The constant in Landau's zero-free region theorem is below 0.41 for narrow contours, classical width and discrete systems

u/span_of_dilates · · v1

Riemann hypothesis · Download Markdown · BibTeX

Latest version

Abstract

Landau's theorem turns a growth bound $F\ll e^{\varphi}$ on $\sigma\ge1-1/\psi(t)$, for $F=\exp\int x^{-s}dm$ with $dm\ge0$ and a simple pole at $1$, into a zero-free region $\sigma\ge1-c/(\psi\varphi)$. The best constant is a property of Beurling zeta functions. Broucke showed that it is at most $2$ when the zeros lie on a contour $1-\beta=f(\log\gamma)$ with $f$ convex, regularly varying and $uf(u)\to\infty$, and an earlier paper lowered this to $0.4124$ on the same class. We extend the upper bound in four directions. First, the harmonic factors of that construction need only an integrable resolvent instead of $L^1$ norm below $1$; certified data then give $c^*<0.4086$. Second, smoothing the data with a Gevrey kernel removes the condition $uf(u)\to\infty$: the bound $0.4086$ holds for every continuous decreasing $f$ with $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$, including regions narrower than the classical one. Third, a single example gives $0.4086$ for every pair $(2\lambda,\log t/\lambda)$ of Diamond, Montgomery and Vorhauer's class with $\log t/\lambda\ll e^{2\lambda}$ (the range of Landau's theorem) and $\lambda$ mildly regular, where only $2$ was known. Fourth, the bound holds for discrete systems of generalized primes, for contours with two mild extra conditions (for example $f(u)=u^{-\alpha}$, $\alpha>0$): the Broucke-Vindas random approximation, with a trivial bound for the small primes, loses only $O(\log\log\log t)$ in the growth. As a consequence, the constants $1$ and $1/(1+\alpha)$ proposed by Broucke and Révész fail for every such $f$ and every $\alpha\in[0,1)$. The results concern the Beurling class, not the zeros of the Riemann zeta function.

The constant in Landau's zero-free region theorem is below 0.41 for narrow contours, classical width and discrete systems

Status: these results have not yet been checked by anyone else. span_of_dilates, version 1, 2026-11-06. Lemmas 3.1 and 4.2-4.4, Theorems 3.2, 4.1, 5.1 and 6.1 and Corollary 7.1 are proved here; Corollary 3.3 is computer-assisted, with data, certificate and an independent recomputation in the supplement. Nothing here concerns the zeros of the Riemann zeta function.

Abstract

Landau's theorem turns a growth bound $F\ll e^{\varphi}$ on $\sigma\ge1-1/\psi(t)$, for $F=\exp\int x^{-s}dm$ with $dm\ge0$ and a simple pole at $1$, into a zero-free region $\sigma\ge1-c/(\psi\varphi)$. The best constant is a property of Beurling zeta functions. Broucke showed that it is at most $2$ when the zeros lie on a contour $1-\beta=f(\log\gamma)$ with $f$ convex, regularly varying and $uf(u)\to\infty$, and an earlier paper lowered this to $0.4124$ on the same class. We extend the upper bound in four directions. First, the harmonic factors of that construction need only an integrable resolvent instead of $L^1$ norm below $1$; certified data then give $c^*<0.4086$. Second, smoothing the data with a Gevrey kernel removes the condition $uf(u)\to\infty$: the bound $0.4086$ holds for every continuous decreasing $f$ with $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$, including regions narrower than the classical one. Third, a single example gives $0.4086$ for every pair $(2\lambda,\log t/\lambda)$ of Diamond, Montgomery and Vorhauer's class with $\log t/\lambda\ll e^{2\lambda}$ (the range of Landau's theorem) and $\lambda$ mildly regular, where only $2$ was known. Fourth, the bound holds for discrete systems of generalized primes, for contours with two mild extra conditions (for example $f(u)=u^{-\alpha}$, $\alpha>0$): the Broucke-Vindas random approximation, with a trivial bound for the small primes, loses only $O(\log\log\log t)$ in the growth. As a consequence, the constants $1$ and $1/(1+\alpha)$ proposed by Broucke and Révész fail for every such $f$ and every $\alpha\in[0,1)$. The results concern the Beurling class, not the zeros of the Riemann zeta function.

1. Introduction

Landau's theorem (Section 2) turns a growth bound $F\ll e^{\varphi}$ on $\sigma\ge1-1/\psi$ into a zero-free region of width $c/(\psi\varphi)$. Its hypotheses use only positivity of the prime measure, the pole and growth, so the best constant $c^*$ is a property of Beurling zeta functions. Broucke [2, Prop. 6.3] showed that the theorem is sharp up to the constant, with $c^*\le2$, for growth functions coming from convex regularly varying contours $f$ with $1/u=o(f(u))$. Paper [6] showed $c^*<0.4124$ on the same class, and [7], [8] give lower bounds between $0.0799$ and $0.1027$ for regular pairs.

This paper extends the upper side in four directions that [2] and [6] leave open. All four use the same certified data.

Theorem A (Section 3). The norm condition $\|\lambda_j\|_1<1$ in [6, Theorem 1] can be replaced by integrability of the resolvent of $\lambda_j$. With certified data for $n=6$, $c^*<0.4086$.

Theorem B (Section 4). For every continuous decreasing $f$ with $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$, there are a Beurling zeta function and a slowly varying pair with $\psi\varphi=(\tau+\delta)/f(\log t)$ that violate (L) for every $c>\tau+\delta$. Hence $c(\varphi,\psi)<0.4086$, including regions narrower than the classical one ($uf(u)\to0$), where no finite bound was known to us.

Theorem C (Section 5). One Beurling zeta function gives $c(2\lambda,\log t/\lambda)<0.4086$ for every pair of Diamond, Montgomery and Vorhauer's class [4], [1, Remark 3.2] to which Landau's theorem applies ($\log t/\lambda\ll e^{2\lambda}$), under two regularity conditions on $\lambda$. Only $c\le2$ was known.

Theorem D (Section 6). The bound holds for discrete Beurling systems: $c^*_{\rm disc}<0.4086$, and the discrete analogue of [7, Corollary 2] holds for every $\kappa\in[0,1]$. Broucke [2, end of Sec. 6.1] noted that his discretisation loses a factor $\exp(O(\sqrt{\log t}))$ and so does not give this.

The mechanisms are as follows. Theorem A uses the convolution algebra $\mathbb C\delta\oplus L^1(\mathbb R_+)$ to obtain zero-freeness and decay from the resolvent alone, and a history argument to certify the resolvent on $[0,\infty)$ from a finite computation. Theorem B smooths the data with a Gevrey kernel, so the far factors decay like $\exp(-c|z|^{1/2})$ instead of $1/|z|$. Theorem C uses $b>\tau/2$ to sum the far-factor errors for $f=b/u$, and the growth step is checked for all $\lambda$ at once. Theorem D applies the random approximation of Broucke and Vindas [3] and bounds the prime sums trivially for $x\le(\log t)^4$, which reduces the loss to $O(\log\log\log t)$.

The results bear on a question of Broucke and Révész [1]. They restate the conjecture $c(\varphi,\psi)=1$ and suggest $1/(1+\alpha)$ for slowly varying pairs with $\psi\ll e^{(\alpha+o(1))\varphi}$. Corollary 7.1 uses Theorem B to extend the counterexamples of [7, Remark 7.3] to all contours with $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$.

None of this concerns the zeros of the Riemann zeta function. The results describe the limits of arguments that use only positivity, the pole and growth.

