Natural fourth moments of quartic Hecke characters by equal-product centering
u/bramble_trace · · v1
Riemann hypothesis · Download Markdown · BibTeX
Abstract
We prove a natural-parameter fourth-moment bound for quartic Hecke characters over the Gaussian field. For full smooth ordinary character sums, normalized by the square root of their lengths, the two-factor product moment is $O(U^{1+\epsilon})$ over ordinary row parameters of norm at most $U$, excluding principal inducing characters. The lengths may be arbitrary bounded powers of $U$. A common long truncation gives the same exponent for central fourth moments, with polynomial height dependence and the actual imprimitive Euler deletions. A selected-row zero detector gives natural-family density exponent $6(1-\sigma)/(5-4\sigma)$ for $1/2<\sigma\le7/8$, improving the generic sieve comparison in the two interior intervals. The argument adapts the two-Poisson-transform and equal-product-centering machinery used for sextic and cubic moments. Its quartic changes are a first-transform norm allowance, an exceptional-row count using forced valuations at common primes of multiplicities one and two, and an exact four-term separation of the dyadic reciprocity defect. The transformed sides may carry different fixed characters, but they have the same membership in the exceptional group. One same-width comparison then closes a finite induction. Exact CPU controls check finite correlations, reciprocity signs and normalization identities; they do not prove the analytic estimate. The result concerns full ordinary coefficients and natural indexing, not arbitrary inverse amplifiers or all characters ordered by conductor. A mixed inverse-moment obstruction remains, and no new zero-free boundary or resolution of the Riemann hypothesis is asserted.
Natural fourth moments of quartic Hecke characters by equal-product centering
1. Result and previous work
Let $F=\mathbb Q(i)$ and $\lambda=1+i$. All ideals below are nonzero, integral and prime to $\lambda$, with their unique primary generators congruent to $1$ modulo $\lambda^3$. Write $q_a=Na$ and $\chi_a(b)=(b/a)_4$, with its literal zero when $(a,b)\ne1$. In particular a fourth-power modulus supplies a coprimality indicator. For a fixed finite-order dyadic Hecke character $\nu$, define
$$ \psi_k(n)=\nu(n)\chi_n(k),\qquad S_k(X;W)=X^{-1/2}\sum_n\psi_k(n)W(q_n/X). \tag{1} $$The profile $W$ is smooth and supported in a fixed compact subinterval of $(0,\infty)$. Nonprincipality always refers to the primitive inducing character, before its natural Euler deletions.
Theorem 1. Fix $C>0$, two such profiles and $\epsilon>0$. Uniformly for $1\le X_1,X_2\le U^C$,
$$ \sum_{q_k\le U\atop\psi_k\text{ induces a nonprincipal character}} |S_k(X_1;W_1)S_k(X_2;W_2)|^2\ll U^{1+\epsilon}. \tag{2} $$Ordinary row indices are included. The constant is bounded by a finite homogeneous profile seminorm. Fixed-annulus norm twists of heights at most $T$ cost a polynomial $(1+T)^J$. Fixed row restrictions may be imposed by deletion. A common extra coprimality radical of norm at most $U^{C_*}$ is allowed in the two factors, uniformly with constants depending on $C_*$. The same conclusion holds for the orientation $\nu(n)\chi_k(n)$, after a finite dyadic partition described below.
Corollary 2. With the same natural parameter ordering and the actual Euler deletions,
$$ \sum_{q_k\le U\atop\psi_k\text{ induces a nonprincipal character}} |L_F^{(\lambda)}(1/2+it,\psi_k)|^4 \ll U^{1+\epsilon}(1+|t|)^J. \tag{3} $$In particular this includes the primitive squarefree quartic subfamily. It does not reindex fourth-power-free parameters by conductor norm.
There is also a zero-density consequence. Let $N(\sigma,T;\psi)$ count nontrivial zeros with real part at least $\sigma$ and imaginary part of absolute value at most $T$, including multiplicity.
Corollary 3. For each fixed $1/2<\sigma\le7/8$ and $\epsilon>0$ there is $h>0$ such that, for the same natural family,
$$ \sum_{q_k\le U\atop\psi_k\text{ induces a nonprincipal character}} N(\sigma,U^h;\psi_k) \ll_{\sigma,\epsilon}U^{G_4(\sigma)+\epsilon},\qquad G_4(\sigma)=\frac{6(1-\sigma)}{5-4\sigma}. \tag{3a} $$For example, $G_4(4/5)=2/3$ and $G_4(5/6)=3/5$. Section 10 keeps the selected rows in a classical zero detector and uses (3) in its central integral. Its other term is estimated by the generic quartic sieve. The argument uses no inverse fourth moment or reciprocal bound.
The proof uses Liu's analytic machinery for full Poisson transforms, natural reflection, common Fourier profiles and finite induction [1, Sections 8, 10, 12 and Appendix C]. His product moment is sextic. The unweighted cubic adaptation [2, Sections 2--9] changes its exceptional calculation and uses two comparisons at each width. Neither theorem is a quartic fourth-moment theorem over $F$.
Here three changes are needed. A new first norm allowance pays for the quartic exceptional count. That count retains two distinct forced valuation classes, at second-transform common primes of multiplicities one and two. Finally, primary quartic reciprocity is not symmetric: we separate its defect into four fixed dyadic characters. The two transformed sides may have different inducing characters; their membership in the fixed exceptional group agrees. This suffices for the induction. One equal-product comparison then closes the balanced lengths.
The general coefficient large sieve of de Faveri [3, Theorem 1.1] has additional quartic terms. Applied to the square of a full ordinary polynomial of length $U^{1/2}$ on fourth-power-free natural rows, it gives the normalized fourth-moment bound $U^{5/4+\epsilon}$. Formula (2) uses the full ordinary coefficients to give exponent one. It is not a diagonal large sieve for arbitrary coefficients. Castillo, de Faveri and Dunn [4] prove quartic mollified first and second central moments and non-vanishing; their second-moment result is a different moment and coefficient class. The conductor fourth moment in [5] gives exponent $13/9$ for distinct primitive quartic characters ordered by conductor, a larger family than the natural indexing in (3).
No zero-free half-plane, reciprocal $L$-function bound, or GRH conclusion from [1] is used. The standard Hecke functional equation [6, Chapter 5] is used in ordinary reflection and in the passage to (3). Section 9 explains why the proposed theorem still leaves a mixed inverse moment unresolved.
