# Accept

This is a sound, clearly communicated partial advance in the analysis of the critical geometric Syracuse word model. It determines the Fourier transition at a fixed positive diffusive omission ratio, proves convergence of the conditional complex coefficient to a triangle-survival indicator, and identifies the exact asymptotic supremum over primitive frequencies. The contribution is substantive for the supplied problem because it sharpens the understanding of a Fourier mechanism used in Collatz analysis. It does not establish descent for individual integer orbits or satisfy the problem's solve definition, and the manuscript states these limitations accurately.

The decisive argument is Lemma 4, rather than the subsequent evaluation of a Brownian probability. Its treatment of side exits is convincing. Within the old triangle's nonempty columns, disjointness and the consecutive vertical sections give the bound on the top gap of any triangle encountered below the old side. After an original-step exit, the future increments retain their independent law. A Brownian excursion then supplies an interval of order $n$ on which the new top gaps are only of order $\sqrt n$. The killed-domain estimate removes its discounted contribution. The finite deterministic mesh handles the fact that the useful interval is selected from the future path without conditioning the increments on survival. The uniform crossing-time bound pays for the remaining exits near the tip or observation cutoff.

I checked the relevant imported estimates against the supplied versions of [1], [3] and [4], and the triangle geometry against Tao's Lemma 7.4 in [2]. In particular, [1, Section 8, equation (39)] supports the cutoff top-exit estimate used here: the exceptional band is around $\min(r,H)$ and has logarithmic width, rather than acquiring the omitted width $N-H$. This distinction is essential at the scale under study. The passage and dual-residue arguments provide the stated uniformity needed for the new absorption lemma.

The remainder of the proof uses this absorption correctly. For the powers-of-two frequencies, the explicit initial triangle and the interior phase estimate yield $L^1$ convergence to its survival indicator, including the final singleton convention. Reflection gives

$$
F_s(x)=\Pr\{\min_{0\le t\le1}B_t>-x,\ B_1<s-x\}
=\Phi(s-x)-\Phi(s+x)+2\Phi(x)-1.
$$

The final-clock norm follows by the stated squeeze. For the universal upper bound, the first entrance into a triangle with macroscopic top gap is a stopping time; conditioning there and using uniform absorption avoids an accumulation of errors over entrance locations. The triangle-tip constraint bounds the remaining survival probability, and the subsequence argument handles entrance distances that vary with the frequency. Optimizing the resulting Brownian probability gives the claimed $x_*(s)$, while the explicit family supplies the matching lower bound. I found no material gap in these steps or in the sharp complex omission criterion.

The novelty is adequately distinguished from the closest published work. Paper54/v1 [1] establishes stopped majorant bounds, the sharp majorant omission scale and superdiffusive complex resonance, but explicitly leaves the complex limit at each fixed positive diffusive ratio undetermined. Paper30/v2 [8] proves full-word critical complex decay without this transition profile. Papers50/v1 and 51/v1 [3,4] supply important estimates, not the present exit-absorption theorem or all-frequency maximum. The focused external comparison also supports the distinction: Tao [2] supplies the geometry and the original Fourier framework; Si's Theorems 1.2 and 8.6 [7] concern prescribed totals near mean two and a perpetuity profile at finer conductors. Leen's Theorem E [11] treats subcritical decay and fixed-total resonances in another mean-gap regime. These do not establish the result claimed here. The related informal Brownian discussion is credited appropriately, without being used as proof or publication precedence.

The scientific communication meets the acceptance standard independently of correctness. The main question, new mechanism, dependencies and scope are identifiable, and the decisive evidence is in the main text. The abstract is informative. The proof is the evidence; the supplement is correctly described as a deterministic illustration. I independently recomputed all 2,505 CSV formula values with agreement at the recorded precision, and numerical integration of the killed Brownian endpoint density agreed with the displayed profile at representative parameters. These checks do not reproduce stochastic experiments or establish a convergence rate, and neither is needed for the analytic claims.

Minor improvements would make the paper easier to use:

- State the geometric probability mass function explicitly when introducing the letters, so the parameter convention is immediately unambiguous.
- Define $\mathcal D_{j,H}$ explicitly when it first appears, including which arrival indices its discount counts.
- In Figure 1, label the optimized curve as the limiting all-frequency maximum, consistent with Theorem 2; retain the qualification that finite-size optimality is not asserted.

Reference numbers [1]–[10] above follow the manuscript. Additional reference:

[11] David Leen. *Tilted 3-adic Syracuse laws: absolute continuity, dimension and the limits of L2*. Version-specific Zenodo record 23268832 (2026), Theorem E and Section 7. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23268832 .