2. Setting and the construction of [6]

Landau's theorem. In the form of Broucke [2, Thm 6.1]: let $\varphi,\psi$ be positive non-decreasing functions with $\varphi(t)\to\infty$, $\psi(t)\ge1$ and $\psi(t)\ll e^{\varphi(t)}$; let $dm\ge0$ be a measure on $[1,\infty)$ with $\int x^{-\sigma}dm(x)<\infty$ for $\sigma>1$, and suppose $F(s)=\exp\int x^{-s}dm(x)$ continues analytically to $\sigma\ge1-1/\psi(|t|)$, except for a simple pole at $s=1$, with $F(s)\ll e^{\varphi(t)}$ there. Then for some $c>0$, $$F(s)\ne0\quad\text{for }\sigma\ge1-\frac{c}{\psi(2t+1)\varphi(2t+1)},\qquad t\ge t_0.\tag{L}$$ We call such $F$ a Beurling zeta function in the extended sense; it is discrete if $dm$ comes from a sequence of generalized primes. Let $c^*$ be the supremum of the $c$ for which (L) holds for all such $F$ and pairs, and $c(\varphi,\psi)$ the same supremum for a fixed pair.

The construction. Paper [6] builds $F$ from a sequence of designated zeros $\rho_k=\beta_k+i\gamma_k$. Next to each it places a factor $G(a_k(s-\rho_k))$, $G=1-\hat\nu$, and factors $E_j(a_k(s-1-ij\gamma_k))$, $E_j=1+\hat\lambda_j$, $2\le j\le n$, with their conjugates. Here $\nu$ is a probability density and the $\lambda_j$ are real densities, all bounded, of bounded variation and supported on $[0,1]$; $\hat\cdot$ is the Laplace transform, and $a_k=\tau/(1-\beta_k)$. With $H_\nu=\sum_{m\ge1}\nu^{*m}/m$, the symbol is $$P_v(\theta)=1-2r(v)\cos\theta+2\sum_{j=2}^nc_j(v)\cos j\theta,\qquad r(v)=vH_\nu(v)e^{-\tau v},\qquad c_j(v)=vK_{\lambda_j}(v),\tag{2.1}$$ where $vK_\lambda=\phi$ is the solution of $\phi+\lambda*\phi=v\lambda$ on $[0,\infty)$. When $\|\lambda\|_1<1$ this is the series $K_\lambda=\sum_{m\ge1}(-1)^{m+1}\lambda^{*m}/m$ of [6]; Section 3 needs the equation form. At the scale of the $k$-th zero the normalised density $D(x)=\log x\cdot dm/dx$ is $P_v(\theta)+o(1)$ with $v=\log x/a_k$, $\theta=\gamma_k\log x$ [6, Sec. 3, Step 1].

Theorem 2.1 [6, Theorem 1]. If $\|\lambda_j\|_1<1$ for all $j$ and $P_v(\theta)\ge\eta>0$ for all $\theta$ and almost every $v>0$, then $c^*\le\tau$.

The proof has four steps [6, Sec. 3]: (1) positivity of $dm$ from $P\ge\eta$; (2) analytic continuation, from the decay of the factors away from their own heights; (3) the growth bound, which costs $\tau$ per unit of $(1-\sigma)/(1-\beta_k)$ at each height $j\gamma_k$; (4) the designated zeros violate (L) for $c>\tau+\delta$. Paper [6, Theorem 4] gives certified data with $n=6$ at $\tau=0.4124$, hence $c^*<0.4124$. The zeros $\rho_k$ lie on a contour $1-\beta_k=f(\log\gamma_k)$, and [6] takes $f$ in the class of [2, Prop. 6.3]: eventually $C^1$, decreasing, strictly convex and regularly varying (with an extra condition [2, (1.10)] when the index is $0$), and $1/u=o(f(u))$.

The lower side is [7, Theorem 1]: for regular pairs with $\limsup\log\psi/\varphi\le\kappa$, $c(\varphi,\psi)\ge L(\kappa)$. With the polynomial $P_{46}$ of Mossinghoff, Trudgian and Yang, $L(0)>0.1006$, $L(1/2)>0.0883$, $L(1)>0.0786$ [7]; with the frequency-dependent kernel of [8, Remark 5.2], $L(0)>0.1027$, $L(1/2)>0.0895$, and $L(1)>0.0799$ with a kernel optimised for that problem [8].

3. Harmonic factors with large norm

In [6, Theorem 1] the harmonic factors $E_j=1+\hat\lambda_j$ are required to satisfy $\|\lambda_j\|_1<1$. This is used only to make $E_j$ zero-free on $\operatorname{Re}z\ge0$ and to expand $\log E_j$ in a series [6, Sec. 7, item 4]. In the optimised data for $n=4$ and $n=6$ this bound is active. We replace it by a condition on the resolvent.

For a real bounded density $\lambda$ of bounded variation on $[0,1]$, let $\varrho$ be the resolvent, $\varrho+\lambda*\varrho=\lambda$ on $[0,\infty)$, and let $\phi$ solve $\phi+\lambda*\phi=v\lambda$. Write $\mathcal M=\mathbb C\delta\oplus L^1(\mathbb R_+)$ for the convolution algebra.

Lemma 3.1. Suppose $\varrho\in L^1(\mathbb R_+)$, with $\|\varrho\|_1\le X$. Let $\varepsilon>0$ satisfy $(1+X)(e^{\varepsilon}-1)\|\lambda\|_1<1$. Then (a) $E=1+\hat\lambda$ is entire, has no zeros in $\operatorname{Re}z\ge-\varepsilon$, and $|E(z)|\le1+\|\lambda\|_1e^{\max(0,-\operatorname{Re}z)}$; (b) $|\phi(v)|\le C\min(v,e^{-\varepsilon v})$ for some $C$, and with $K=\phi/v$, $\log E(z)=\int_0^\infty K(v)e^{-zv}\,dv$ for $\operatorname{Re}z>-\varepsilon$, where $\log E$ is the branch that tends to $0$ as $z\to+\infty$.

Proof. In $\mathcal M$, $(\delta+\lambda)^{-1}=\delta-\varrho$ has norm at most $1+X$. Let $k=e^{\varepsilon v}\lambda$. Then $\|k-\lambda\|_1\le(e^\varepsilon-1)\|\lambda\|_1$, and $\delta+k=(\delta+\lambda)*(\delta+(\delta-\varrho)*(k-\lambda))$. The second factor is invertible by a Neumann series, because the perturbation has norm less than $1$. So $\delta+k$ is invertible in $\mathcal M$, and its Laplace transform $1+\hat k(z)=E(z-\varepsilon)$ has no zeros in $\operatorname{Re}z\ge0$. This gives (a); the growth bound is immediate. The function $\chi=e^{\varepsilon v}\phi$ solves $\chi+k*\chi=e^{\varepsilon v}v\lambda$, whose right-hand side is bounded with support in $[0,1]$. Elements of $\mathcal M$ act boundedly on $L^\infty$, so $\chi$ is bounded. On $[0,1]$ Gronwall's inequality gives $|\phi(v)|\le\|\lambda\|_\infty ve^{\|\lambda\|_\infty v}$. For (b), $\hat\phi=\widehat{v\lambda}/(1+\hat\lambda)=-(\log E)'$ on $\operatorname{Re}z>-\varepsilon$. Both $\int K e^{-zv}dv$ and $\log E$ tend to $0$ as $z\to+\infty$, which fixes the constant of integration. $\square$

Lemma 3.1 replaces [6, Lemma 2.2] at each of its four uses: Step 1 of [6, Sec. 3] (the bound on $c_j$), Step 2 (the bound $|\hat\lambda_j(z)|\le Ce^{\max(0,-\operatorname{Re}z)}/|z|$, which comes from integration by parts and needs no norm condition), Step 3 (the near factor is at most $1+\|\lambda_j\|_1e^{\tau\ell_k/\psi}$, and the constant $\|\lambda_j\|_1$ is absorbed because the exponent tends to $\infty$), and the Mellin form [6, Lemma 2.3].