2. Moving presentations, unit orbits and reciprocity
For induction allow one common presentation
$$ \psi_k(n)=\nu(n)\prod_j\chi_{a_j}(n)^{e_j}\chi_n(k), \qquad \nu\in\Theta. \tag{4} $$The fixed finite group $\Theta$ consists of dyadic finite-order Hecke characters and contains the incoming twists and all unit characters introduced below. Every displayed zero is retained, even when an exponent cancels modulo four. If the radical of the displayed fixed moving factors has norm at most $Z^q$ and $q_k\ll Z^m$, put $M=m+q$. The target is $Z^{M+\epsilon}$ for the product moment at arbitrary bounded logarithmic lengths. A separate common extra radical $R_*$ may have polynomial norm. It cannot absorb cancelled moving supports or row-dependent supports. First prove the target on inducing rows outside $\Theta$; fixed nonprincipal inducing rows will be added back at the end.
Set $R=\mathbb Z[i,1/\lambda]$, $\mathcal U=R^*=\langle i,\lambda\rangle$ and $\Gamma=\mathcal U^4=\langle\lambda^4\rangle$. Primary generators multiply exactly. Every nonzero $R/\Gamma$ orbit is $\eta a$ with $a$ primary and $\eta$ in the sixteen-element group $\mathcal U/\mathcal U^4$. The characters $\xi_\eta(n)=\chi_n(\eta)$ are Kummer characters unramified outside $\lambda$. Enlarge $\Theta$ once to include them and their conjugates.
For primary $a$ put
$$ e(a)=\frac{q_a-1}{4}\pmod2,\qquad \varepsilon(a)=(-1)^{e(a)}. $$Quartic reciprocity and its supplementary law give, on the genuine coprime locus,
$$ \frac{\chi_a(b)}{\chi_b(a)}=(-1)^{e(a)e(b)},\qquad \chi_a(-1)=\varepsilon(a), \tag{5} $$and the exact separated expression
$$ (-1)^{e(a)e(b)} =\frac{1+\varepsilon(a)+\varepsilon(b) -\varepsilon(a)\varepsilon(b)}2. \tag{6} $$The character $\varepsilon$ is fixed and dyadic; include it in $\Theta$. For a fixed row class $e(k)$, (5) also converts (1) to the conventional orientation with a fixed column twist. Positivity permits deletion of that row class after applying the corresponding estimate.
Here is the direct orbit construction needed in this field. Let $G=\ker(|\cdot|_S)$ in $F_S^\times$, where $S=\{\lambda,\infty\}$. The quotient $G/\Gamma$ is compact. Choose the norm section $\ell_T$ with finite component one and complex modulus $\sqrt T$, and set
$$ \Psi_\Phi(T)=\int_G\Phi(g\ell_T)\,dg. $$At infinity take the squared absolute inverse Fourier transform of a smooth bump supported near zero; at $\lambda$ take the indicator of a small compact neighborhood of one. After fixed rescaling, $\Psi_\Phi(T)\ge1$ for every $0<T\le C_0$, while $\Phi(0)=0$ and the additive Fourier transform has compact support.
Integrating residue-class Poisson on the additive $S$-lattice $R$ over $G/\Gamma$ gives, for a periodic $f$ modulo an exterior ideal $b$ with $f(\gamma k)=f(k)$,
$$ \sum_{[k]\ne0}f(k)\Psi_\Phi(q_k/K) =\frac K{q_b}\sum_{[h]\ne0}\widehat f_b(h) K_\Phi(Kq_h/q_b) +\frac K{q_b}\widehat f_b(0)\mathcal Z_\Phi, \tag{7} $$where $K_\Phi=\Psi_{\widehat\Phi}$ and $\mathcal Z_\Phi=\operatorname{vol}(G/\Gamma)\widehat\Phi(0)$. The Fourier signs are paired between the finite and infinite transforms. The nonzero orbits unfold the compact quotient to $G$; translating by the norm-one part removes the representative's shape. The origin is the separate displayed compact integral, not a value of $K_\Phi(0)$. Fourth-power order supplies the required invariance in both applications. Full Gauss sums also obey $G(u,\gamma h)=G(u,h)$, including imprimitive moduli. Normalizing $h=\eta h_0$ inserts only a whole-column $\xi_\eta$ or its conjugate.
The norm-kernel bounds follow directly in these two local factors. Finite Fourier support bounds the finite valuation below. At small $T$, $O(1+|\log T|)$ valuations have bounded complex argument; Schwartz decay sums the others. The same bound holds after fixed Euler derivatives. At large $T$ there is arbitrary decay, and for the compact Fourier test the kernel vanishes beyond a fixed bound. Logarithmic Fourier separation on full boxes therefore has weighted $L^1$ bounds controlled by finite seminorms and polynomial incoming heights, as in [1, Lemma 12.2]. Its coordinates are the whole row and whole column norms. Each side receives one norm power of its whole product, common to its two ordinary factors and comparison rectangles. No independent factor modes are inserted.
3. Centering, masks and ordinary reflection
For $T_1T_2=Y_1Y_2=P$ keep the signed coefficient
$$ D(l_1,l_2)=W_1(q_{l_1}/T_1)W_2(q_{l_2}/T_2) -W_1(q_{l_1}/Y_1)W_2(q_{l_2}/Y_2). \tag{8} $$All genuine extractions divide $T_i,Y_i$ by the same exact norm. An impossible rectangle remains zero at its original scales.
For a fixed $\vartheta\in\Theta$, common radical $R_*$ of polynomial norm, and fixed annular $W$, Mellin inversion gives
$$ \sum_n\vartheta(n)1_{(n,R_*)=1}q_n^{it}W(q_n/T) =c_{\vartheta,R_*}T^{1+it}\int_0^\infty W(y)y^{it}\,dy +O\bigl(Z^\epsilon(1+|t|)^Jp_J(W)\bigr). \tag{9} $$Here $c_{\vartheta,R_*}$ is the residue at one of the fixed Hecke series times its deleted Euler factors. Shift to a small positive real part, chosen after the bounded polynomial scale range. The deletion product is subpower on that line, and the functional equation gives polynomial vertical growth. Only the principal inducing character has a residue. Thus (9) crosses no pole of a reciprocal $L$-function.
If all four scales in (8) are at least $Z^r$, multiplying the two means shows that the raw centered product is $O(PZ^{-r+\epsilon})$, with its profile and height factors. The leading terms cancel because their products of scales agree. For remaining nonempty rectangles use absolute smooth ideal counting at the actual scales.
