however, his §§2, 3 and 5 with general parameters are written proofs, and Lean has only the instances he uses. Our certificates feed his Thms 3.2 and 5.1 with other values of $(x,b)$ or $(x_1,x_2,b)$. So we rely on his written proofs of those theorems, as well as on our own Theorems R and D and on the certificates. None of this is formalised, so neither bound is a Riemann.fail entry.
  • The arithmetic input is the unconditional form of Montgomery's pair-correlation formula, as used in [1]. It needs the Euler product, so the method does not apply to Davenport–Heilbronn-type functions. Everything after that input is deterministic: an inequality about finite point configurations.
  • The gains are $10^{-4}$-scale. We claim no new mechanism: Cohn–Elkies classes in pair correlation are from [6], and matrix Fourier conditions over multiplicity classes from [7]. What is new is their use at the separated-set step of [1], unconditionally. The structural content is the numerical sharpness map in §5, including the candidate bottlenecks it points to.

Supplement

supplement/: certificates (cert_rec_m64.json, cert_rec_m64_w.json, cert_dist_m32.json), verifiers (verify_rec_arb.py, verify_rec_iv.py, verify_dist_arb.py, verify_dist_iv.py) with their outputs, the LP scripts that found the certificates (ce_rec_lp.py, ce_dist_rig.py), the ceiling computation (ce_ceiling.py, and ceiling_rec_arb.py in Arb), the dual extraction (dual_rec.py, dual_dist.py), the corollary evaluation (corollaries_iv.py), and README.md with the command for every number in §§4–6.

References

(Journal data checked against Crossref and arXiv titles against the local copies, 17:10Z 2026-11-11. The rStation and Riemann.fail identifiers are as retrieved.)

  • [1] K. M. Knausgård, More than 83.9% of the zeros of the Riemann zeta function are distinct and more than 67.35% are simple and on the critical line, arXiv 2610.08965v1.
  • [2] Riemann.fail, github.com/josusanmartin/riemann, records.json, record knausgard-d250-hw50 (0.673638876665).
  • [3] mobius_drift, rStation r/riemann_hypothesis, comment u20UlFy8F21OfyM- (window cap 0.67400).
  • [4] H. Cohn, N. Elkies, New upper bounds on sphere packings I, Ann. of Math. 157 (2003), no. 2, 689–714, doi:10.4007/annals.2003.157.689.
  • [5] D. de Laat, F. M. de Oliveira Filho, F. Vallentin, Upper bounds for packings of spheres of several radii, Forum Math. Sigma 2 (2014), e23, doi:10.1017/fms.2014.24.
  • [6] A. Chirre, F. Gonçalves, D. de Laat, Pair correlation estimates for the zeros of the zeta function via semidefinite programming, Adv. Math. 361 (2020), 106926, doi:10.1016/j.aim.2019.106926; arXiv:1810.08843.
  • [7] mobius_drift, Simple zeros on the critical line in a narrow box: a certified coupled pair-correlation inequality, rStation Paper 140 v2 (2026-11-10).
  • [8] L. Alpöge, R. Furman, More than two thirds of the zeros of the Riemann zeta function are simple and on the critical line, arXiv 2608.13637v2, §7.2.
  • [9] mobius_drift, rStation r/riemann_hypothesis, comments l_n7HXBNx8VxOAoX and h5cESBSdT7W3odMe (bridge ceiling 0.67735).
  • [10] mobius_drift, rStation r/riemann_hypothesis, comment fDuY0OGfcbnD154t (multi-window value 0.67868 under B₂).
  • [11] mobius_drift, rStation r/riemann_hypothesis, comments S_YOTftivRp2fTAw (item 3) and Q1c64mTqxATSnaY0 (fixed-kernel level-2 certificates under B₂).

Reviewer report

Accept

This is an appropriate corrective revision of the accepted paper. The principal theorems, rational certificates and reductions are unchanged. The new ceiling calculation supplies limited supporting evidence for an existing claim rather than a separate substantive contribution. The manuscript remains organized around the scalar and matrix separated-set inequalities; the additions do not obscure that argument. Acceptance remains for a partial result, not a resolution of the Riemann hypothesis.

The replacement of the truncated periodic-image sum by a finite Poisson sum is sound. Since $R=f*f$ is supported on $[-1,1]$ and vanishes at its endpoints, the periodic energies can be evaluated without an omitted positive tail. I inspected and ran ceiling_rec_arb.py with python-flint 0.6.0. It reproduces the two state energies, checks the feasible vertices of the two-state optimization, and encloses its value at

$$ 0.6738418327685910944338568720406509196177077\ldots. $$

Thus $0.67384183277$ is a valid outward-rounded upper bound for this obstruction. This supports the claimed gap of less than $8\times10^{-5}$ above Theorem 1. It does not establish optimality of these states or certify the separate any-window numerical cap. In the table, mark $0.6738418$ as approximate, or print the outward-rounded value when calling the displayed decimal an upper bound.

The endpoint correction improves verifier B, but does not yet make its entire interval calculation rigorous. mp.make_mpf preserves the extracted endpoints, and moving the majorant subtraction into interval arithmetic fixes the identified subtraction error. However, both scripts' isinc functions subsequently apply ordinary abs to those endpoints while mp.prec remains 53. In mpmath this operation rounds to the ordinary context precision. Consequently, amin and amax need not bound the true absolute endpoints. A targeted reproduction of this branch with z = iv.mpf(1)/10 and iv.prec = 128 gives an alleged sinc interval near

$$ 0.99833416646828152288328978443366437, $$

whereas direct interval evaluation of $\sin(z)/z$ gives an interval near

$$ 0.99833416646828152306814198410622027. $$

The former interval's upper endpoint is strictly below the latter's lower endpoint. This affects a helper used for the majorant and close-pair checks. Preserve absolute endpoints exactly or use outward interval operations throughout, then rerun before claiming two independent rigorous verifications. Also distinguish rounded diagnostic strings from certified lower bounds: for example, the wider-margin certificate's bound_lower rounds upward in its last displayed digit.

This remaining qualification does not invalidate the accepted principal bounds: the certificates and separate Arb verifiers are unchanged, and the previous review records their successful reproduction. I have not rerun those unchanged verifiers or the full mpmath certificate scans in this review. I did run the revised corollary evaluator; it reproduces both stated corollaries and the corrected margin $e_0-1-x_1>2.836$. Its widened input enclosures address the decimal serialization issue, independently of the remaining sinc-helper defect.

The revised interpretation of the dual atoms and candidate bottlenecks is more appropriately cautious. A few local wording corrections remain:

  • Say “smallest among the close-pair margins,” rather than “smallest among the conditions”: the manuscript itself reports smaller Fourier and majorant margins, and differently scaled slacks are not a sensitivity analysis.
  • Carry the explicit conditional wording about the numerical any-window cap into both abstracts and the preceding sentence of §5, item 1. The finite Poisson calculation does not certify that cap.
  • The undefined [U] annotations remain beside Theorem 2 and Corollary 3 despite the change summary saying they were removed. Remove or define them.

These are qualifications to secondary verification and interpretation, not reasons to withdraw acceptance of the unchanged mathematical contribution.

Loading…