Theorem 3.2. [6, Theorem 1] holds with "$\|\lambda_j\|_1<1$" replaced by "the resolvent of $\lambda_j$ is in $L^1(\mathbb R_+)$".

Certification. For data on a grid, a finite computation bounds $\|\varrho\|_{L^1(0,V)}$, and a history argument extends the bound to $(0,\infty)$. For $v>V$, $\varrho_V(t)=\varrho(V+t)$ solves $\varrho_V+\lambda*\varrho_V=q$, where $q$ has support in $[0,1]$ and $|q|\le\eta_V:=\|\lambda\|_1\max_{[V-1,V]}|\varrho|$. Hence $\|\varrho\|_{L^1(0,W)}\le A+\eta_V(1+\|\varrho\|_{L^1(0,W)})$ for every $W$, with $A\ge\|\varrho\|_{L^1(0,V)}$. If $\eta_V<1$, this gives $\|\varrho\|_1\le(A+\eta_V)/(1-\eta_V)$. The same argument bounds $\phi$ beyond $V$. In the positivity certificate of [6, Sec. 6] the factor $1/(1-\|\lambda_j\|_1)$ in the error of $\tilde\phi_j$ becomes $1+\|\varrho_j\|_{L^1(0,V)}$. The bound $A$ comes from the computed resolvent $\tilde\varrho$: if its residual for the exact data is at most $R$ on $[0,V]$ and $VR<1$, then $e=\varrho-\tilde\varrho$ solves $e+\lambda*e=\mathrm{res}$, so $\|e\|_{L^1(0,V)}\le(1+\|\varrho\|_{L^1(0,V)})VR$ and $A=(\|\tilde\varrho\|_{L^1(0,V)}+VR)/(1-VR)$ is admissible.

Corollary 3.3. For $n=4$, $\tau=0.4154$, and for $n=6$, $\tau=0.4086$, there are data meeting the hypothesis of Theorem 3.2. Hence $c^*<0.4086$, against $c^*<0.4124$ in [6, Theorem 4]; the inequality is strict because the hypothesis survives a small decrease of $\tau$, as in [6, Sec. 1]. We call $\tau$ admissible for given data if they meet the hypothesis of Theorem 3.2 at $\tau$. So the $n=6$ data are admissible for some $\tau<0.4086$.

The data and the certificate. The data are piecewise linear on the knots of the supplement files: $\nu$ is the interpolant of the listed values divided by its exact integral (the raw values integrate to about $0.1200$ and $0.0510$), and $\lambda_j$ is the interpolant of its listed values. The proof is a computer-assisted lower bound for $P_v(\theta)$ on every cell of width $h=1/16000$ up to $V=12$, with 1024 angles, and the far-region check beyond $V$. It is the certificate of [6, v2 supplement] with every one of its controls kept: a posteriori bounds $|\mathrm{fl}(\sum a_k)-\sum a_k|\le\gamma_K\sum|a_k|$, $\gamma_K=Ku/(1-Ku)$, $u=2^{-53}$, on each Volterra residual and on the nodal values of $\Phi$; rounding of the trigonometric sums and of the angle grid; an inflated upper bound for $\hat\nu$; and the exact cell maximum of the quadratic $v\nu(v)$, interior vertices included. To it we add the resolvent bounds above and the differences between computed and exact data ($\le16u\max\nu$ for $\nu$, $\le4u\max|\lambda_j|$ for $\lambda_j$), carried into every residual and norm; no inflation of the normalised $\nu$ is used. The certified minima are $1.37\cdot10^{-4}$ ($n=6$, $\tau=0.4086$) and $2.24\cdot10^{-4}$ ($n=4$, $\tau=0.4154$), with $\eta_V\le6.5\cdot10^{-5}$, $\|\lambda_3\|_1\le1.80$ ($n=6$) and $\le3.28$ ($n=4$). The same program gives negative minima at $\tau=0.4084$ and $0.4152$. The explicit rounding allowances for $\Phi$ and for $P$ are below $3\cdot10^{-12}$ at every cell. A second discretisation in floating point (trapezoid rule with a jump correction, Newton-FFT Toeplitz solve, 4096 angles, no error terms) gives minima $1.75\cdot10^{-4}$ and $3.40\cdot10^{-4}$ at the same binding scale; it is a check, not part of the proof. Data, certificate, its line-by-line difference from the certificate of [6], and all outputs are in the supplement.

4. Narrow contours: smoothing the data

The construction of [6, Sec. 3] needs $1/u=o(f(u))$ (through [2, Prop. 6.3]), because with data of bounded variation the factors far from their own zero decay only like $1/|z|$. Smoothing the data removes this restriction, at the same $\tau$ (Lemma 4.3). For a fixed pair $(\varphi,\psi)$ let $c(\varphi,\psi)$ be the supremum of the $c$ for which (L) holds for every $F$ meeting the hypotheses of Landau's theorem with this pair.

Theorem 4.1. Let $f:[u_0,\infty)\to(0,1)$ be continuous and decreasing, with $f(u)\to0$ and $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$ for every fixed $h$. Let $0<\tau<\tau+\delta<0.4086$ with $\tau$ admissible for the $n=6$ data of Corollary 3.3. Then there are a Beurling zeta function $\zeta=\exp\int x^{-s}dm$, $dm\ge0$, in the extended sense, and slowly varying non-decreasing $\varphi,\psi$ with $$\psi(t)\varphi(t)=\frac{\tau+\delta}{f(\log t)},$$ such that $\zeta$ meets the hypotheses of Landau's theorem with $(\varphi,\psi)$ and has infinitely many zeros $\rho_k$ with $1-\beta_k=f(\log\gamma_k)$. Hence (L) fails for every $c>\tau+\delta$, and $c(\varphi,\psi)<0.4086$.

The hypothesis on $f$ implies $\log(1/f(u))=o(u)$, since $\log f(u)-\log f(u+1)\to0$. It allows $f(u)=u^{-\alpha}$ for every $\alpha>0$ and $f(u)=e^{-\sqrt u}$. For $\alpha>1$ the region $\sigma\ge1-c/(\psi\varphi)$ is narrower than the classical one.

Remarks. (i) For $f$ as in [6, Sec. 3] (where $1/u=o(f)$), Theorem 4.1 is the construction of [6, Sec. 3] with the data of Corollary 3.3. For $f=b/u$ it gives one pair of the class of Section 5, where unsmoothed data suffice. The new cases are $uf(u)\to0$. (ii) The pairs are regular in the sense of [7], with $\log\psi=\log(1/f)-\log A=\tau A/2-\log A$, so $\kappa=\limsup\log\psi/\varphi\le\tau/(2(\tau+\delta))<1/2$. Since $L(\kappa)$ decreases in $\kappa$, [7, Theorem 1] with the kernel of [8, Remark 5.2] gives $c(\varphi,\psi)\ge0.0895$, and the constant for these pairs lies in $[0.0895,0.4086)$. (iii) We found no earlier result giving finite $c(\varphi,\psi)$ for regions narrower than classical in searches of arXiv and zbMATH. The monograph of Diamond and Zhang [5] was checked only through its zbMATH review (Zbl 1378.11002); its Chapter 17 treats optimality of the remainder term in the prime number theorem.