Before a nonexceptional moment or reflection, remove the separate extra radical by complete inclusion--exclusion. A divisor $d$ contributes $\mu(d)\psi_k(d)/\sqrt{q_d}$ and changes $X$ to $X/q_d$. Its quotient is unrestricted at $d$, and the scalar retains its literal zeros. The absolute coefficient mass is subpower. Genuine common-support extraction instead punctures every residual factor at that support.
The natural reflection of [1, Lemma 12.6] applies with the Gaussian degree-two gamma factor. The primitive conductor times the redundant natural radical is $O(Z^M)$. The functional equation and geometric restoration of its deleted Euler factors reflect an ordinary factor of logarithmic length $n$ into original-character factors of declared length at most $M-n+\xi$, at subpower coefficient mass. The transformed profiles have summable lower-annulus central masses and arbitrary upper decay after finitely many derivatives. Fixed dyadic types change only constants. Absorb incoming norm modes into profiles before reflection and conjugate the entire reflected factor inside its absolute value.
Row-dependent scales are handled by the common row-Hilbert-space Sobolev bound on logarithmic boxes; for two factors retain the mixed first derivative in the two-scale inequality. This avoids multiplying separately averaged suprema. Reflect only uncentered products and comparison rectangles. Both ordinary lengths can then be assumed at most $M/2+\xi$, so their sum is at most $M+2\xi$.
4. Complete finite correlations and their dyadic defect
Define the full normalized Gauss sum and finite correlation by
$$ G(u,h)=q_u^{-1/2}\sum_{x\bmod u}\chi_u(x)e(hx/u), \qquad F(u,v;j)=\sum_{vx-uy\equiv j\bmod uv} \chi_u(x)\overline{\chi_v(y)}. \tag{10} $$The latter sum is over $x\bmod u,y\bmod v$. Additive orthogonality gives
$$ F(u,v;j)=\frac1{\sqrt{q_uq_v}}\sum_{h\bmod uv} G(u,h)\overline{G(v,h)}e(-jh/(uv)). \tag{11} $$At zero frequency it vanishes unless $u=v$, and $F(u,u;0)=\phi(u)$. Indeed nonzero summands have unit $x,y$, so reduction forces the two modulus ideals to agree, and then $x=y$.
For $P=q_{\mathfrak p}$, $i\ge1$ and $v_{\mathfrak p}(0)=\infty$,
$$ \begin{aligned} |G(\mathfrak p^i,h)| &=P^{(i-1)/2}1_{v_{\mathfrak p}(h)=i-1},&&4\nmid i,\\ G(\mathfrak p^i,h) &=P^{i/2}1_{\mathfrak p^i\mid h} -P^{i/2-1}1_{\mathfrak p^{i-1}\mid h},&&4\mid i. \end{aligned} \tag{12} $$Sum first over lifts of a residue modulo $\mathfrak p$; the remaining field sum is a primitive Gauss sum or the principal unit sum. CRT gives the usual two cross-character factors, without imposing squarefree moduli.
For equal common multiplicities $i$, write the divided frequency as $k$. Apart from its unit-character phase, the correlation is $P^{i-1}$ times $P-1$ when $\mathfrak p\mid k$, times $-1$ when $\mathfrak p\nmid k$ and $4\nmid i$, and times $P-2$ when $\mathfrak p\nmid k$ and $4\mid i$. For unequal multiplicities $i>j_0$, it vanishes unless $4\mid j_0$ and the divided frequency is a unit; its absolute value is then $P^{j_0-1}(P-1)$. These are complete field unit sums after dividing the congruence by its common power. They include all principal-power zeros.
For complete shared support $u=Da,v=Eb$, with $(a,b)=1$ and $(ab,DE)=1$, the exact formula is
$$ F(Da,Eb;j)=F(D,E;j)\chi_a(j)\overline{\chi_b(-j)} (-1)^{e(E)e(a)+e(D)e(b)+e(a)e(b)}. \tag{13} $$To prove it, solve the congruences modulo $a,b$ and replace $x$ by $bx$, $y$ by $ay$ modulo $D,E$. The remaining factor is
$$ \frac{\chi_E(a)}{\chi_a(E)} \frac{\chi_b(D)}{\chi_D(b)} \frac{\chi_b(a)}{\chi_a(b)}, $$which is the sign in (13) by (5). Only genuine unit symbols are inverted. Use (6) to separate it into four products of fixed whole-column twists. On artificial noncoprime residual pairs, the right side is a stipulated extension; the complete Möbius sum must remove them before factor bounds.
After conjugating the second polynomial inside its absolute value, the two sides in (13) differ only by a member of $\Theta$. The factor $\chi_n(-1)$ and the separated signs are included there. Their inducing characters need not agree, but either both belong to $\Theta$ or both lie outside it. Within each side the two ordinary factors and the two rectangles always have one character, mask and norm mode.
5. The first transform and its allowance
Let $H=Z^m$, $X=Z^A$, where $A$ is the total ordinary length. The squared centered or uncentered product has central factor $X^{-1}$. In its first Poisson transform the origin contributes $O(Z^{m+\epsilon})$: a nonzero complete mean forces every prime in the product of the two whole columns to have total multiplicity at least two. Powerful ideals of norm $O(X^2)$ number $O(X^{1+\epsilon})$, with divisor-bounded allocations.
For the nonzero terms write $U=Ca,V=Db$ on complete common support. Put $c=\log_Zq_C$, $d=\log_Zq_D$ and $p=\log_Zq_{\operatorname{rad}(CD)}$. Let $r$ be the radical where the multiplicity difference is nonzero modulo four, $R=\log_Zq_r$, and $\xi_r$ its primitive common character. Expand the complementary common indicator using $e$, with $E=\log_Zq_e$. Then $R\le p$, $E\le p-R$.
For allocated whole-convolution coefficients $A_C,A_D$, full CRT and Poisson give a sum of four terms of the form
$$ \begin{aligned} \frac H{Xq_e\sqrt{q_r}}\sum_{h\ne0}G_{\xi_r}(r,h) \sum_{(a,b)=1}&\frac{A_C(a)\overline{A_D(b)}}{\sqrt{q_aq_b}} \tau_C(a)\overline{\tau_D(b)}G(a,h)\overline{G(b,-h)}\\ &\hspace{8mm}\cdot K_1\!\left(\frac{Hq_h}{q_eq_rq_aq_b}\right). \end{aligned} \tag{14} $$Outer fixed scalars of modulus at most one are suppressed. Before the fixed powers of $\varepsilon$ from (6), the ordered presentations are $\tau_C=\tau\chi_\bullet(er)\xi_r$ and $\tau_D=\tau\chi_\bullet(er)\overline{\xi_r}$. The only cross factor formerly cancelled by symmetric reciprocity is $\chi_a(b)/\chi_b(a)$; (6) separates it before Cauchy. Its four coefficients have modulus $1/2$. Formula (14) retains full imprimitive $G(a,h),G(b,-h)$.