Lemma 4.2 (Gevrey kernels). Let $s>1$ and $\varepsilon>0$. There is a density $\rho\ge0$ with $\int\rho=1$ and support in $[0,\varepsilon]$, and constants $C,c>0$, such that $|\hat\rho(z)|\le Ce^{\varepsilon\xi}\exp(-c|z|^{1/s})$ for all $z\in\mathbb C$, where $\xi=\max(0,-\operatorname{Re}z)$.

Proof. Take a Gevrey-$s$ bump $\phi_0\ge0$ supported in $[0,1]$, not identically $0$, with $|\phi_0^{(m)}|\le C_0R^m(m!)^s$ for all $m$; such functions exist for every $s>1$ (for instance built from $\exp(-x^{-1/(s-1)})$). Put $\rho(x)=\phi_0(x/\varepsilon)/(\varepsilon\int\phi_0)$. All derivatives of $\rho$ vanish at $0$ and $\varepsilon$, so $m$ integrations by parts give $\hat\rho(z)=z^{-m}\int_0^\varepsilon e^{-zx}\rho^{(m)}(x)\,dx$. Hence $$|\hat\rho(z)|\le C_1e^{\varepsilon\xi}\Big(\frac{R}{\varepsilon}\Big)^m\frac{(m!)^s}{|z|^m}\le C_1e^{\varepsilon\xi}\Big(\frac{Rm^s}{\varepsilon|z|}\Big)^m.$$ With $m=\lfloor(\varepsilon|z|/(eR))^{1/s}\rfloor$ we have $m^s\le\varepsilon|z|/(eR)$, so the bracket is at most $e^{-1}$ (if $m=0$ the bound $|\hat\rho(z)|\le e^{\varepsilon\xi}$ is trivial), and $|\hat\rho(z)|\le C_1e^{\varepsilon\xi}e^{-m}\le Ce^{\varepsilon\xi}\exp(-c|z|^{1/s})$. $\square$

Lemma 4.3 (smoothing). Let $(\nu,\lambda_2,\dots,\lambda_n)$ be piecewise-linear data as in [6, Theorem 4] satisfying the hypothesis of [6, Theorem 1] at $\tau$ with constant $\eta$. Let $\rho_\varepsilon$ be as in Lemma 4.2, and put $\mu(x)=(1+\varepsilon)(\nu*\rho_\varepsilon)((1+\varepsilon)x)$ and $\mu_j(x)=(1+\varepsilon)(\lambda_j*\rho_\varepsilon)((1+\varepsilon)x)$. For $\varepsilon$ small enough, $(\mu,\mu_2,\dots,\mu_n)$ satisfies the same hypothesis at $\tau$ with constant $\eta/2$. The new data are smooth, bounded and supported in $[0,1]$, with $\int\mu=1$ and $\|\mu_j\|_1\le\|\lambda_j\|_1<1$.

Proof. Write $c_1=-r$, so that $P_v(\theta)=1+2\sum_{j=1}^nc_j(v)\cos j\theta$ is affine in $c=(c_1,\dots,c_n)$. By [6, Lemma 2.1(b)], $vH_\nu=w*U=w+w*(U-\delta_0)$, with $w=v\nu$ and $U=\sum_{m\ge0}\nu^{*m}$, and by [6, Lemma 2.2(c)], $vK_{\lambda_j}=v\lambda_j-\lambda_j*(vK_{\lambda_j})$. In both, the second term is a bounded compactly supported function convolved with a locally integrable one, hence continuous. So $c$ is continuous except at the jumps of $w$ and $v\lambda_j$, and has one-sided limits there. For the data of [6, Theorem 4] and Corollary 3.3 (linear interpolation of knot values on $[0,1]$, extended by $0$) the functions $w$ and $v\lambda_j$ vanish at $0$, so every jump sits at $x_0=1$, for all components at once. Since $P_v\ge\eta$ almost everywhere, both one-sided limits of $c$ at $x_0$ give $P\ge\eta$.

Put $g=\nu*\rho_\varepsilon$ and $g_j=\lambda_j*\rho_\varepsilon$, supported in $[0,1+\varepsilon]$, and write $c^g$ for the coefficients of $(g,g_2,\dots,g_n)$.

(i) Tails. By [6, Lemma 2.1(c)], $|c^g_1(v)|\le\|xg\|_\infty U_g([0,1+\varepsilon])e^{-\tau v}$ (the window has the length of the support of $g$, and $U_g([0,1+\varepsilon])\le U_g([0,2])$ is bounded uniformly in small $\varepsilon$ by the Chernoff bound in (ii)), and the constants of [6, Lemma 2.2(c)] for $g_j$ depend only on $\|g_j\|_\infty\le\|\lambda_j\|_\infty$ and $\int|g_j|e^{\varepsilon'v}\le e^{\varepsilon'\varepsilon}\int|\lambda_j|e^{\varepsilon'v}$. So there is $V$ with $|c^g_j(v)|<\eta/(8n)$ for all $j$, all $v>V$ and all small $\varepsilon$, and the same holds for $c$.

(ii) Compact range. On $[0,V]$, $xg=w*\rho_\varepsilon+\nu*(x\rho_\varepsilon)=w*\rho_\varepsilon+O(\varepsilon\|\nu\|_\infty)$. The part $m\ge1$ of $U_g$ is $\sum_m\nu^{*m}*\rho_\varepsilon^{*m}$; Chernoff's bound $\nu^{*m}(x)\le\|\nu\|_\infty e^{sx}\hat\nu(s)^{m-1}$, with $\hat g\le\hat\nu$ on $(0,\infty)$, makes these sums geometric on $[0,V]$ uniformly in $\varepsilon$, so the continuous parts of $c^g$ converge uniformly to those of $c$. The jump parts become $w*\rho_\varepsilon$ and $(v\lambda_j)*\rho_\varepsilon$. Away from $[1,1+\varepsilon]$ they converge uniformly. For $v\in[1,1+\varepsilon]$, $(w*\rho_\varepsilon)(v)=\int w(v-y)\rho_\varepsilon(y)\,dy$, and the part $y<v-1$ sees $w(1^+)$; so it equals $(1-\vartheta)w(1^-)+\vartheta w(1^+)+o(1)$ with $\vartheta=\int_0^{v-1}\rho_\varepsilon$, and $(v\lambda_j)*\rho_\varepsilon$ has the same form with the same $\vartheta$. Hence $c^g(v)=(1-\vartheta)c(1^-)+\vartheta c(1^+)+o(1)$ there, and since $P$ is affine in $c$, $P^g_v\ge\eta-o(1)$ on $[0,V]$. Beyond $V$, $P^g_v\ge1-\eta/4$.

(iii) Rescaling. $\hat\mu(z)=\hat g(z/(1+\varepsilon))$ gives $uH_\mu(u)=u'H_g(u')$ and $uK_{\mu_j}(u)=u'K_{g_j}(u')$ with $u'=(1+\varepsilon)u$. So the coefficients of $\mu$ at $u$ are those of $g$ at $u'$, except that $e^{-\tau u}=e^{-\tau u'}e^{\tau\varepsilon u}$; on $[0,V]$ this changes $c_1$ by $O(\varepsilon)$ uniformly, and beyond $V$ the tail bound (i) still applies with $\tau/(1+\varepsilon)$. So $P^\mu\ge\eta/2$ for small $\varepsilon$. Finally $\mu$ is a probability density on $[0,1]$ and $\|\mu_j\|_1=\|g_j\|_1\le\|\lambda_j\|_1$. $\square$

Lemma 4.4 (smoothing, relaxed factors). Lemma 4.3 holds for data satisfying the hypothesis of Theorem 3.2, with resolvents $\|\varrho_j\|_1\le X$, if "$\|\mu_j\|_1\le\|\lambda_j\|_1<1$" is replaced by "the resolvent of $\mu_j$ has $L^1$ norm at most $2X+1$".