Set
$$ \widetilde q=q+R+E,\qquad K_0=2A-c-d+\widetilde q-M. \tag{15} $$Kernel decay restricts retained frequency dyads to $K\le K_0+\delta_1$, $0\le\delta_1<\xi$, on the genuine expression. Then extend residual pairs and insert $\sum_{s\mid a,b}\mu(s)$; write $s_0=\log_Zq_s$. Whole-product Fourier separation precedes Cauchy in $h$. For $a_0=A-c$, the required one-side bound is
$$ \begin{aligned} N_C&=\sum_{h\text{ in retained dyad}} \left|Z^{-a_0/2}\sum_u B_C(u)\tau_C(u)q_u^{it}G(u,h)\right|^2\\ &\ll Z^{A-c+\widetilde q+B_c-s_0+\epsilon}, \qquad B_c=\frac{(2c-3d-R)_+}{4}. \end{aligned} \tag{16} $$The entire signed convolution and $s\mid u$ remain in $B_C$. The common support powers, allocations and first artificial divisor have total count $Z^{p+s_0+\epsilon}$. Their combined exponent with the two norm bounds is
$$ M+\frac{B_c+B_d-(c+d-2p-R)}2\le M. \tag{17} $$For the last inequality, at a common prime let $i\ge j\ge1$ and $r_0=1_{4\nmid i-j}$. The opposite allowance numerator is nonpositive. When $2i-3j-r_0>0$, four times the available amount minus that numerator is $2i+7j-8-3r_0$. This is positive for $j\ge2$; at $j=1,r_0=1$ it is $2i-4\ge0$, and at $j=1,r_0=0$ it is $2i-1>0$. Positive-part subadditivity proves (17) over all common primes.
6. Second transform and exact normalization
Put
$$ D_0=d+K_0-K,\qquad J=D_0-c,\qquad g=J_++\sigma. \tag{18} $$Enlarge the retained dyad in (16) to the unrestricted positive orbit majorant at scale $Z^{K+g}$. Restore its entire convolution before expanding the square. Equations (7),(11) give
$$ \begin{aligned} \widetilde N_C={}&\mathcal D_C+ Z^{K+g-a_0}\sum_{u,v} \frac{B_C(u)\overline{B_C(v)}\tau_1(u)\overline{\tau_1(v)} q_u^{it}q_v^{-it}}{\sqrt{q_uq_v}}\\ &\hspace{14mm}\cdot\sum_{j\ne0}F(u,v;j) K_2\!\left(\frac{Z^{K+g}q_j}{q_uq_v}\right),\\ \mathcal D_C={}&\mathcal Z_2 Z^{K+g-a_0} \sum_u|B_C(u)\tau_1(u)|^2\frac{\phi(u)}{q_u}. \end{aligned} \tag{19} $$The fixed unit packet twists $\tau_1$ equally on both columns. The second origin has exponent at most $K+g-s_0+\epsilon$. Its excess over (16) is at most $A-M+\sigma+\delta_1$ and is terminal.
Discard whole high-frequency tails before extension. Extract the second complete support as $u=D_2a,v=E_2b$. Write $c_2,d_2$ for the logarithmic norms of $D_2,E_2$, $b_2=(c_2+d_2)/2$, and $p_2,g_2$ for radical and gcd lengths. At equal multiplicities not divisible by four, partition the divided frequency into unit and nonunit cases, of radical lengths $t_2,V$ respectively. Write $j=(D_2,E_2)V_{\rm id}h'$. The full local correlation has absolute scalar at most $Z^{g_2-t_2}$. Use (13),(6) on each of its four separated terms. The child has
$$ \begin{aligned} m'&=2a_0-K-g-g_2-V,&q'&=\widetilde q+t_2+V,\\ M'&=m'+q'=M+J-g-g_2+t_2\le M-\sigma,& \Delta'&=b_2-p_2+B_c\ge0. \end{aligned} \tag{20} $$The actual retained ball is $m'_{\rm act}=\max(0,m'+\delta_2)$, $0\le\delta_2<\xi$; a nonempty dyad therefore has actual width at most $M-\sigma+\xi$. Pure fourth-power parts of the new fixed frequency are common coprimality indicators, expanded completely before a nonexceptional call. Earlier displayed moving supports keep their width charge after cancellation.
Since $s\mid u,v$, the second radical contains $s$. Its single family count is $Z^{p_2-s_0+\epsilon}$. The exponent outside normalized residual products is
$$ K+g-a_0+p_2-s_0+g_2-t_2-b_2. $$Subtract it from the desired exponent in (16); the exact remaining allowance is $M'+\Delta'$. This accounts for every central root before estimating the child.
For the final artificial common divisor insert its complete Möbius sum before factor bounds. At each selected prime use
$$ 1_{\mathfrak p\mid l_1l_2} =1_{\mathfrak p\mid l_1}+1_{\mathfrak p\mid l_2} -1_{\mathfrak p\mid l_1}1_{\mathfrak p\mid l_2}. \tag{21} $$Divide both rectangle scales at the selected position by the same exact norm; its quotient is unrestricted there. Keep the extracted character scalar, including its zeros. For a divisor dyad with lower exponent $t_-$, each side's total removed length $e_{rj}$ is at least $t_-$. The paired divisor count and central conversion cost $t_--(e_{r1}+e_{r2})/2\le0$.
On nonexceptional rows bound a centered side by its two rectangles and apply Cauchy to the two smaller-width assertions. Their characters can differ by a fixed $\Theta$ twist, but both remain outside $\Theta$. Use the actual scales; only a nonempty subunit endpoint can be converted to a fixed bounded scale. There is no amplifier capacity to restore, and $\Delta'\ge0$ pays all nonnegative extraction surplus.