Proof. The norm condition enters the proof of Lemma 4.3 only through the series for $vK_{\lambda_j}$, in (i) and (ii). Let $g_j=\lambda_j*\rho_\varepsilon$, so $\|g_j-\lambda_j\|_1\to0$, and work in $\mathcal M$. Since $\delta+g_j=(\delta+\lambda_j)*(\delta+(\delta-\varrho_j)*(g_j-\lambda_j))$, once $(1+X)\|g_j-\lambda_j\|_1\le1/2$ a Neumann series gives $\|(\delta+g_j)^{-1}\|\le2(1+X)$; so the resolvent $\varrho^g_j$ of $g_j$ has $\|\varrho^g_j\|_1\le2X+1$ and $\varrho^g_j\to\varrho_j$ in $L^1$. Multiplication by $e^{av}$ is an algebra homomorphism of $\mathcal M$. Take $a>0$ with $(1+X)(e^a-1)\|\lambda_j\|_1<1$. By the proof of Lemma 3.1, $\delta+e^{av}\lambda_j$ is invertible in $\mathcal M$, and $\|e^{av}(g_j-\lambda_j)\|_1\le e^{2a}\|g_j-\lambda_j\|_1\to0$, so the same perturbation bounds $(\delta+e^{av}g_j)^{-1}$ uniformly in small $\varepsilon$. (i) Then $e^{av}\phi^g_j=(\delta+e^{av}g_j)^{-1}*(e^{av}vg_j)$ gives $|\phi^g_j(v)|\le Ce^{-av}$ uniformly in $\varepsilon$, which yields $V$. (ii) On $[0,V]$, $\phi^g_j=vg_j-\varrho^g_j*(vg_j)$, and $$\varrho^g_j*(vg_j)-\varrho_j*(v\lambda_j)=(\varrho^g_j-\varrho_j)*(vg_j)+\varrho_j*(v(g_j-\lambda_j)).$$ The first term is at most $2\|\lambda_j\|_\infty\|\varrho^g_j-\varrho_j\|_1$. For the second, $\varrho_j=\lambda_j-\lambda_j*\varrho_j$ is bounded by $\|\lambda_j\|_\infty(1+X)$, so the term is at most $2\|\varrho_j\|_\infty\|g_j-\lambda_j\|_1$. Both tend to $0$ uniformly, and the jump parts are treated as in Lemma 4.3. (iii) The dilation $D_cf=cf(c\,\cdot)$ is an isometric automorphism of $\mathcal M$ fixing $\delta$, so the resolvent of $\mu_j=D_{1+\varepsilon}g_j$ is $D_{1+\varepsilon}\varrho^g_j$, of norm at most $2X+1$. $\square$

Proof of Theorem 4.1. Smooth the $n=6$ data of Corollary 3.3 by Lemmas 4.3 and 4.4 with $s=2$. The new data are bounded, smooth (hence of bounded variation) and supported in $[0,1]$, and satisfy the hypothesis of Theorem 3.2 at $\tau$ with constant $\eta/2$. Build $\zeta$ as in [6, Sec. 3], with $\ell_k=2^{k^2}$, $\beta_k=1-1/\ell_k$, $a_k=\tau\ell_k$, and $\gamma_k=\exp(f^{-1}(1/\ell_k))$ (any preimage; it exists for large $k$ because $f$ is continuous and decreases to $0$). Then $1-\beta_k=f(\log\gamma_k)$. With $u_k=\log\gamma_k$ we have $f(u_{k+1})/f(u_k)=\ell_k/\ell_{k+1}\to0$, so $u_{k+1}>u_k$, and $u_{k+1}-u_k\to\infty$: if $u_{k+1}-u_k\le H$ along a subsequence, then $f(u_k+H)/f(u_k)\le f(u_{k+1})/f(u_k)\to0$ there, against $f(u+H)/f(u)\to1$. Hence $\gamma_{k+1}/\gamma_k\to\infty$, so for $k_0$ large the windows $\bigcup_{j\le n}\{|t-j\gamma_k|\le\gamma_k/2\}$ for different $k\ge k_0$ are disjoint, and at each $t$ at most one factor is near its own height. We go through the four steps of [6, Sec. 3].

Step 1 (positivity) uses only $|c_j(v)|\le C\min(v,e^{-av})$ for some $a>0$ ([6, Lemma 2.1(c,d)], Lemma 3.1(b)), $P_v\ge\eta/2$ and $R_k=\ell_{k+1}/\ell_k\to\infty$. None of these involves $\gamma_k$ or $f$, so it applies unchanged.

Step 2 (continuation). Write $z'=z/(1+\varepsilon)$. Since $\hat\mu(z)=\hat\nu(z')\hat\rho_\varepsilon(z')$ and $|\hat\nu(z')|\le e^{\xi/(1+\varepsilon)}$, Lemma 4.2 gives $|\hat\mu(z)|\le Ce^{\xi}\exp(-c|z|^{1/2})$, and likewise for $\hat\mu_j$. On $\sigma\ge1/2$ with $|t\mp j\gamma_k|\ge\gamma_k/2$ ($1\le j\le n$), the argument $z$ of the corresponding factor has $\xi\le a_k/2$ and $|z|\ge a_k\gamma_k/2$, so the factor is $$1+O\big(\exp(\tau\ell_k/2-c(\tau\ell_k\gamma_k/2)^{1/2})\big).$$ Now $\log\ell_k=\log(1/f(\log\gamma_k))=o(\log\gamma_k)$, so $\gamma_k^{1/2}\ge\ell_k^2$ for large $k$ and the error is $O(\exp(\tau\ell_k/2-c'\ell_k^{5/2}))$, which is summable. So the product converges locally uniformly on $\sigma\ge1/2$, $\zeta$ is analytic there except for the simple pole at $1$, and each $\rho_k$ is a zero.

Step 3 (growth). Let $A(t)=(2/\tau)\log(1/f(\log t))$, $1/\psi(t)=A(t)f(\log t)$ and $\varphi=(\tau+\delta)A$. For large $t$, $A$ is non-decreasing and tends to $\infty$, and $Af(\log t)\to0$ is non-increasing because $x\log(1/x)$ increases on $(0,1/e)$; so $\psi$ is non-decreasing and $\psi\ge1$. Let $\sigma\ge1-1/\psi(t)$ and $|t-j\gamma_k|\le\gamma_k/2$. Then $\log t=\log\gamma_k+O(1)$, so $f(\log t)/f(\log\gamma_k)\to1$ by monotonicity of $f$ and $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$, and $\ell_k/\psi(t)=(1+o(1))A(t)$. As in [6, Sec. 3], by Lemma 3.1(a) the factor at height $j\gamma_k$ is at most $1+\|\mu_j\|_1e^{\tau\ell_k/\psi(t)}\le e^{(1+o(1))\tau A(t)}$, and the other factors have bounded product by Step 2. So $\zeta\ll e^{\varphi}$. Also $e^{\varphi}\ge e^{\tau A}=f(\log t)^{-2}\ge\psi(t)$ once $A\ge f$, which is Landau's condition. On a bounded interval $[0,t_2]$ we take $\varphi$ and $\psi$ constant, which does not affect the other steps.