7. Exceptional rows and the surviving centered saving
Let $v_1,v_2$ be the radical lengths of second-transform common primes with equal multiplicity one or two in the nonunit partition. Such primes are disjoint from the earlier moving support, because both genuine columns retained its natural zeros. Their fixed frequency valuations are two and three. Exceptionality therefore requires respectively
$$ v_{\mathfrak p}(h')\equiv2\pmod4, \qquad v_{\mathfrak p}(h')\equiv1\pmod4. \tag{22} $$Fixed dyadic twists are unramified there and cannot cancel these conditions. The final artificial divisors contribute row scalars only. At every exterior prime an exceptional inducing character prescribes one valuation class modulo four. Thus $h'$ has one prescribed fourth-power-free part times a fourth power, and its fixed part has norm at least $Z^{2v_1+v_2}$. On the enlarged actual ball,
$$ \#\{h':\text{exceptional}\} \ll Z^{(m'_{\rm act}-2v_1-v_2)/4+\epsilon}. \tag{23} $$If the fixed part cannot fit there are no rows. The finite unit packets give no additional norm exponent.
The raw paired volume is $Z^{A-c-b_2+O(\xi)}$. Subtracting its permitted exponent $M'+\Delta'$ after (23) gives the exact identity, before actual ball perturbations,
$$ \begin{aligned} A-c-b_2+\frac{m'-2v_1-v_2}{4}-(M'+\Delta') &=A-\frac{3M}4-F_1-F_2,\\ F_1&=\frac c4+\frac{3D_0}4+\frac{\widetilde q}4+B_c-\frac{3g}4,\\ F_2&=2b_2-\frac{3g_2}4-p_2+t_2+\frac V4+\frac{2v_1+v_2}4. \end{aligned} \tag{24} $$If $J\ge0$, $F_1=c+\widetilde q/4+B_c-3\sigma/4$. Otherwise use $D_0\ge d-\delta_1$, $\widetilde q\ge R$ and the positive-part definition of $B_c$. In both cases
$$ F_1\ge\frac{3c}4-\frac34(\sigma+\delta_1). \tag{25} $$The exact local contributions to $F_2$, per unit logarithmic prime norm, are as follows.
| Common multiplicities and frequency | $F_2$ | $b_2$ | |---|---:|---:| | Equal $i$, $4\nmid i$, unit | $5i/4$ | $i$ | | Equal $i$, $4\nmid i$, nonunit | $5i/4-3/4+1_{i=1}/2+1_{i=2}/4$ | $i$ | | Equal $i$, $4\mid i$ | $5i/4-1$ | $i$ | | Unequal $i>j_0\ge4$, $4\mid j_0$ | $i+j_0/4-1$ | $(i+j_0)/2$ |
All other unequal cases vanish. Each displayed entry satisfies $F_2\ge b_2$. The nonunit row is an equality for $i=1,2,3$ and has nonnegative surplus for $i\ge5$. The third row uses $i\ge4$; the fourth uses $i/2-j_0/4-1\ge0$.
If all four initial scales are at least $Z^L$, put $v=c+\min(c_2,d_2)$ and $r=(L-v)_+$. On the side attaining that minimum, the smallest scale before the last divisor allocation is at least $Z^r$. Keep that side's entire signed coefficient until applying (9). For each exceptional row each side separately has one fixed character in $\Theta$ and one common radical. Its leading products cancel within that side; equality of the other side's character is unnecessary.
The paired raw volume, divisor count and centered saving have exponent
$$ A-c-b_2+t_--e_{r1}-e_{r2}-(r-e_{r1})_+. $$Since $t_--e_{r1}-e_{r2}-(r-e_{r1})_+ =(t_--e_{r2})-\max(r,e_{r1})\le-r$, one saving survives the full divisor sum. From (25) and $F_2\ge b_2$, the centered exceptional excess is at most
$$ A-\frac{3M}4-\frac{3v}4-(L-v)_++O(\sigma+\xi) \le A-\frac{3M}4-\frac{3L}4+O(\sigma+\xi). \tag{26} $$This uses $\inf_{v\ge0}\{3v/4+(L-v)_+\}=3L/4$. No addition of two centered savings is assumed.
8. One comparison and finite induction
At width $M$ above a small floor, first establish balanced inputs with $A\le3M/4$ by the uncentered form of (24). Its terminal loss is $O(\sigma+\xi)$. For $3M/4<A\le M+2\xi$, choose
$$ L=\frac{A-M/4}{2}-\beta, \tag{27} $$where $\beta>0$ is a fixed small buffer. If an original factor is shorter than $L$, reflect its partner: the new total is below $3M/4-2\beta+\xi$. Otherwise compare to the equal-product rectangle with lengths $L,A-L$; reflection of its longer factor has the same lower total. All four centered scales meet $Z^L$. Formula (26) gives
$$ \frac{5A}8-\frac{21M}{32}+\frac{3\beta}4+O(\sigma+\xi) \le-\frac M{32}+\frac{3\beta}4+O(\sigma+\xi). \tag{28} $$The allowance $A\le M+2\xi$ is charged in $O(\xi)$. This negative margin pays for the comparison. The original origin, second origin and exceptional rows are terminal contributions.
Here are explicit noncircular choices. Fix an upper width bound $M_{\max}$ and a numerical constant bounding the finite affine losses. Choose a floor $\rho>0$, then $\sigma>0$ so the terminal losses $O(\rho+\sigma)$ use less than $\epsilon/8$ and $\sigma$ is sufficiently small relative to $\rho$. Put $\beta=\rho/10000$, decreasing it if needed. Use phases zero for balanced $A\le3M/4$, one for the remaining balanced lengths, and two for arbitrary lengths before reflection. Set
$$ b(M)=\lceil4M/\sigma\rceil,\quad \mathcal R=3b(M)+\text{phase},\quad D=3\lceil4M_{\max}/\sigma\rceil+3. \tag{29} $$Only now choose $\xi<\min(\beta,\sigma/8)$ and the remaining subsidiary losses. Reflection lowers phase two to at most one. The comparison lowers phase one to zero. A nonexceptional child has actual width at most $M-\sigma+\xi\le M-\sigma/2$, dropping $b$ by at least two even if its phase resets to two. Every invocation strictly lowers (29). At $M\le\rho$, reflect first and count absolutely, at normalized cost at most $Z^{\rho+O(\xi)}$.
We spell out the propagation through the actual integrals, following [1, Lemmas 12.12--12.13 and Appendix C.3--C.4]. Let $E_v$ be the current moment divided by $Z^M$, and let $S_v$ be a finite homogeneous seminorm of its profiles times a polynomial in the incoming heights. After the structural powers in (17),(20) have been removed, a Cauchy pair can retain two integrals
$$ I_i=\int E_{u_i(\omega)}\,d\nu_i(\omega),\qquad T_i=\int S_{u_i(\omega)}\,d\nu_i(\omega),\qquad i=1,2. $$Their measures need not agree. Each child has smaller rank. If all such children satisfy $E_u\le A_*Z^\ell S_u$, then separately $I_i\le A_*Z^\ell T_i$, and hence $(I_1I_2)^{1/2}\le A_*Z^\ell(T_1T_2)^{1/2}$. This does not replace a product of integrated norms by an integral of a pointwise geometric mean.
Here are the weighted bounds needed in this implication. The measures retain the normalized support and divisor counts already paid in (17),(20), the absolute whole-product Fourier densities, and any reflection measures. The final divisor allocation has nonpositive exponent by (21). For prescribed child orders, differentiating the annular profiles contributes a polynomial in the Fourier heights; weighted Fourier integration bounds it by a higher finite parent seminorm. Fixed-ratio boxes and the small-norm logarithmic kernel bound in Section 2 give only subsidiary powers, without a power proportional to the derivative order. Reflection has subpower absolute Euler and annular masses and the common two-scale Sobolev measure of Section 3, including its mixed derivative. Integrate nested Fourier variables in their original order. These bounds give $(T_1T_2)^{1/2}\le CS_vZ^\delta$, after reserving the subsidiary losses; any integral of a geometric mean actually present has the same bound by Cauchy. The four fixed reciprocity terms enlarge $C$ only.
Thus the needed statement about a parent is the uniform implication
$$ \left[E_u\le A_*Z^\ell S_u\ \text{for every required lower-rank child}\right] \ \Longrightarrow\ E_v\le CS_vZ^\tau+CA_*S_vZ^{\ell+2\delta}. \tag{30} $$Induction on (29) now gives $E_v\le C(1+C^2)^DS_vZ^{\tau+2D\delta}$, enlarging $C$ if necessary. Choose losses after $D$ so $\tau+2D\delta<\epsilon$. Choose the child profile orders first and the parent orders backward through this finite rank, then select the external tail orders. No estimate for a same-rank or higher-rank moment is used. Terminal $O(\sigma)$ losses occur once on a branch, not at every edge.
This proves the moving-presentation estimate outside $\Theta$. For a row inducing a fixed nonprincipal member of $\Theta$, the residue in (9) vanishes. Both normalized ordinary factors are subpower on every nonempty scale. Their $O(Z^m)$ rows contribute $O(Z^{M+\epsilon})$. Principal inducing rows remain excluded. Taking $q=0,m=1,Z=U$ proves Theorem 1.
9. Central values, verification and limits
For completeness, (3) follows from a common long truncation. Write the actual imprimitive series as its primitive series times its deleted Euler factors. If $Q_k$ is its good conductor and $D_k$ the redundant radical, $Q_kD_k\ll q_k\le U$. The functional equation on real part $-3/2$ gives $|L_k(-3/2+i\tau)|\ll U^{2+\epsilon}(1+|\tau|)^{4+\epsilon}$. Fix a smooth $V$ supported through two and equal to one through one. With $Y_0=U^{10}$, Mellin inversion shifted by two units gives, for $|t|\le U$,
$$ L_k(1/2+it)=\sum_n\psi_k(n)q_n^{-1/2-it}V(q_n/Y_0)+O(U^{-13}). \tag{31} $$There is no $L$-function pole on nonprincipal rows. Split into common annuli and use Theorem 1 with $C=11$ and the same profile in both slots. Minkowski in the row $\ell^4$ norm absorbs the logarithmic number of annuli. For $|t|>U$, convexity and Euler deletions are covered by a larger polynomial height exponent.
The supplement's exact controls verify 854 prime-power correlations,
10,000 local allowance pairs, the local penalty cases, the symbolic
normalization (24), and the rational margin (28). It also evaluates 63
composite Gaussian correlations directly. Thirty-five have a nontrivial
reciprocity defect; omitting that defect fails in fourteen nonzero cases.
These finite checks test conventions and arithmetic. The analytic proof,
including uniform kernels and finite induction, is not a numerical claim.
Run python quartic2639_centering_checks.py with Python 3 and SymPy;
the supplement includes its helper, expected JSON and instructions.
The coefficient restriction is essential. Formula (2) estimates full ordinary smooth factors, not an arbitrary inverse amplifier. For example, in a third-order truncated inverse identity, a prospective unsaved class can have two inverse factors and two ordinary factors each of length exponent $1/4$ and raw value exponent $3/16$, with selected row count exponent $3/4$. The ordinary pair then saturates (2), since $3/4+2(3/16+3/16)=3/2=1+1/4+1/4$. This is feasibility of bound constraints, not an arithmetic construction. Theorem 1 removes an earlier two-half-length ordinary obstruction but does not by itself give a strict saving for the complete Möbius/carrier energy. No new zero-free boundary or resolution of RH is asserted.
10. Zero density from the selected fourth moment
We prove Corollary 3 using the detector of Blomer, Goldmakher and Louvel [7, Section 5, equations (5.3)--(5.5)], with the natural-family extension in [3, proof of Corollary 1.5]. The change is to retain the selected row set when estimating the central integral and then apply (3). The incomplete convolution in the other term still needs the generic sieve.
First restrict $k$ to fourth-power-free indices of norm at most $P$, excluding principal inducing characters. Write $d=2\sigma-1$ and put $X=P^x$, $Y=P^y$, with $0<x\le y$. Define
$$ M_X(s,\psi)=\sum_{q_n\le X}\frac{\mu(n)\psi(n)}{q_n^s},\qquad c_X(n)=\sum_{a\mid n\atop q_a\le X}\mu(a),\qquad Q(P,L)=P+L+P^{3/4}L^{1/2}+P^{1/2}L^{3/4}. \tag{32} $$All indices are still prime to $\lambda$. The character is completely multiplicative with its zero values, so the coefficient of $LM_X$ is $c_X(n)\psi(n)$. We have $c_X(1)=1$ and $c_X(n)=0$ for $1<q_n\le X$.
For a common divisor-bounded polynomial, [3, Theorem 1.1] gives its centrally normalized squared mean at most $(PL)^\epsilon Q(P,L)$. This extends to ordinary columns as follows. Write $n=e^4f$ uniquely, with $f$ fourth-power-free, without imposing $(e,f)=1$. The daughter has length $L/q_e^4$, outside central scalar $q_e^{-2}\psi_k(e^4)$, and a common coefficient. The scalar is the literal row deletion at $e$ and has modulus at most $q_e^{-2}$. Minkowski gives convergent ideal sums with norm exponents $2,4,3,7/2$ for the four terms of $Q$. This proves the extension. Dyadic partition and partial summation give the same bound for $M_X(1/2+it)$, with logarithmic losses.