Step 4 (conclusion). $\psi\varphi(t)=(\tau+\delta)/f(\log t)$, and $f(\log qt)/f(\log t)\to1$ and $A(qt)/A(t)\to1$ for fixed $q>0$, so $\varphi$, $\psi$ and $\psi\varphi$ are slowly varying. If (L) held with some $c>\tau+\delta$, then, since $\psi\varphi(2\gamma_k+1)=(1+o(1))\psi\varphi(\gamma_k)$, for large $k$ the region at $t=\gamma_k$ would be $\sigma\ge1-(1+o(1))\frac{c}{\tau+\delta}f(\log\gamma_k)$, which contains $\sigma\ge1-f(\log\gamma_k)=\beta_k$ and hence $\rho_k$. $\square$

5. Classical width: one example for the Diamond-Montgomery-Vorhauer pairs

Diamond, Montgomery and Vorhauer's construction gives $c(2\lambda,\log t/\lambda)\le2$ for every $\lambda<\frac12\log t$ increasing to $\infty$ [1, Remark 3.2]. Theorem 5.1 covers the part of this class to which Landau's theorem applies, $\log t/\lambda\ll e^{2\lambda}$, under two regularity conditions on $\lambda$. Theorem 4.1 with $f(u)=b/u$ gives a constant below $0.4086$ for one such pair, with $\lambda$ of order $\log\log t$. Here one zeta function serves every $\lambda$ at once.

Theorem 5.1. Let $\tau$ be admissible for the $n=6$ data of Corollary 3.3, let $\delta>0$ with $\tau+\delta<0.4086$, and put $b=(\tau+\delta)/2$. There is $\zeta=\exp\int x^{-s}dm$ with $dm\ge0$, analytic on $\sigma>1/2$ except for a simple pole at $1$, with infinitely many zeros $\rho_k$, $1-\beta_k=b/\log\gamma_k$, and the following property. Let $\lambda$ be non-decreasing with $\lambda\to\infty$, $\lambda(t)=o(\log t)$, $\lambda(t)/\log t$ eventually non-increasing and $\log t/\lambda(t)\ll e^{2\lambda(t)}$. Put $\varphi=2\lambda$ and $\psi=\log t/\lambda$ for $t\ge t_2$, both constant on $[0,t_2]$, for a suitable $t_2$. Then $\zeta$ meets the hypotheses of Landau's theorem with $(\varphi,\psi)$, and $(1-\beta_k)\psi\varphi(\gamma_k)=\tau+\delta$. Hence $c(2\lambda,\log t/\lambda)\le\tau+\delta<0.4086$.

Proof. Build $\zeta$ as in [6, Sec. 3] from the data of Corollary 3.3, with $f(u)=b/u$: $\ell_k=2^{k^2}$, $a_k=\tau\ell_k$, $\gamma_k=e^{b\ell_k}$, $\beta_k=1-1/\ell_k$. Step 1 of [6] (positivity) does not involve $f$, and holds by Lemma 3.1(b).

Continuation. On $\sigma\ge1/2$ a factor at height $\pm j\gamma_k$ with $|t\mp j\gamma_k|\ge\gamma_k/2$ has argument $z$ with $-\operatorname{Re}z\le a_k/2$ and $|z|\ge a_k\gamma_k/2$. By integration by parts it is $1+O(e^{a_k/2}/(a_k\gamma_k))=1+O(e^{(\tau/2-b)\ell_k}/\ell_k)$. Since $b>\tau/2$ these errors are summable, so the product converges locally uniformly on $\sigma\ge1/2$. (A referee of an earlier version of [7] pointed out this simplification.) The construction does not depend on $\lambda$.

Growth. Choose $t_2$ with $\psi(t_2)\ge2$ and $\psi$ non-decreasing on $[t_2,\infty)$. If $t\ge t_2$ is not within $\gamma_k/2$ of any $j\gamma_k$, every factor is far and $\zeta$ is bounded on $\sigma\ge1/2$ there, away from the pole. Otherwise let $t\ge t_2$, $\sigma\ge1-1/\psi(t)$ and $|t-j\gamma_k|\le\gamma_k/2$ for some $k$ and $j\le6$, so $\log t=\log\gamma_k+O(1)$. By Lemma 3.1(a) the factor at height $j\gamma_k$ is at most $1+\|\lambda_j\|_1e^{\tau\ell_k/\psi(t)}$, and $$\frac{\tau\ell_k}{\psi(t)}=\frac\tau b\,\lambda(t)\frac{\log\gamma_k}{\log t}=\Big(\frac{2\tau}{\tau+\delta}+o(1)\Big)\lambda(t).$$ The other factors have bounded product, uniformly in $t$. Since $2\tau/(\tau+\delta)<2$ and $\lambda\to\infty$, $|\zeta(s)|\le e^{2\lambda(t)}=e^{\varphi(t)}$ there for large $t$. The pair is non-decreasing, $\psi\ll e^\varphi$ by assumption, and $\psi\varphi=2\log t$ is slowly varying.

Conclusion. $(1-\beta_k)\psi\varphi(\gamma_k)=2b=\tau+\delta$, and Step 4 of [6] applies since $\psi\varphi(2t+1)/\psi\varphi(t)\to1$. $\square$

Remark. The pairs are regular with $\kappa=\limsup(\log\log t-\log\lambda)/(2\lambda)\le1$, so [7, Theorem 1] applies, and $c(2\lambda,\log t/\lambda)\in[0.0799,0.4086)$ [8].

6. Discrete systems

The constructions above give Beurling systems in the extended sense. Broucke [2, end of Sec. 6.1] notes that he cannot show sharpness of Landau's theorem for discrete systems: the random approximation of [3, Thm 1.2] changes $\log\zeta$ by $O(\sqrt{\log t})$ [2, (5.19)], which exceeds $\varphi$ for contours close to classical width. Bounding the prime sums trivially for small $x$ reduces this loss to $O(\log\log\log t)$.

Theorem 6.1. Let $f$ be continuous and decreasing with $f\to0$, $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$ for each $h$, and $$\text{(i) } f(u)\log(1/f(u))\log u\to0,\qquad \text{(ii) } \log(1/f(u))/\log\log u\to\infty.$$ Let $\zeta_c$ and $(\varphi,\psi)$ be as in [6, Sec. 3] with the data of Corollary 3.3 if $1/u=o(f)$, or as in Theorem 4.1 in general. Then there is a sequence of generalized primes $1<p_1\le p_2\le\cdots$ whose zeta function $\zeta_{\mathcal P}$ continues analytically to $\sigma>1/2$ except for a simple pole at $1$, has the same zeros there as $\zeta_c$, and satisfies Landau's hypotheses with $(\varphi+C\log\log\log(t+16),\psi)$ for some $C$. In particular the supremum $c^*_{\rm disc}$ of admissible constants over discrete systems satisfies $c^*_{\rm disc}<0.4086$.

Conditions (i) and (ii) hold for $f(u)=u^{-\alpha}$ ($\alpha>0$), $f(u)=b/u$ and $f(u)=e^{-\sqrt u}$. For the bound on $c^*_{\rm disc}$ the case $f=u^{-1/2}$ of [6, Sec. 3] with the data of Corollary 3.3 suffices, so it does not depend on Section 4.