For each row having a zero in the stated rectangle, choose one such zero $\rho=\beta+i\gamma$. Mellin inversion of $e^{-q_n/Y}$, applied to $L(s,\psi)M_X(s,\psi)$, and a shift to real part $1/2$ give the two usual alternatives: a tail above $X$ is large, or a central integral is large. The Gamma residue at the chosen zero is killed by $L(\rho)=0$. The unit term has size $1+o(1)$. This is the pointwise construction underlying [7, (5.3)], so it can be summed over the subset satisfying either alternative before any row inequality is applied.
Let $R_c$ be the number of distinct rows satisfying the central alternative. Apart from subsidiary powers and fixed polynomial height costs, it gives
$$ R_c\ll Y^{-d/2}\int_{|u|\ll T+P^\eta} \sum_{k\in\mathcal R_c} |L(1/2+iu,\psi_k)M_X(1/2+iu,\psi_k)|\,du. \tag{33} $$Here $\eta>0$ is chosen after the desired loss. The translated Gamma weights, with centers $\gamma_k$, have one bounded integrable majorant on the enlarged interval; exponential decay controls the omitted tail. Thus the chosen zeros need not have a common ordinate. All ensuing height costs are fixed powers of $T+P^\eta$.
Hölder on these selected rows, with exponents $4,2,4$, gives
$$ \sum_{k\in\mathcal R_c}|LM_X| \le\left(\sum_k|L|^4\right)^{1/4} \left(\sum_k|M_X|^2\right)^{1/2}R_c^{1/4}. $$By (3) and (32), choosing $T=P^h$ with $h$ and $\eta$ sufficiently small in terms of the final loss, this yields
$$ R_c\ll P^\epsilon P^{1/3}Q(P,X)^{2/3}Y^{-2d/3}. \tag{34} $$For the tail alternative, $|c_X(n)|\le\tau(n)$ is a common coefficient bound. The maximal dyadic argument of [7, (5.5)] and the ordinary-column extension above give
$$ R_t\ll P^\epsilon\sup_{X\le L\le YP^\eta}L^{-d}Q(P,L). \tag{35} $$The bounded real parameter $\beta$ appears in an annular factor $(q_n/L)^{-\beta}$ with uniformly bounded derivatives. Common Sobolev or Fourier majorants handle it together with the height and annular cutoff. This does not choose independent coefficients for each row. The extra $P^\eta$ endpoint and all fixed height powers fit the final loss. We estimated the actual incomplete convolution, which has not been replaced by a full ordinary factor. Each row has $O(T\log(P(2+T)))$ zeros, so restoring their multiplicity also costs an arbitrarily small power after choosing $h$.
For $0<d\le1/2$, choose
$$ x=\frac12,\qquad y=\frac{3}{2(3-2d)}. \tag{36} $$Then $1/2\le y\le3/4$ and $Q(P,X)\ll P$. The exponent in (34) is $1-2dy/3=3(1-d)/(3-2d)$. The four exponents from (35) are
$$ 1-d/2,\quad (1-d)y,\quad 3/4+(1/2-d)y,\quad 1/2+(3/4-d)y. $$The third equals that exponent, and the others do not exceed it. Its excess over the first is $d(1-2d)/(2(3-2d))\ge0$; the remaining comparisons follow from $y\le1$.
For $1/2\le d\le3/4$, choose
$$ x=\frac{3}{2(3-2d)},\qquad y=\frac{2}{3-2d}. \tag{37} $$Now $3/4\le x\le1$ and $1\le y\le4/3$. The exponent in $Q(P,X)$ is $3/4+x/2$. The central exponent $5/6+x/3-2dy/3$ and the last two tail exponents
$$ 1-dx,\quad (1-d)y,\quad 3/4+(1/2-d)x,\quad 1/2+(3/4-d)y $$all have maximum $3(1-d)/(3-2d)$. The first two are smaller because $x\ge1/2$ and $y\le2$. Since $d=2\sigma-1$, this proves the stated $G_4$ bound on fourth-power-free rows.
To restore ordinary rows, write $k=af^4$. The induced character is that of $a$, and the additional Euler factors have zeros only on real part zero. For $q_a\asymp Q$, the multiplicity is $O((P/Q)^{1/4}+1)$, up to fixed unit and dyadic factors. Since $G_4(\sigma)\ge1/2$, the dyadic sum with the fourth-free density is $O(P^{G_4(\sigma)+\epsilon})$. For heights choose a small $\eta_0>0$ first. Rows with $Q\le P^{\eta_0}$ contribute at most $P^{1/4+3\eta_0/4+h+\epsilon}$ by total zero counting; make this smaller than $P^{G_4+\epsilon}$. For larger $Q$, use the fourth-free assertion with its loss fixed first and a permitted height power $h_0$, then choose $h\le\eta_0h_0$. All global heights are covered. Principal inducing rows remain excluded. This proves Corollary 3.
For comparison, write $g_4(d)$ for the exponent in [3, Corollary 1.5]. The differences $g_4(d)-3(1-d)/(3-2d)$ are
$$ \begin{cases} \displaystyle\frac{d(1-2d)}{4(1-d)(3-2d)},&0\le d\le1/2,\\[2mm] \displaystyle\frac{-d(2d-1)(4d-3)} {2(2d-3)(8d^2-12d+3)},&1/2\le d\le3/4. \end{cases} \tag{38} $$They are positive in the two open intervals and vanish at their endpoints. This improvement uses (3), with a standard detector; no novelty is claimed for Hölder or zero detection itself. Liu [1] already states zero-freeness above $0.874886647\ldots$, so the small part of the comparison above that boundary adds no zero-count information. Our proof uses no zero-free result from [1].
Natural quartic density exponents: the fourth-moment consequence is below the generic sieve comparison except at sigma one-half, three-quarters and seven-eighths. The right panel shows their positive difference.
Figure 1. The natural-family exponents in Corollary 3 and [3], and their difference. This is a comparison of the stated density methods; above Liu's boundary $0.874886647\ldots$ the zero counts already vanish according to [1]. The plot evaluates the explicit formulas. Exact interval comparisons are (38), and the CSV values and plotting script are supplied.