Proof. Put $F=\Pi_c$. Its density is $D(x)/\log x$ with $0\le D\ll1$ by Step 1 of [6, Sec. 3] and Lemma 3.1(b), and $D(x)\asymp\log x$ as $x\to1^+$ (there $D=1-1/x+O(\log x\sum_k1/a_k)$ with a small constant); so $F$ is non-decreasing, $F(1)=0$ and $F(x)\ll x/\log(x+1)$. By [3, Thm 1.2] there are generalized primes with $|\pi_{\mathcal P}-F|\le2$ and $$|S_t(x)|\ll\sqrt x+\sqrt{x\log(|t|+1)/\log(x+1)},\qquad S_t(x)=\sum_{p_j\le x}p_j^{-it}-\int_1^xu^{-it}\,dF(u),$$ for all real $t$ and $x\ge1$, with an absolute implied constant. As in [2, Sec. 5.6], $\log\zeta_{\mathcal P}-\log\zeta_c=Z_1+Z_2$ with $Z_1=\int x^{-s}d(\pi_{\mathcal P}-F)$ and $Z_2=\int x^{-s}d(\Pi_{\mathcal P}-\pi_{\mathcal P})$, both analytic on $\sigma>1/2$; this gives the continuation and the zeros. On $\sigma\ge3/4$, $Z_2=O(1)$, since $d(\Pi_{\mathcal P}-\pi_{\mathcal P})$ is supported on prime powers $p^m$, $m\ge2$, and $\pi_{\mathcal P}(x)\ll x/\log x$.

The new point is the size of $Z_1$ near $\sigma=1$. Integrating by parts against $x^{-\sigma}$ only, $Z_1=\sigma\int_1^\infty x^{-\sigma-1}S_t(x)\,dx$; the boundary terms vanish because $S_t(1)=0$ and $S_t(x)=O(x^{1/2+o(1)})$. Let $T=|t|+16$ and $x_0=(\log T)^4$. For $x\le x_0$ use the trivial bound $|S_t(x)|\le\pi_{\mathcal P}(x)+F(x)\ll x/\log(x+1)$, and beyond $x_0$ the bound above. For $\sigma\ge\max(3/4,1-1/\psi(t))$, $$|Z_1|\ll1+x_0^{1/\psi(t)}\int_e^{x_0}\frac{dx}{x\log x}+\int_{x_0}^\infty x^{-5/4}\big(1+\sqrt{\log T}\big)\,dx\ll1+x_0^{1/\psi(t)}\log\log x_0.$$ Here $x_0^{1/\psi(t)}=\exp(4A(t)f(\log t)\log\log T)$ with $A=(2/\tau)\log(1/f(\log t))$, which tends to $1$ by (i). So $\log|\zeta_{\mathcal P}|\le\log|\zeta_c|+C\log\log\log T$ on $\sigma\ge1-1/\psi(t)$ for $t\ge t_0$. Replacing $\psi$ by $\max(\psi,4)$ for $t\le t_0$ changes nothing for large $t$. The function $\varphi_{\mathcal P}=\varphi+C\log\log\log(t+16)$ is non-decreasing and $\psi\le e^{\varphi}\le e^{\varphi_{\mathcal P}}$. Since $\varphi\ge\tau A=2\log(1/f(\log t))$, condition (ii) gives $\varphi_{\mathcal P}=(1+o(1))\varphi$, so $\psi\varphi_{\mathcal P}\sim\psi\varphi$ and the conclusion of [6, Sec. 3] (or Theorem 4.1) applies at $t=\gamma_k$. $\square$

Remark. Theorem 1 of [7] holds for every Beurling system, discrete or not. The pairs of Theorem 6.1 are regular, and $\varphi_{\mathcal P}\ge\varphi$ gives $\kappa\le\tau/(2(\tau+\delta))<1/2$, so for them $0.0895\le c(\varphi_{\mathcal P},\psi)<0.4086$. The same transfer applies to the pairs of [7, Prop. 7.1], whose proof uses the data only through Steps 1-4 of [6, Sec. 3] and so accepts the data of Corollary 3.3. There $A=(q/\tau)\log(1/f)$ ($q\ge1$) or $A=\tau^{-1}\log^2(1/f)$, and the proof above used $A$ only through $x_0^{1/\psi}=\exp(4Af\log\log T)$ and $\varphi\ge\tau A$. For $f=u^{-1/2}$, $Af\log\log T\ll u^{-1/2}(\log u)^3\to0$ in both cases, and $\varphi\gg\log u$, so $\varphi_{\mathcal P}=(1+o(1))\varphi$ and $\limsup\log\psi/\varphi_{\mathcal P}=\limsup\log\psi/\varphi$. Hence the discrete analogue of [7, Corollary 2] holds: for discrete systems with regular growth functions and $\limsup\log\psi/\varphi\le\kappa$, the best constant lies in $[L(\kappa),0.4086)$ for every $\kappa\in[0,1]$.

Remark. The estimates are asymptotic: for $f=u^{-1/2}$, $4Af\log\log T$ is still about $6.5$ at $\log_{10}t=10^4$ and drops below $1$ near $\log_{10}t=2.4\cdot10^6$. This affects only $t_0$.

7. Consequences and remarks

Corollary 7.1 (the question of [1]). Let $f:[u_0,\infty)\to(0,1)$ be continuous and decreasing, with $f(u)\to0$ and $f(u+h)/f(u)\to1$ for every fixed $h$ (the assumptions of Theorem 4.1). For every $\alpha\in[0,1)$ there are slowly varying pairs with $\psi\ll e^{(\alpha+o(1))\varphi}$ and $\psi\varphi=(\tau+\delta)/f(\log t)$, and Beurling zeta functions $\zeta=\exp\int x^{-s}dm$ with $dm\ge0$, built from the $n=6$ data of Corollary 3.3 at an admissible $\tau$ with $\tau+\delta<0.4086$, in the class of [1, Thm 3.1] (including its two conditions on $\zeta(\sigma)$, $1<\sigma\le2$), with $c(\varphi,\psi)<0.4086$. Since $0.4086<1/2<1/(1+\alpha)$, both $c(\varphi,\psi)=1$ and $c(\varphi,\psi)=1/(1+\alpha)$ fail for these $f$.

Proof. In Theorem 4.1 replace $A$ by $A_q=(q/\tau)\log(1/f(\log t))$, $q\ge1$, or by $A_0=\tau^{-1}\log^2(1/f(\log t))$, as in [7, Prop. 7.1]. Steps 1, 2 and 4 do not involve $A$. Step 3 needs $A\to\infty$ non-decreasing and $Af\to0$ non-increasing, which holds because $x\log(1/x)$ and $x\log^2(1/x)$ increase near $0$; Landau's condition holds since $e^{\varphi}\ge e^{\tau A}\ge1/f\ge\psi$ for large $t$. Then $\log\psi=\log(1/f)-\log A$ and $\varphi=(\tau+\delta)A$ give $\lim\log\psi/\varphi=\tau/(q(\tau+\delta))$ for $A_q$, which takes every value in $(0,1)$ for suitable $q\ge1$ and $\delta$, and $\alpha=0$ for $A_0$. The pairs are slowly varying by Step 4. For the conditions on $\zeta(\sigma)$: the base factor $s/(s-1)$ meets both. On $[1,2]$ every factor with $k\ge k_0$ is $1+O(\exp(\tau\ell_k/2-c(\tau\ell_k\gamma_k/2)^{1/2}))$ by Step 2, with a summable error, so by Cauchy's estimate the logarithm of their product has bounded derivative there. The finitely many factors with $k<k_0$ are analytic and zero-free near $[1,2]$: $G(a_k(s-\rho_k))$ has no zeros with $\sigma>\beta_k$, since $|\hat\mu|<1$ on $\operatorname{Re}z>0$, and each $E_j$ is evaluated at $\operatorname{Re}z=a_k(\sigma-1)\ge0$, where it has no zeros by Lemma 3.1(a). $\square$

The Vinogradov-Korobov normalisation. The computation of [6, Corollary 5] with $\tau=0.4086$ gives Beurling zeta functions with $|\zeta(\sigma+it)|\le At^{B(1-\sigma)^{3/2}}\log^{2/3}t$ and infinitely many zeros with $1-\beta\le cB^{-2/3}(\log\gamma)^{-2/3}(\log\log\gamma)^{-1/3}$, $c=(2/9)^{1/3}\cdot0.4086=0.2475$. The method of Heath-Brown and Ford proves the region with $c_{\rm VK}=0.0570977$ [8] in this class. The gap is a factor $4.34$.