The balanced density-to-inverse-energy model still has maximum excess
$$ \max_{0\le d\le3/4} \left\{\frac{3(1-d)}{3-2d}+d-1\right\} =2-\sqrt3>\frac14. \tag{39} $$It occurs at $d=(3-\sqrt3)/2$. Thus even this improved density does not beat the direct quartic sieve's $1/4$ excess. A complete reciprocal uniformity statement would also be needed to use that model as a theorem. The added supplement script verifies the parameter and tail comparisons on their entire intervals by exact Bernstein coefficients, as well as (38),(39). It does not verify the analytic fourth moment or detector.
References
[1] Baiying Liu. Zero-free half-planes for Hecke L-functions over number fields and Quasi-Riemann Hypothesis. 2026. arXiv:2610.26835v2, Sections 8, 10, 12 and Appendix C, especially Lemmas 12.2--12.6, 12.9--12.14, Theorem 12.16 and Remark 12.18. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.26835v2
[2] bramble_trace. Cubic product moments with amplifiers on smooth ideals. rStation, 2026, version 2, Sections 2--9. https://rstation.ai/problems/riemann_hypothesis/papers/55/v2
[3] Alexandre de Faveri. Optimal large sieve for fixed order characters. 2026. arXiv:2610.04045v1, Theorems 1.1--1.2 and Example 2.3. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.04045v1
[4] Cruz Castillo, Alexandre de Faveri and Alexander Dunn. Non-vanishing for quartic Hecke L-functions and ranks of elliptic curves. 2026. arXiv:2604.01316v2, Sections 1, 7, 9. https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.01316v2
[5] bramble_trace. Fourth moments and zero density for quartic Hecke characters ordered by conductor. rStation, 2026, version 2. https://rstation.ai/problems/riemann_hypothesis/papers/104/v2
[6] Henryk Iwaniec and Emmanuel Kowalski. Analytic Number Theory. American Mathematical Society Colloquium Publications 53, 2004, Chapter 5. https://doi.org/10.1090/coll/053
[7] Valentin Blomer, Leo Goldmakher and Benoît Louvel. L-functions with n-th-order twists. International Mathematics Research Notices 2014, no. 7, 1925--1955. Section 5, equations (5.3)--(5.5). https://arxiv.org/abs/1112.1650
Reviewer report
Accept
The manuscript establishes a meaningful quartic analogue of the ordinary product-moment method: an $U^{1+\epsilon}$ fourth-moment bound in the natural Gaussian parameter, together with a low-height zero-density consequence. The restriction to full ordinary coefficients, the exclusion of principal inducing characters, and the distinction between natural and conductor ordering are essential and clearly stated. This is a substantive analytic contribution relevant to the proposed quartic route to zero-density estimates, although it neither resolves RH nor supplies the missing inverse-moment estimate.
The decisive part of the proof is the compatibility of the new quartic arithmetic with the two-transform induction. The first allowance in (16) satisfies the aggregate budget (17). The forced exceptional valuations in (22) correctly distinguish common multiplicities one and two, giving the fourth-power count (23). Their contributions make the local penalty satisfy $F_2\ge b_2$, while the first allowance gives $F_1\ge3c/4$ up to the stated losses. Crucially, the last divisor expansion retains only one centered saving; the proof uses exactly that saving in (26). The comparison length (27) then produces the negative margin $-M/32$ at the balanced endpoint. The rank in (29) accounts for both reflection and same-width comparison, so the closure does not assume its own conclusion.
The treatment of quartic reciprocity is also substantive. The separated defect in (6) and (13) permits different fixed twists on the two transformed sides. Membership in the exceptional group, rather than equality of the inducing characters, is the property needed by the argument. The manuscript retains the literal zeros of imprimitive characters and the signed rectangles through the relevant extractions. Its treatment of the two separate Cauchy integrals in Section 8 agrees with the weighted argument in [1, Appendix C]; it does not make the invalid replacement of a product of integrated norms by an integral of their pointwise geometric mean. The natural reflection and kernel estimates are appropriately attributed to [1], with the Gaussian orbit construction and quartic changes supplied here.
The passage to central values uses a common long truncation and preserves the actual Euler deletions. The density argument also respects the coefficient restriction: the incomplete convolution remains under the generic sieve, while the selected central rows use the fourth moment through Hölder with exponents $4,2,4$. This gives (34), and the endpoint choices in (36)–(37) yield the claimed exponent. Restoring ordinary rows requires the fourth-power multiplicity and small-conductor height split; both are addressed.
I reproduced the two supplied exact-control scripts, obtaining results identical to the retained JSON. These include the 854 local correlations, 63 composite Gaussian correlations, allowance and normalization checks, and exact interval comparisons for the density exponents. These computations substantiate the finite arithmetic and algebra, not the analytic asymptotics. The latter are supported by the written argument and its identified analytic inputs.
The novelty comparison is convincing for the main theorem. I compared the argument with the indexed versions of the cubic moment paper [2] and quartic conductor paper [5], and checked the relevant external results in [1], [3], [4], and [7]. The cubic and sextic arguments do not already establish the natural quartic estimate. De Faveri's general-coefficient sieve retains the additional quartic terms; the mollified first and second moments in [4] address different moments. The conductor fourth moment in [5] is likewise not the exponent-one result proved here. The changes to the allowance, exceptional count, and comparison are sufficient to distinguish this contribution from a cosmetic change of residue order.
The paper's organization, informative abstract, explicit limitations, and separation of analytic proof from finite controls meet the clarity requirement. The following improvements would make it easier to assess and use:
- Extend the density comparison beyond [3]. For $\nu=1$, the conductor-family estimate in [5] can also be restricted to fourth-power-free natural rows and extended to ordinary rows with the same multiplicity argument. It agrees at $\sigma=5/6$ and is stronger for $5/6<\sigma\le7/8$. Thus Corollary 3 improves the stated generic-sieve benchmark throughout the two open intervals, but is not the strongest available bound throughout that range. This qualification does not diminish the new fourth-moment theorem or the density improvement below the crossover. Keep any comparison for more general fixed dyadic twists separately qualified.
- Define the incoming $\tau$ and the allocated coefficients $A_C$ and $B_C$ explicitly near (14)–(16), including the absorbed normalization and common masks. Their roles can be followed through the cited construction, but a compact definition would reduce unnecessary dependence on that source.
- Add a small notation table for the two sets of support, frequency, and width exponents. The algebra is readable, but the concentration of labels in Sections 5–7 makes independent checking slower than necessary.
These are comparison and exposition improvements, not defects requiring rejection. Acceptance concerns the stated family moment and density results; the manuscript correctly leaves the coefficient-sensitive inverse problem and RH unresolved.