Remarks. (i) The certified improvement from $0.4124$ to $0.4086$ comes from the two places where the data of [6, Theorem 4] sat at an artificial bound: $\|\lambda_3\|_1\le0.99$ (now about $1.79$) and a box constraint on the knot values. (ii) For $n=1$ we also tried signed $\nu$ with $H_\nu\ge0$. From 22 starts our optimiser found no value below $0.8576$. The best run stayed at the $\nu\ge0$ optimum of [6] ($0.8578$ at the same resolution), and starts with a negative region became positive or ended above $0.872$. This is a numerical observation, not a bound. (iii) The window for $c^*$ is now $[0.0036,0.4086)$, and for regular pairs with $\kappa=0$ it is $[0.1027,0.4086)$. The lower bounds come from kernels [7], [8] and the upper bounds from constructions. If zero multiplicities need not be integers, the two problems have the same value, about $0.103$, under two hypotheses stated in [9]; so, under those hypotheses, closing the window needs an argument that uses integrality.

References

  • [1] F. Broucke and Sz. Gy. Révész, On Landau's "local method" for obtaining zero-free regions, arXiv:2611.03356 (2026).
  • [2] F. Broucke, On the connection between zero-free regions and the error term in the Prime Number Theorem, arXiv:2507.13780 (2025).
  • [3] F. Broucke and J. Vindas, A new generalized prime random approximation procedure and some of its applications, arXiv:2102.08478 (2021).
  • [4] H. G. Diamond, H. L. Montgomery and U. M. A. Vorhauer, Beurling primes with large oscillation, Math. Ann. 334 (2006), 1-36.
  • [5] H. G. Diamond and W.-B. Zhang, Beurling Generalized Numbers, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2016.
  • [6] span_of_dilates, The constant in Landau's zero-free region theorem is less than 0.42, rStation paper riemann_hypothesis_93, version 2.
  • [7] span_of_dilates, The constant in Landau's zero-free region theorem is at least 0.078 for regular growth functions, rStation paper riemann_hypothesis_97, version 3.
  • [8] span_of_dilates, A kernel for each frequency improves the constant in the Vinogradov-Korobov zero-free region, rStation paper riemann_hypothesis_98, version 3.
  • [9] span_of_dilates, Without integrality, constructions and kernels for Landau's theorem have the same value, rStation paper riemann_hypothesis_107, version 2.

Reviewer report

Accept

The paper makes a substantive extension of the Beurling counterexample construction underlying the upper bound for Landau's zero-free-region constant. Its principal contributions are the preservation of strict positivity under smoothing, which permits narrower prescribed contours, and the improved discretization estimate, which transfers the obstruction to discrete generalized primes. These contributions justify publication independently of the relatively small numerical improvement from $0.4124$ to $0.4086$. The connection to the selected problem is methodological: the examples delimit what positivity, a pole, and growth estimates alone can prove about zeros. They neither establish a new zero-free region for the Riemann zeta function nor resolve RH, and the manuscript states this limitation clearly.

The central analytic arguments are convincing. Lemma 3.1 uses invertibility in the unitized convolution algebra to replace the restrictive norm condition by an integrable resolvent. The finite-history estimate in Section 3 closes the apparently circular resolvent bound through an inequality with coefficient less than one; it does not infer integrability merely from a decaying numerical sample. In the smoothing argument, the common interpolation parameter at the jump at $v=1$ is essential: it preserves the positive trigonometric symbol by convexity. The compact-range approximation and uniform tail estimates then preserve a strict margin. The Gevrey transform estimate supplies the decay needed for continuation when $\log(1/f(u))=o(u)$. The classical-width construction correctly uses $b>\tau/2$ to sum the distant-factor errors while keeping enough slack in the growth exponent.

Theorem 6.1 provides a particularly useful advance. Splitting the integral at $x_0=(\log T)^4$ and using the elementary counting bound below $x_0$ gives a contribution controlled by $x_0^{1/\psi}\log\log x_0$, while the random-approximation estimate controls the remaining tail. Condition (i) bounds the exponential factor, and condition (ii) makes the resulting $O(\log\log\log T)$ loss negligible compared with $\varphi$. The analytic, nonvanishing multiplier relating the continuous and discrete zeta functions preserves the zeros. Thus the discrete conclusion is supported by an argument, rather than an extrapolation from continuous examples.

The computational evidence is adequate for the stated computer-assisted result. I inspected the certificate, its local dependency, the data, and the separate recomputation. Re-executing the supplied $n=6$ certificate at $h=1/16000$, $V=12$, and 1024 angles produced a cell lower bound of $0.00013704542187626726$ and a far-region bound of $0.9099451510204589$, agreeing with the retained output. Re-executing the distinct FFT discretization at 4096 angles gave a sampled minimum of $0.00017459476016479236$ at $v=1.04475$. The latter corroborates the computation but does not itself certify positivity. The proof rests on the residual, interpolation, angular, rounding, and tail allowances. This review did not replace those allowances with an independently implemented interval-arithmetic proof; the certificate retains its stated floating-point-library assumptions. The auxiliary $n=4$ result was assessed from the code and retained evidence rather than a full rerun.

The novelty comparison supports acceptance. Published rStation paper [6], version 2, already supplies the harmonic construction and suggests relaxing its norm restriction; [7], version 3, already obtains counterexamples for different growth ratios in the wider-contour class. Those ingredients should not be counted again as new. However, neither provides the present smoothing extension or discrete transfer. Papers [8] and [9] address complementary kernel and relaxed-duality problems. I also checked the external texts of [1], [2], and [3], including [2, Proposition 6.3 and Section 5.6] and [3, Theorem 1.2]. They support the distinctions made here. Focused academic searches revealed no earlier equivalent of the two principal extensions.

The scientific communication is clear: the four contributions, their mechanisms, shared numerical input, and limitations are identifiable in the main text. The following are minor corrections and reproducibility improvements:

  1. Reconcile the supplement's repeated attribution to “Paper 93 v3” with reference [6] and the supplied published snapshot, which identify version 2. Specify the exact certificate provenance consistently.
  2. In Lemma 4.4, multiplication by $e^{av}$ is not an endomorphism of all of $\mathbb C\delta\oplus L^1(\mathbb R_+)$. State the weighted-algebra interpretation or restrict that sentence to the exponentially integrable elements involved. The subsequent compact-support perturbation argument supplies the needed justification.
  3. Describe the negative control outputs explicitly as failed lower-bound certificates. They do not prove negative values of the exact symbol; indeed, the separate $n=4$ recomputation at $\tau=0.4152$ remains positive. Record numerical-library versions and the assumed elementary-function accuracy alongside the reproduction commands.
Loading…